You really are quite ridiculous. The caller was speaking at Gary for the majority of the phone call, how on earth was Kelly meant to find the question hidden in there. And it's not as if Kelly said it in a "miserable" voice either... :rolleyes:

It was a comment about her in general and not just about the caller

 

I find she takes things too seriously. My opinion. Don't really see how that's "ridiculous" and :rolleyes:

01 Little Mix - If I Were A Boy

02 Misha B - Perfect

03 Amelia Lily - Ain't No Mountain High Enough

04 Little Mix - Keep Me Hanging On

05 Amelia Lily - I'm With You

06 Misha B - Dancing In The Street

 

I skipped Marcus' performances on itv player lmao. I do like him but Gary is a f***ing AWFUL mentor and judge - only praises his own act who hes turn into a complete bore and tries to make all the others look awful with deluded pathetic comments - Little Mix's vocals weren't perfect? They were the best they've been with 'Don't Let Go' ... everyone else forgot about Misha's bullying thing but he decided to bring it up again and thinks Amelia needs to find her softer vocals, errrm whut?

 

Seriously he defines f***ing PRICK. I'd have Cheryl, Dannii, Sharon or Simon over him ANY DAY. Seriously hope Marcus doesn't win and Little Mix do now just because his ego deserves a bruising.

 

Amelia was surprisingly great tonight after I've been off with her the past two weeks, Misha was amazing on her 'Perfect' performance which I didn't think would suit her at all but she really pulled it off! Little Mix were both really good in both performances, 'If I Were A Boy' being their best along with 'Don't Let Go' (and I f***ing HATE 'If I Were A Boy'). Tulisa was amazing in her little breakdown - more reason why I want Little Mix to win!

Amelia really can suck the emotion out of EVERYTHING. She needs to go.

4 new judges next year please! Nevermind how poor they've been as judges, I can't really get over how terrible they've been as mentors! Tulisa has done alright with Little Mix but lost potential winners The Risk through crap song choices. The others have just been rubbish, especially Gary, he's had a nightmare.

 

4 big stars who can sing would be nice. Might be hard to get them onboard after they see how Gary's come across though.

4 new judges next year please! Nevermind how poor they've been as judges, I can't really get over how terrible they've been as mentors! Tulisa has done alright with Little Mix but lost potential winners The Risk through crap song choices. The others have just been rubbish, especially Gary, he's had a nightmare.

 

4 big stars who can sing would be nice. Might be hard to get them onboard after they see how Gary's come across though.

I just don't agree that The Risk's song choices were crap. To be put together, then to lose a member, then to gain a member less then 48 hours before the live shows they weren't going to create a solid connection and fanbase.

I think that this week's X factor was the nail in the coffin. It was so unbelievably dull and uninspired. Motown is such an awful theme and has absolutely no relevance with the current record buying public. Then the songs to get them into the final were equally yawn-tastic. I just find it hard to care about anyone...contestants and judges.

 

I think the final is going to be such an overblown borefest with lots of shots of the audience at Wembley to show how BIG everything is.

 

I think the x factor is dead.

10.0 Little Mix (1) // INCREDIBLE. I don't even fucking care that the red one forgot a couple of words. It was outstanding. Louis, Kelly and Gary - kindly go and jump off a cliff.

08.5 Marcus (2) // So much better second time around.

08.0 Little Mix (2) // Didn't think it worked 100%. The fat one grimaced too much. I was afraid Tulisa would KILL SOMEBODY while having that speech. *.*

08.0 Misha (1) // THE FUCK IS SHE WEARING?!

07.5 Misha (2) // Will Louis please change his comments to something ELSE? ANYTHING.

06.0 Marcus (1) // That was incredibly boring even if the song really suit him.

05.5 Amelia Lily (1) // That was mediocre. Judges keep being deaf, as always.

01.0 Amelia Lily (2) // Vocally it was just terrible. Emotion was fake as hell. My cat can sing better. Gary speaks sense. Her "thank you" to Gary's comment looked like OH f*** YOU, I DON'T CARE, I'MMA GO N THROW UP NOW. Janet's 'Mmmbop' looks like a masterpiece comparing to this.

