Which is your favourite line-up?

For quality of music I'd say Keisha, Heidi & Mutya but K, H & Amelle would run close because of About You Now, Denial, Change etc. The recent line up hasn't really done much apart from About A Girl which was decent. Nothing came out of them that lived up to past material.

 

So Heidi, Keisha & Mutya :D

Edited May 16, 201213 yr by Rob Summers

Keisha/Heidi/Amelle for me. Catfights & Spotlights and Change are my favourite Sugababes albums (with Taller In More Ways close behind).

Sugababe's version two were one of the best groups around.

Unpopular opinion, but Heidi/Amelle/Jade for me. I loved Freedom and the Sweet 7 album and I wished we had got to hear more of their new material! :D

Of course I do like tracks from previous eras too, but I loved a lot from this line-up despite only being 1 album and Freedom.

Of course the second line-up and I'm not surprised they are so far ahead in the poll.

I want those days back when Keisha, Heidi and Mutya were on top of things. They had a great spark together. The first line-up also had something special but they don't have the long string of memorable hits with them.

The second line-up of course. For me, they WERE the Sugababes, Siobhan was dispensable and easily replaced. Obviously the other two weren't as replaceable, but 3.0 had some pretty good songs too.

Change is my favourite album of theirs, but my fave line up would be Mutya, Keisha and Heidi.

3 for me! 'Change' is one of my favourite pop albums and 'About You Now' and 'Easy' are my two favourite Suga singles.

The second line-up of course. For me, they WERE the Sugababes, Siobhan was dispensable and easily replaced. Obviously the other two weren't as replaceable, but 3.0 had some pretty good songs too.

 

True as that may be, 'Ghosts' is still far better than any of their albums.

Round Round, Hole In The Head & Too Lost in You are amongst my favourite Sugababes songs, all of which came from V2, the only thing that would even come close is About You Now by V3, but they weren't so great that aside, the one that came after that is a joke to say the least and I don't actually remember much material from V1, so its no contest really...

If Siobhan had stayed and they'd continued together, I do imagine they wouldn't have had much commercial success and would have probably split a few years later anyway. Although the music they did release would surely have been amazing.

 

But 2.0 is the obvious answer. They just had such a good synergy, musically at least. Some of Heidi's middle-8s are among the best pop moments of the '00s. Nothing from 3.0 ever lived up to 2.0's releases - even 'About You Now' was always a bit too clean for me.

We have a Sugababes forum here: http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/Sugababes-Forum-f32.html It's been there forever. So can a PopMod/GM/Admin move this there please?

 

 

 

For the record it's all about 2.0.

The 2nd line up were the proper sugababes.

2.0 for me! :wub:

Oh wow I didn't expect 2.0 to be THAT dominant in the poll :lol: Voted for them of course, I've never been a huge Sugababes fan but that line-up had by far the best singles.

http://www.dingsme.info/avatar13.jpgCatfights & Spotlights and Change are my favourite Sugababes albums

We have a Sugababes forum here: http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/Sugababes-Forum-f32.html It's been there forever. So can a PopMod/GM/Admin move this there please?

For the record it's all about 2.0.

 

I posted it here because it seemed on-topic, and because far more people would see it than if it was 'lost' on an artist-specific forum.

 

Regards,

 

PS, like nearly everyone else, I prefer v2.

 

Sorry Phil, but I also think it'd get lost in our forum. :lol: Maybe when the topic dies down a bit we can move it to Suga forum.

 

My answer: OBVIOUSLY 2.0. Then 1.0 -> 3.0 -> 4.0.

True as that may be, 'Ghosts' is still far better than any of their albums.

That's irrelevant really since that is not a Sugababes album and her contribution to the Sugababes was 1/7 of their output.

 

We have a Sugababes forum here: http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/Sugababes-Forum-f32.html It's been there forever. So can a PopMod/GM/Admin move this there please?

For the record it's all about 2.0.

There's no way this would have got 40 votes in the Sugababes forum. It's probably better off in here...