Look at him with his TINIE TEMPAH glasses.

The Risk 8.0

I really hate this song. They sang it very well though. What about the rap part? They want (need) chavs votes of course. :D

 

 

The Risk - 8.0

Janet - 7.5

Johnny - 7.0

Craig - 5.0

 

That was OK, not their best but better than last week for sure.

I'm not bothering with comments per perfomance unless I feel they're worthy of them. So here's my ranking so far.

 

Craig 8/10

The Risk 5/10

Janet 4/10

Johnny 3/10

Poor rest of the Risk.

Return to form for them (although I don't think they were that bad last week). They're definitely the best group XF has ever put together. The rap bit wasn't too invasive like most other 'rap bits' in XF performances.

 

Rates 2011 (week 5)

9.0 Janet Devlin - I Want You Back

8.5 The Risk - A Night To Remember

7.5 Craig Colton - Heaven

6.5 Johnny Robinson - Hung Up / You Spin Me Round (Like A Record)

Edited November 5, 201113 yr by Bré

06 The Risk

04 Johnny

04 Craig

00 Janet

Craig had the best performance so far, brilliant 9/10

 

Risk, not too sure it sounded a bit karoake unless Hits was listening to a plank of wood 4/10

Wow, that was great, miles better than the last couple of weeks. WTF is Gary on tonight?

 

RATES:

The Risk - 9.0

Craig - 8.0

Johnny - 5.5

Janet - 2.0

Janet was awful - I really am confused how anyone could think otherwise.

Absolutely HORRIFIC performance from Johnny. Very, very strange man. 0/10

I actually really liked Janet's performance. You could tell she was out of her "comfort zone", but I liked that it wasn't her standing still singing an uninspired ballad. 7.5/10

Craig SMASHED IT. A really good song choice from him - I was worried that he'd sing it as a ballad throughout, but when it kicked in it was SO GOOD. My favourite performance from him so far. 10/10

The Risk really managed to turn it around this week. A much better choice of song than their Hallowe'en effort, and that style really suits them. 10/10

 

-- The Risk

-- Craig

-- Janet

-- Johnny

Anyone else think that if they're gonna push the 'Charlie's the lead singer' thing, they may as well have just let the Keys through?

"Charlie is the lead singer"

 

I hate how there has to be a "lead". They did the same with Aston and JLS.. basically having him sing 99% of the song and the rest were back up singers

Good performance by the Risk. Not sure if the rap worked.

 

Who the hell does Tulisa and Gary they are?

They b*ched about Janet wanting her to sing in a different style so she does and gets critcised and told to back to her original style. and reduce her to tears.

8.0 The Risk ~ Best perf in weeks. Good vocally (still room for improvement) and they look like a group again.

8.0 Craig ~ Again his best in a while. Nice to see him switch it up a bit and he really is a very likable performer.

7.4 Johnny ~ Hung Up was crap. You Spin Me Round was great. He should sing in his lower register more often.

4.6 Janet ~ Good start but she lost it when she forgot the words and never got it back. Some shocking vocals during the final minute.

 

Janet was awful - I really am confused how anyone could think otherwise.

well we do? :)

well we do? :)

No offense (and I know you get stick for being a Janet fan), but are you truly being objective?

06 The Risk

04 Johnny

04 Craig

00 Janet

 

Boy, you're so demanding. ^_^

I was going to comment about how Janet was utterly dreadful, but then I saw the word 'objective' and thought better of it.

well we do? :)

I haven't read this whole topic but are you serious? You liked Janet? Do you even know the meaning of objectivity?