Hello all and welcome to Spice Rate 2019!!

 

Over the course of this summer , we will be conducting the Spice Girls 2019 rate. People who were on DenDen know this from the past.

 

This year we decided to do it in a different format cause all together our girls have released a lot of songs to do it in one bunch , There will be a 90s edition, a 00s editions and a 2010s edition. So 3 times more fun. The 3 editions + results will keep us entertained for the summer.

We are starting with the 90s edition!

The rules are just like any other rate One 11, one -1. should be easy.

We will do the same with the other eras and then putting all results together to which is Buzzjacks favorite Spice/solo spice song!

Get rating!

 

 

Spice Girls:

xx Wannabe

xx Say You''ll Be There

xx 2 Become 1

xx Mama

xx Who Do You Think You Are

xx Spice Up Your Life

xx Too Much

xx Stop

xx Viva Forever

xx Goodbye

 

Mel B:

xx I Want You Back

xx Word Up

 

Emma:

xx What I Am

 

Melanie C:

xx When You're Gone

xx Goin' Down

xx Northern Star

 

Geri:

xx Look At Me

xx Mi Chico Latino

xx Lift Me Up

 

A spotify playlist of this rate is here so you can listen if you want to remember a song!

Thank you for the wonderful banner Joseph *.*

 

Spice Rate :cheer:

 

Spice Girls:

10.0 Wannabe

10.0 Say You''ll Be There

10.0 2 Become 1

08.5 Mama

10.0 Who Do You Think You Are

11.0 Spice Up Your Life

10.0 Too Much

10.0 Stop

10.0 Viva Forever

10.0 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

08.0 I Want You Back

06.5 Word Up

 

Emma:

08.0 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

09.0 When You're Gone

07.0 Goin' Down

10.0 Northern Star

 

Geri:

09.5 Look At Me

10.0 Mi Chico Latino

08.0 Lift Me Up

 

#loon

Loving that banner!! :wub:

 

Spice Girls:

08 Wannabe

10 Say You''ll Be There

08 2 Become 1

07 Mama

09 Who Do You Think You Are

10 Spice Up Your Life

09 Too Much

09 Stop

11 Viva Forever

05 Goodbye

 

'Viva Forever' is my 3rd favourite song of all time so no competition here <3 seeing it performed live at Wembley was an ultimate life highlight :wub: 'Goodbye' is a real outlier here, I've always appreciated the sentiment but as a song I just find it quite dull oops. Otherwise, very strong!

 

Mel B:

08 I Want You Back

03 Word Up

 

'I Want You Back' is my favourite song she released so I'm glad it's the #1 in her discography. The 'Word Up' cover is so bad, Timbaland production aside :')

 

Emma:

08 What I Am

 

I only learned that this was a cover a few years ago :o a really cool direction initially for Emma but she definitely bettered it over the years.

 

Melanie C:

10 When You're Gone

08 Goin' Down

08 Northern Star

 

Melanie was on fire right now and we haven't even reached her best solo songs yet. 'When You're Gone' is such a strong duet :wub: I find 'Goin' Down' underrated amongst the fans (it surprises me how high it peaked in the UK though for what it is! Spice hype I guess) - almost gave it a 9 actually. A weird initial direction to look back on in terms of commercial appeal! I sometimes forget that 'Never Be The Same Again' wasn't actually her debut. That feels like the true moment when her solo career slotted into place.

 

Geri:

08 Look At Me

10 Mi Chico Latino

04 Lift Me Up

 

'Mi Chico Latino' is my favourite Geri song for sure :wub: 'Look At Me' was a very fun debut from her - if only it peaked at #1 like many of her others. I've never been able to warm to 'Lift Me Up', her vocals in the final chorus feel quite strained in particular.

Spice Girls:

09 Wannabe

09 Say You''ll Be There

09 2 Become 1

07 Mama

08 Who Do You Think You Are

08 Spice Up Your Life

09 Too Much

10 Stop

08 Viva Forever

09 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

07 I Want You Back

06 Word Up

 

Emma:

05 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

11 When You're Gone

07 Goin' Down

09 Northern Star

 

Geri:

09 Look At Me

08 Mi Chico Latino

07 Lift Me Up

:cheer: YYAAYYYY thank you for this :wub:

 

Spice Girls:

07 Wannabe

11 Say You''ll Be There

10 2 Become 1

02 Mama

10 Who Do You Think You Are

10 Spice Up Your Life

10 Too Much

10 Stop

10 Viva Forever

10 Goodbye

 

Not many groups could say that they released mostly excellent singles that have stood the test of time. Mama is the sour point in their 90s group discography, in my opinion!

