Transexual shock as Janet promises to get her "guitar" out haha

Janet - I quite liked that, but I wasn't overly mad about it. You could tell she was really trying hard though, to do the best she could basically.

Janet & Frankie back to back really is suicide inspiring stuff.

I thought that was better than last week (which on reflection I overrated). Still nowhere near as good as 'Fix You' though, the vocals were a bit off in parts. And FOR GOD SAKE DO AN UPTEMPO. Still my favourite of the night so far but only barely.

 

2011 rates (week 4)

8.5 Janet Devlin - Every Breath You Take

8.5 Johnny Robinson - That Ole Devil Called Love

7.5 Marcus Collins - Superstition

7.0 The Risk - Thriller

6.5 Misha B - Tainted Love

4.0 Sophie Habibis - Bang Bang (My Baby Shot Me Down)

Janet & Frankie back to back really is suicide inspiring stuff.

 

Too true.

Question: Should I Stay Or Should I Go?

Answer: Go.

probably my least performance from princess janet, although still the best of the night so far. the performances tonight have so far been lacking, they're all just completely void of energy.

I can see kitty being the best of the night tonight if I'm honest.

You do understand that the producers direct everything that's said in these VTs right? That's what she's been told to talk about... she has no choice in the matter.

 

 

 

Pfft, her personality in any interviews is that of a drip.

How many more songs are there for Frankie to talk his way through (badly)?

For Frankie: They would expect someone who doesn't treat his mentor, Gary Barlow like cr*p. And act like a prat every day.

Edited October 29, 201113 yr by ukchartstatsfan

LOVING the INXS backing track here, I love that track anyway. I think Marcus is becoming more and more of a front runner each week. Another absolutely brilliant performance from him them.

 

Silas Rates - Week 4

 

Marcus - 10/10

Sophie - 9/10

Johnny - 8/10

The Risk - 5/10

Eurgh mankie frankie. Completely without vocal talent.

Erugh I really hope he is out tomorow

Frankie - 4.0

He definitely should go tomorrow. Bye bye, freak person. It wasn't that bad tonight though. Still my least fave left in the competition.

 

 

Johnny - 8.5

Sophie - 8.0

Marcus - 7.5

Janet - 7.0

Misha B - 7.0

The Risk - 5.5

Frankie - 4.0

Frankie - I'm bored of him. He's barely got a singing voice.

Marcus - One of my favourite performances from his so far! A weird song choice on first glance, but his vocals and the performance made that seem pointless. He's really coming out as one of my surprise favourites of the competition. 9/10

Misha - I still dislike her as a person, but that was a good performance. Not the best song choice, and the rap was very cringeworthy (like all of her self-written raps), but she did it well. 8/10

Sophie - Not her best performance, but again it was very good vocally. I was just disappointed that she didn't go into the dance breakdown of the mid-noughties remix. 7.5/10

The Risk - Alright performance from them - a lot worse than last week's, but that was pretty special. I also felt the chemistry seemed to dissolve with the addition of Ashford. 7/10

Johnny - I will never like a performance of his. I dislike his singing voice, although his personality is growing on me, and vocally - it was a good performance. 5/10

Janet - Very flat performance. I really liked the arrangement, but she didn't sing it well at all. Such a let down after last week's performance, which was my favourite of hers by far. 4/10

Frankie - Abysmal. 0/10

Frankie - Instant 0/10 because of the entrance. The performance itself? Terrifying. 0/10

 

The Frankie I saw in the auditions has completely vanished. He always seemed like a ladies man (and that was perfectly fine), but now he's just dirty.

 

 

Misha - 9/10

Johnny - 8/10

Sophie - 8/10

Marcus - 7/10

Janet - 6.5/10

The Risk - 2/10

Frankie - 0/10

 

THANK YOU ALEXANDRA, THANK YOU FOR SPEAKING THE TRUTH ABOUT THIS f***er FOR ONCE.

Frankie Cacossa - Should I Stay Or I Go

 

DEAR GOD at the start of this performance. I just don't think I will EVER like anything Frankie sings. He sounds bored to death when he sings, and ultimately it makes me feel bored having to listen to it. Also, if Frankie was "real" then he wouldn't be going on The X Factor to be a rebellious rock icon. Smacks of stageschool student acting hard. Ha!!!

 

Misha B = 9/10

Marcus Collins = 8/10

Sophie Habibis = 7/10

Johnny Robinson = 6/10

Janet Devlin 4/10

The Risk = 4/10

Frankie Cacossa = 3/10

He gave a good performance for him. Still want him out far more than anyone else left. Hence 3/10, it wasn't THAT enjoyable.

 

Misha 9/10

Janet 8/10

Johnny 6/10

Sophie 5/10

The Risk 5/10

Marcus 4/10

Frankie 3/10