 

Averages:

09.00 Little Mix

07.75 Misha

07.25 Marcus

03.25 Amelia Lily

 

Totals:

29.5 Round 1

25.0 Round 2

 

I think it's obvious, if there will be bottom 2 this week, Misha and Amelia are there.

01 Little Mix - If I Were A Boy

02 Misha B - Perfect

03 Amelia Lily - Ain't No Mountain High Enough

04 Little Mix - Keep Me Hanging On

05 Amelia Lily - I'm With You

06 Misha B - Dancing In The Street

 

I skipped Marcus' performances on itv player lmao. I do like him but Gary is a f***ing AWFUL mentor and judge - only praises his own act who hes turn into a complete bore and tries to make all the others look awful with deluded pathetic comments - Little Mix's vocals weren't perfect? They were the best they've been with 'Don't Let Go' ... everyone else forgot about Misha's bullying thing but he decided to bring it up again and thinks Amelia needs to find her softer vocals, errrm whut?

 

Seriously he defines f***ing PRICK. I'd have Cheryl, Dannii, Sharon or Simon over him ANY DAY. Seriously hope Marcus doesn't win and Little Mix do now just because his ego deserves a bruising.

 

Amelia was surprisingly great tonight after I've been off with her the past two weeks, Misha was amazing on her 'Perfect' performance which I didn't think would suit her at all but she really pulled it off! Little Mix were both really good in both performances, 'If I Were A Boy' being their best along with 'Don't Let Go' (and I f***ing HATE 'If I Were A Boy'). Tulisa was amazing in her little breakdown - more reason why I want Little Mix to win!

 

Pretty much all of this. Little Mix's performances are the only ones I didn't skip through at all and even though I'd prefer it if they didn't win and did a JLS, I kinda want them to know just to spite Gary. But then they'll probably have an awful winners single.

 

& Jesy needs to sort her singing face out.

Well, I watched last night at a mate's house and admittedly we tried out my XF drinking game so were bladdered by the time Little Mix first got on the stage. I thought everyone was decent, Marcus was probably the most average. They were out to get Little Mix and Amelia last night and I think they've sabotaged their own efforts to boost Misha with Gary bringing up the bullying again for no reason whatsoever.

 

Gary remains the biggest twat ever. Saying the Perri is the main vocalist and making her look extremely uncomfortable on stage during the feedback-is he trying to piss the rest of the group off? Disregarding Louis's fair comments as if their not important and then despite all three judges agreeing he says he 'speaks for the audience and the plublic' that Marcus's perf was AMAZING when it clearly wasn't. He won't be back next year. He takes it too seriously and it's obviously stressing him out. Plus I think he may have found out that being 'Head Judge' means absolutely f**k all.

 

Kelly missing her cue to introduce Amelia was hilarious. Luckily my mate had sky plus so we could watch it back, pause on her shocked face, take a picture with my phone, and upload it as my Facebook profile pic.

Not really bothered who goes out tonight, they still get a record deal of some sort, coming 4th is not a big deal, hoping Misha to leave tonight, she be back next year with a single around this time next year. I be surprised if its Little Mix, their performances weren't that great.

 

Gary really annoyed me last night, he only gave positive comments to Marcus, and decided to blank out the other acts by having digs.

Oh marcus completely messed up on his second song. His first song might have been boring to some but from being through music college. His phrasing, dynamics etc was spot on. Little mix were great on both though not extremely fantastic. Misha as much as i dont like her she did really well vocally on the first. Why oh why do perfect though. Amelia was my fave tonight. Delivered on both. Hopefully Mishas time is up though. Gary please do us all a favour and F""" off and never come back to judge thankyou.

Edited December 4, 201113 yr by Rob Summers

My rankings for this week:

 

1. Amelia Lily

2. Misha B

3. Marcus Collins

4. Little Mix

 

Kelly's girls really delivered last night.

 

Marcus gave two middle of the road performances. His song choices were unfortunate and the vocals weren't perfect, especially on the second song.

 

Little Mix bombed last night - both performances were bad.

1. Misha B

2. Amelia Lily

3. Little Mix

4. Marcus Collins

 

Marcus' second song was really bad. I can't BELIEVE the judges didn't pick up on Leigh-Anne forgetting her words in the first Little Mix performance.