 

Mel B:

10 I Want You Back

10 Word Up

 

Mel B wins, hands down, the best debut and follow up solo singles! Two excellent tracks with excellent videos! Deserved better in the charts though. Shame about Hot, it was a mess of an album for what promised to be a really interesting pop artist.

 

Emma:

06 What I Am

 

Not the greatest of starts for Bunton tbh. Im soooo glad she got much better with her second and third album!!

 

Melanie C:

06 When You're Gone

06 Goin' Down

08 Northern Star

 

I got bored of WYG quite quickly tbh, but Northern Star continues to be excellent. Going Down is not terrible just a bit too random and a bit lame attempt at 'rock' lol

 

Geri:

02 Look At Me

04 Mi Chico Latino

-1 Lift Me Up

 

Never really got the whole Geri music thing. People keep saying that her first album is the 3rd Spice Girls album that never was, but I always thought it was a bit shit to be honest. All the ballads are just tacky and the uptempos are not that much better, in my opinion. Bag It Up is basically a cheap version of Who Do You Think You Are, Look At Me is cheap narcisistic drama, and her voice is terrible throughout.... Lift Me Up had to be the worst single ever released by one of them....

 

 

Edited July 12, 20196 yr by Mr.X

Spice Girls:

08.5 Wannabe

10.0 Say You''ll Be There

10.0 2 Become 1

09.5 Mama

07.0 Who Do You Think You Are

09.0 Spice Up Your Life

08.0 Too Much

06.0 Stop

11.0 Viva Forever

10.0 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

05.0 I Want You Back

03.0 Word Up

 

Emma:

07.0 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

08.0 When You're Gone

07.0 Goin' Down

09.0 Northern Star

 

Geri:

09.0 Look At Me

09.5 Mi Chico Latino

09.0 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

10 Wannabe

10 Say You''ll Be There

10 2 Become 1

08 Mama

10 Who Do You Think You Are

10 Spice Up Your Life

10 Too Much

10 Stop

11 Viva Forever

09 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

08 I Want You Back

05 Word Up

 

Emma:

06 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

10 When You're Gone

06 Goin' Down

10 Northern Star

 

Geri:

09 Look At Me

10 Mi Chico Latino

07 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

07.5 Wannabe

10.0 Say You''ll Be There

08.5 2 Become 1

07.5 Mama

09.5 Who Do You Think You Are

10.0 Spice Up Your Life

10.0 Too Much

08.5 Stop

11.0 Viva Forever

10.0 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

08.0 I Want You Back

07.5 Word Up

 

Emma:

08.5 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

07.0 When You're Gone

07.5 Goin' Down

08.0 Northern Star

 

Geri:

10.0 Look At Me

10.0 Mi Chico Latino

10.0 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

07 Wannabe

05 Say You''ll Be There

06 2 Become 1

02 Mama

08 Who Do You Think You Are

08 Spice Up Your Life

04 Too Much

05 Stop

08 Viva Forever

05 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

05 I Want You Back

03 Word Up

 

Emma:

07 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

06 When You're Gone

04 Goin' Down

04 Northern Star

 

Geri:

03 Look At Me

04 Mi Chico Latino

04 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

08 Wannabe

07 Say You''ll Be There

09 2 Become 1

06 Mama

08 Who Do You Think You Are

11 Spice Up Your Life

04 Too Much

09 Stop

09 Viva Forever

10 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

08 I Want You Back

05 Word Up

 

Emma:

06 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

08 When You're Gone

09 Goin' Down

09 Northern Star

 

Geri:

08 Look At Me

06 Mi Chico Latino

-1 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

09 Wannabe

10 Say You''ll Be There

10 2 Become 1

08 Mama

10 Who Do You Think You Are

10 Spice Up Your Life

08 Too Much

08 Stop

10 Viva Forever

10 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

09 I Want You Back

02 Word Up

 

