October 1, 20168 yr I would have put one of the girl bands (4oD) through instead of the two muppets, it would have put the bands on even par...
October 1, 20168 yr Yeah. The girls are so BLAND and "seen it all before (and better)" this year! Gifty is the only one I can see doing something in the final (but even she comes off as pretty generic), but I can't see her winning, or coming anywhere near the final 3!
October 1, 20168 yr Loved Gifty's performance she sang something current, I pick Gifty, Olivia and Emily for the finals.
October 1, 20168 yr Caitlyn forgetting her words :( such a shame, what a fantastic voice she has :heart: Emily and particularly Gifty were superb, what an inspired song choice for the latter! :o Best performance of judges' houses so far this year.
October 1, 20168 yr Samantha probably the best one there actually. If he puts her, Gifty & Olivia through I'd be satisfied.
October 1, 20168 yr This is pretty difficult to call! Any of Caitlyn, Gifty, Samantha and Emily could make it, I THINK. Gifty, Samantha and Emily for me.
October 1, 20168 yr I forgot about Sam, but she sounded better stripped back, probably one of the best girls in the category.
October 1, 20168 yr That was very nearly the ideal 3 (Emily was 4th best anyway). Wonder if they're having wildcards for the Lives too, I think that'd be a BIT overkill.
October 1, 20168 yr Emily, Gifty and Olivia would have been my preferred top 3 after those performances but 2/3 ain't bad! (Justice for 4 of Diamonds :( easily the best group tonight)
October 1, 20168 yr I actually think Samantha will be the one to watch in this category, after seeing her perform Make It Rain, she really sounded the strongest of the final 3 girls. I actually think this is the best category on paper, the rest of the categories seem a mess.
October 1, 20168 yr 4 Of Diamonds really should have got through, by far the strongest of the groups and were fabulous tonight, rly annoyed they went out :( Hope they do wildcards and they come back as it! Also wished Olivia went through :( GROUPS RANKING: 1. 4 Of Diamonds- Incredible 2. Tom & Laura- Solid as usual 3. The Brooks- Love them but they were weak tonight 4. Ottavio And Bradley- Hate them but that was their best performance tonight 5. Scarl3t- What the heck was that? 6. 5AM- No. 7. Yes Lad- No. GIRLS RANKING: 1. Olivia Garcia- Perfect 2. Emily Middlemas- Her best performance yet, fabulous song choice and she did great! 3. Gifty- She slayed again *.* 4. Caitlyn Vanbeck- Was my favourite but rly messed up badly with song choice and forgetting the lyrics :( 5. Samantha Lavery- Loved her and another great performance from her 6. Kaleigh- She did really well but was nowhere near the top 5 7. Sohelia- Crap again. Tbh I would have been happy with any of that top 5 in the girls going through but I do wish Olivia/Caitlyn made it :( Such a strong category this year!
October 1, 20168 yr Author Groups have all changed their names... again! We now have: 5 After Midnight Bratavio Brooks Way Anyway, the girls was a very tough category - I could have made a case for all of them apart from Soheila whose vocals just weren't at the level of the others. Samantha did pull her best performance out of the bag at the right time, would have liked to see Olivia given a chance though - although she's surely a cert to be back in 1 or 2 years and getting very very far. Gifty's song choice was spot on tonight, as was Emily's, would love Gifty to pursue a dance route throughout the show.
Create an account or sign in to comment