I find it funny how Gary criticises Johnny saying it's all about the singing. Let's see what he says after Frankie performs.

 

Pot. Kettle. Black.

I actually thought that was really good! My favourite performance from him so far :D

I really don't understand the Johnny love. Nothing more than a novelty act

I find it funny how Gary criticises Johnny saying it's all about the singing. Let's see what he says after Frankie performs.

 

Pot. Kettle. Black.

 

 

That's a large part of the reason I'm finding Gary an awful judge.

Janet on right at the start AGAIN? Why are they doing this?!

Ooh Janet on early, it would be amazing if she was at risk as a result.

Yes, Janet, this is what I wanted to see you do! Nice change, and her voice is sounding better too.

Did she just forget the words? HA

GURL GOT SWAG.

 

Did she just forget the words there for a second? Woah, that's some performance! A bit shaky at the start, but really good overall :wub:

This is terrible.

Janet - 7.5

It was good to see her singing some upbeat tune. I can't see her in the bottom 2 (or 3) this week.

 

 

Janet - 7.5

Johnny - 7.0

She looks crushed! HA, take that you little cow.

Twat again, Gary. You said the opposite of that last week. Urgh, I'm glad I don't take this show seriously anymore.

Absolutely HORRIFIC performance from Johnny. Very, very strange man. 0/10

I actually really liked Janet's performance. You could tell she was out of her "comfort zone", but I liked that it wasn't her standing still singing an uninspired ballad. 7.5/10

 

-- Janet

-- Johnny

Glad she's finally doing something uptempo. I loved that, probably my second favourite of hers so far (although still not as good as 'Fix You', I doubt she's going to top that). I have a bad feeling they're trying to make her the week 5 shock exit though :(

 

Rates 2011 (week 5)

9.5 Janet Devlin - I Want You Back

6.5 Johnny Robinson - Hung Up / You Spin Me Round (Like A Record)

Janet - I don't agree with Tulisa, I thought Janet seemed more comfortable this week than she has any week previous actually and she got to show off her personality better too. Last week Janet was painfully uncomfortable and it showed. It was a nice fun performance. It wasn't amazing...but very good. 8/10

 

Janet - 8/10

Johnny - 5/10

Edited November 5, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf

Craig and dancefloor fillers in the same sentence?

Janet - I really enjoyed that, big improvement from last week, even with the slip-up.

love how positive she is after the performance which was her worst so far indeed!

Janet - 0 - utterly dreadful, forgot the words and sounded piss weak throughout. Bottom 3 please.