Emma:

06 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

09 When You're Gone

-1 Goin' Down

10 Northern Star

 

Geri:

10 Look At Me

11 Mi Chico Latino

08 Lift Me Up

 

Spice Girls:

07 Wannabe

08 Say You''ll Be There

10 2 Become 1

03 Mama

10 Who Do You Think You Are

04 Spice Up Your Life

06 Too Much

10 Stop

10 Viva Forever

03 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

01 I Want You Back

03 Word Up

 

Emma:

02 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

05 When You're Gone

-1 Goin' Down

04 Northern Star

 

Geri:

10 Look At Me

10 Mi Chico Latino

11 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

09 Wannabe

10 Say You''ll Be There

10 2 Become 1

07 Mama

10 Who Do You Think You Are

9 Spice Up Your Life

08 Too Much

10 Stop

10 Viva Forever

10 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

05 I Want You Back

06 Word Up

 

Emma:

-1 What I Am

 

Melanie C :

08 When You're Gone

05 Goin' Down

09 Northern Star

 

Geri:

10 Look At Me

11 Mi Chico Latino

10 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:
10 Wannabe
11 Say You''ll Be There
10 2 Become 1
08 Mama
10 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
10 Stop
10 Viva Forever
10 Goodbye

Mel B:
10 I Want You Back
04 Word Up

Emma:
08 What I Am

Melanie C:
10 When You're Gone
06 Goin' Down
09 Northern Star

Geri:
10 Look At Me
10 Mi Chico Latino
10 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

08.0 Wannabe

11.0 Say You''ll Be There

10.0 2 Become 1

07.5 Mama

09.5 Who Do You Think You Are

10.0 Spice Up Your Life

09.0 Too Much

09.0 Stop

10.0 Viva Forever

09.0 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

08.5 I Want You Back

07.5 Word Up

 

Emma:

07.5 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

09.0 When You're Gone

06.5 Goin' Down

10.0 Northern Star

 

Geri:

07.0 Look At Me

10.0 Mi Chico Latino

06.5 Lift Me Up

 

I've attempted to be more critical with this rate, to indicate an order of preference. But it's very hard to give low scores to such iconic pop moments.

Spice Girls:

09.0 Wannabe

10.0 Say You''ll Be There

11.0 2 Become 1

09.0 Mama

09.0 Who Do You Think You Are

09.0 Spice Up Your Life

07.0 Too Much

08.0 Stop

08.0 Viva Forever

09.0 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

07.0 I Want You Back

05.0 Word Up

 

Emma:

08.0 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

08.0 When You're Gone

04.0 Goin' Down

07.0 Northern Star

 

Geri:

07.0 Look At Me

08.0 Mi Chico Latino

06.0 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

08 Wannabe

11 Say You''ll Be There

10 2 Become 1

09 Mama

10 Who Do You Think You Are

10 Spice Up Your Life

10 Too Much

10 Stop

06 Viva Forever

09 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

04 I Want You Back

08 Word Up

 

Emma:

07 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

08 When You're Gone

03 Goin' Down

06 Northern Star

 

Geri:

10 Look At Me

10 Mi Chico Latino

10 Lift Me Up

Spice Girls:

10 Wannabe

09 Say You'll Be There

09 2 Become 1

05 Mama

11 Who Do You Think You Are

09 Spice Up Your Life

10 Too Much

05 Stop

05 Viva Forever

09 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

09 I Want You Back

04 Word Up

 

Emma:

06 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

07 When You're Gone

07 Goin' Down

08 Northern Star

 

Geri:

09 Look At Me

08 Mi Chico Latino

06 Lift Me Up

17 rates so far, thank you!

Spice Girls:

08 Wannabe

06 Say You''ll Be There

09 2 Become 1

05 Mama

10 Who Do You Think You Are

11 Spice Up Your Life

06 Too Much

08 Stop

10 Viva Forever

10 Goodbye

 

Mel B:

07 I Want You Back

03 Word Up

 

Emma:

07 What I Am

 

Melanie C:

10 When You're Gone

07 Goin' Down

10 Northern Star

 

Geri:

03 Look At Me

03 Mi Chico Latino

03 Lift Me Up

Edited July 16, 20196 yr by pippa