The Motown perfs varied between bland and downright horrible so I've disregarded those and pretended they all only sang the free choice songs. Misha was excellent, not quite her best vocal but full of genuine emotion. Marcus did what he needed to which was break away from his norm and turn his hand at something new... It wasn't his best but I think it was enough. Assuming he makes it through though I'd like him to pull out something extraordinary for the final, he's had fewer 'moments' than Little Mix or Misha. Little Mix were fantastic and managed to make a bleh song enjoyable for me, no small ask. Gary was being very sneaky and tactical with his criticisms. There's no need to push Perrie to the front, they can all sing. Leigh-Anne surprised me, it was her best vocal yet, and Jade was legit amazing.

 

Amelia's time is up now. She seriously lagged behind the others. However as with last week Gary is wrong, her soft singing voice is much better than her belting voice which is ten a penny and painful to listen to.

I am going to spoiler this as X Factor tracker gathers all positive/negative comments from all social networking sites, and shows who is the most popular from last night. It has been correct in predicting the bottom two most times during the series, and even put The Risk at the bottom the week they went, so incase anyone moans I will spoiler it:

 

X Factor Tracker results:

 

 

1. Little Mix

2. Amelia Lily

3. Misha Bryan

4. Marcus Collins

 

A SHOCK EXIT? I HOPE SO

 

Edited December 4, 201113 yr by Davidson

06.5 • Misha B • Dancing In The Street • Solid enough but nothing particularly exciting for me. Vocally okay as she didn't try to show off too much.

07.5 • Amelia Lily • Ain't No Mountain High Enough • I thought she did well with this, kept her vocal together nicely and didn't get totally drowned out by the choir.

06.0 • Little Mix • You Keep Me Hanging On • This didn't really work for me, aside from the timing issues and forgetting lyrics it was just a really flat performance by their standards.

07.0 • Marcus • My Girl • I don't really like the song at all but his vocal was pretty good.

 

04.0 • Misha B • Perfect • I thought this was painful to listen to, am really surprised so many of you seem to have loved it. It was all so overwrought and desperate, probably her worst performance for me.

07.5 • Amelia Lily • I'm With You • Solid week for her, this was a better song choice than Perfect would have been for her anyway imo.

02.0 • Marcus • Can You Feel It • Dreadful. The staging was dire, he didn't appear to be able to even hold the tune and he just looked uncomfortable. No idea why as it's not that far removed from the things he was doing well a few weeks back but it was the worst performance of the night by far.

07.5 • Little Mix • If I Were A Boy • An improvement from them but still not amazing. The blonde one really is the best singer but she seemed to be feeling like she had to compensate for the others, I prefer them when they sang things like E.T. and Don't Let Go as there was more harmony/unison in the vocal. Still want them to win though so I hope they get through...

 

 

Totals:

15.0 • Amelia Lily

13.5 • Little Mix

10.5 • Misha B

09.0 • Marcus

Amelia on top. Oh Dandy :no:

The odd thing is that I really don't care for Amelia that much. In terms of my general liking of them it goes Little Mix > Misha B > Marcus/Amelia but the others really lowered their game this week I thought.

I disagree I think Misha and Amelia were the only two that lifted their game and showed they want to get to the finals no matter what. I could not fault thier performances although the stylists need to be shot. The fact that X-factor needs to pump out an act that can do consistently well should ensure Misha and Amelia both make the final. Its a shame that most years X factor cranks out a substandard winner that slips into obscurity never to be seen again (Alexandra and Leona aside).

8.7 Misha B (2)

7.9 Little Mix (2)

7.1 Marcus (1)

6.8 Little Mix (1)

6.4 Amelia (1)

6.3 Marcus (2)

5.9 Misha B (1)

4.0 Amelia (2)

 

Have to disagree with r Dand, Misha's second performance was by far and away the best of the night (the rap-like verses WERE particularly good) and I only really enjoyed the top 3. Nobody had their best week by a long way so it's pretty much wide open for tonightt.

 

Amelia was actually more on form than she'd ever been this week but that didn't stop her from being PAINFUL. It seems like she has practically no range and Misha's Perfect was a MASTERCLASS in emotional singing compared to the dry version of I'm With You she churned out. I really wish I liked her but I just can't. Still want Little Mix to win yeaa

 

OVERALL

 

Little Mix - 7.4

Misha - 7.3

Marcus - 6.7

Amelia - 5.2