Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 459
  • Views 61.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

1. Call It What You Want

2. Delicate

3. Look What You Made Me Do

4. Gorgeous

5. Ready For It

6. King of my Heart

7. Getaway Car

8. End Game

9. I Did Something Bad

10. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

11. Dancing with our Hands Tied

12. Dress

13. So It Goes

14. Don't Blame Me

 

 

 

15. New Year's Day

 

This was so hard, I adore literally every song from 12 up :') Even the next two are 8/10's, it's just NYD which is 50 shades of yawn that I'm not keen on.

  • 2 weeks later...

omg me missing people posting rankings and thoughts on this album :o Yasss Andrew stan and I'm glad you checked out the album Klum and loved hearing your thoughts *.*

 

I think I'm at the place where I'd say Speak Now is the best Taylor album but Reputation is my favourite <3 I just love this album so much and I still go back to and listen to it in full SO regularly, more regularly in full than any other Taylor album. The tracklist flows so well and there's so many moments on this album <3 the production is fab and has aged great and there's something so special about this album :heart:

 

my ranking nowadays:

 

1. Look What You Made Me Do

2. Delicate

3. Don't Blame Me

 

4. Call It What You Want

5. Getaway Car

6. ...Ready For It?

7. I Did Something Bad

8. King Of My Heart

9. End Game

10. Dancing With Our Hands Tied

 

11. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

12. New Year's Day

13. Gorgeous

14. So It Goes

15. Dress

 

The top 3 are the holy trinity and untouchable, all 11/10's in my top 10 Taylor songs of all time. 4 to 8 are all pretty close to each other and are all easy 10/10's that I listen to regularly <3 EG and DWOHT not too far behind them at all, the latter has aged so well. On a great day, TIWWCHNT and NYD are 10/10's as well. Gorgeous hasn't aged great but is still an underrated fun bop (9/10) and So It Goes is FINALLY growing on me a lot the past couple of months!!!! I think it's the first time it's not been last in my rankings aha. Dress remains I Don't Wanna Live Forever's inferior sister.

I cba to look further back in the thread the forum as it's too hard but these are how the songs have ranked in my last 4 rankings of Reputation on the forum I can find! (Feb 2018, June 2018, Feb 2019 & April 2020)

 

Look What You Made Me Do 01-01-01-01

Don't Blame Me 02-03-03-03

Getaway Car 03-07-04-05

...Ready For It? 04-04-05-06

End Game 05-06-08-09

Call It What You Want 06-05-06-04

I Did Something Bad 07-08-09-07

Delicate 08-02-02-02

Gorgeous 09-10-11-13

New Year's Day 10-13-12-12

King Of My Heart 11-09-07-08

This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things 12-11-10-11

Dancing With Our Hands Tied 13-12-13-10

Dress 14-14-14-15

So It Goes... 15-15-15-14

 

Looking at this, the top 3 has been set in stone since Delicate's video release really clicked the song for me and most of 4 to 9 are pretty much the same in a different order each time round! King Of My Heart & DWOHT have gone up the most whilst End Game and Gorgeous have aged the poorest as both have fallen. few places since my initial reactions. 13 of the 15 tracks being in my top 10 at one point!!!! what an album <3

Inspired by my post in the AF Idol thread :lol:

 

1. Delicate

2. Look What You Made Me Do

3. Don't Blame Me

4. ...Ready For It?

 

...RFI was my #1 for a while but gradually the others have climbed back up, either because of single pushes (Delicate), because I stopped overplaying it (LWYMMD), or just because it was a clear album highlight from the beginning and cannot be flawed (Don't Blame Me). All of these are 10/10 songs

 

5. I Did Something Bad

6. Getaway Car

7. Call It What You Want

 

More great songs although not ones I admittedly go back to overly often. I Did Something Bad is ICONIC and Getaway Car should have been a (properly pushed) single!

 

8. End Game

9. Gorgeous

10. King Of My Heart

 

End Game was a fantastic collaboration... that could have been. I love it but it was absolutely not what I was expecting :lol: I really wanted another 'Everything Has Changed' as unlikely as that was.

 

11. So It Goes

12. New Year's Day

13. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

14. Dancing With Our Hands Tied

15. Dress

 

Getting lower and lower in my ranking there's kind of a steep drop after King Of My Heart tbh. I do enjoy these but at the same time this could be a 10 track album and I wouldn't have any issues.

omg me missing people posting rankings and thoughts on this album :o Yasss Andrew stan and I'm glad you checked out the album Klum and loved hearing your thoughts *.*

 

I think I'm at the place where I'd say Speak Now is the best Taylor album but Reputation is my favourite <3 I just love this album so much and I still go back to and listen to it in full SO regularly, more regularly in full than any other Taylor album. The tracklist flows so well and there's so many moments on this album <3 the production is fab and has aged great and there's something so special about this album :heart:

It's close between Rep and Lover (unpopular opinion?) but I think this edges it for me too :wub: She needed this album and it comes through in the production and songwriting. I haven't heard her self-titled, Fearless or Red (so many albums I need to go back and listen to :lol:) but I love all the other four <3 Rep > Lover > Speak Now > 1989

Only over the last year around the point where I was excited for Lover to come out did some of the songs really click with me far more than before and I began to really see this album as a masterpiece, only slightly less than 1989 and Lover anyway.

 

01 // Call It What You Want

02 // ...Ready For It?

03 // Delicate

04 // Getaway Car

05 // I Did Something Bad

06 // Look What You Made Me Do

07 // This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

08 // Don't Blame Me

09 // End Game

10 // So It Goes

11 // King Of My Heart

12 // Dancing With Our Hands Tied

13 // New Year's Day

14 // Gorgeous

15 // Dress

 

01-06 are all 10/10s. CIWYW I always loved but hit me more than ever this year, it's such a stunning song. Gorgeous and Dress I don't dislike, I'd give them about a 6, but the former is a little cringey and Dress lacks what CIWYW and Delicate have in terms of the sort of song it is, it just feels empty.

  • 2 weeks later...

on the topic of this album: I am listening to Dress rn and I can never UNHEAR carve your name into my nipples in the chorus ffs :lol:

 

yasss Dexton at having the holy trinity in your top 3 and I'm glad more of the album has clicked for you Doug <3

 

It's close between Rep and Lover (unpopular opinion?) but I think this edges it for me too :wub: She needed this album and it comes through in the production and songwriting. I haven't heard her self-titled, Fearless or Red (so many albums I need to go back and listen to :lol:) but I love all the other four <3 Rep > Lover > Speak Now > 1989

Omg Red is essential!! There is some filler but the highlights are up there with her absolute best! <3

  • 1 year later...
Don't Blame Me is no 94 in the UK this week. I read that the song is exploding on TikTok. What is the reason for that?

Edited by Monzo

Don't Blame Me is no 94 in the UK this week. I read that the song is exploding on TikTok. What is the reason for that?

Perhaps this since I am not sure myself.

 

  • 7 months later...
  • 9 months later...
I heard that Reputation will be the next TV album and it’s due for release in February 2024
I heard that Reputation will be the next TV album and it’s due for release in February 2024

 

Interesting. Where did you hear that??

It’s a prediction. In the karma video she has a coffee with a clock pattern. One hand with a blue nail by the 10 (as in 1989tv in October) and the other hand had a black nail by 2 (so February 2024 for rep)
Really hope they do Getaway Car justice and it ends up a massive no1!
Really hope they do Getaway Car justice and it ends up a massive no1!

 

Agree, Getaway Car to get the massive success it deserves would be great.

  • 3 months later...
1. Delicate

2. Look What You Made Me Do

3. Don't Blame Me

4. ...Ready For It?

5. I Did Something Bad

6. Getaway Car

7. Call It What You Want

8. End Game

9. Gorgeous

10. King Of My Heart

11. So It Goes

12. New Year's Day

13. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

14. Dancing With Our Hands Tied

15. Dress

 

Aaaand four years on...

 

1. ...Ready For It?

2. Don't Blame Me

3. Delicate

4. Getaway Car

5. Look What You Made Me Do

6. I Did Something Bad

7. Call It What You Want

8. Gorgeous

9. So It Goes

10. End Game

11. King Of My Heart

12. New Year's Day

13. Dress

14. Dancing With Our Hands Tied

15. This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

 

RFI is firmly a Top 5 Taylor Swift song for me, no question about it. I'd push to say 'perfect' but who am I to judge hmm. I will say though that reputation was the best album live at the Eras tour. Obviously it was all amazing, but repuation was such a production. The energy behind each song was phenomenal.

 

Four years ago I probably would've said this was my favourite TS album but now maybe I'd drop it to #2-3. The re-recordings have reignited my love for her older albums and pushed rep to the side a little. I imagine when reputation TV comes out it'll be different though :lol:

  • 10 months later...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.