Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted
WELCOME TO THE MELODRAMA 2017 RATE RESULTS!
http://i68.tinypic.com/2di382g.jpg

Here are the songs hoping to get a high placement!

Green Light
Sober
Homemade Dynamite
The Louvre
Liability
Hard Feelings/Loveless
Sober II (Melodrama)
Writer In The Dark
Supercut
Liability (Reprise)
Perfect Places


PREDICTIONS?
Who will win? Who will finish in last place?

All songs averaged over 7.5!

Edited by cqmerqn

  • Replies 56
  • Views 4.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

11 Liability (Reprise) - 7.64

 

At 11 and finishing in last place, we have 'Liability (Reprise)' with a respectable average score of 7.64. This song isn't one of my favourites on the album, in fact I would probably also place this last. It's still a beautiful follow up (can I call it that) to Liability, which is also stunning. Where will Liability finish?

 

Lovers John-James (9.5)

Haters Bjork (4)

Edited by cqmerqn

Hyped for this

vcGwqFz.gif

 

Liability (Reprise) is fab but is in my bottom two so I'm fine with that last, the quality's gonna go up from here onwards *.*

http://i.imgur.com/gmDEgHs.gif

10 Hard Feelings/Loveless 7.98



:mellow: finishing SECOND TO LAST is one of the standout moments of the album, Hard Feelings / Loveless (this is by far the biggest grower for me as well). The first half is so dreamy and the instrumental leading into the end of it to Loveless is one of my favourite moments, so f***ing powerful. And of course what is this tape? THIS IS MY FAVOURITE TAPE!! is iconic and ya'll need to deal #justiceforhardfeelings/loveless

HOW is that second to last?? Top 5 (maybe 3) for me.

I can't really complain though because I don't vote.

  • Author

Hard Feelings/Loveless is stunning but it took me a while to appreciate. Maybe people are in the same position as I was?

 

Still, second to last with an average 7.98 isn't bad at all!

Correct bottom two tbh. They're both good but weaker links on an album as strong as 'Melodrama'. A 7.64 average for last place is incredible :lol:

That is definitely the right bottom 2 there, no bad songs on the album but those ones have the least WOW factor ~

 

Lol at how high all of the averages are *.*

  • Author

09 Writer In The Dark 8.23

 

At 09 we have Writer In The Dark which is incredibly beautiful :wub: It's the first song with an 11 to bow out but the only song in this rate to receive a 0. The song has been criticised by many, saying that she's trying too hard to sound like Kate Bush that they just can't enjoy it. I think it's a great song, but probably does deserve the 9 placing.

 

Lovers Josh (11)

Haters 152chris :mellow: (0)

Writer in the Dark is stunning, I've always loved how different it is for her too. Can't believe Chris thought it was 0 worthy :cry:

 

I'm predicting a Green Light win but I hope not as I've never really found it that special. Perfect Places was much more my thing but I'm predicting that to fall out in about 7th place :lol:

08 Sober II (Melodrama) 8.4318



dropping out next is another 111111/10 moment (why do i have to announce all my favs dropping out low :(). The title track of the album serves as an "interval", i'm usually hugely sceptical of continuations of songs (especially as sober was such an instant MOMENT for me) but this is just absolutely beautiful and is so brilliant when performed live!

WE TOLD YOU THIS WAS MELODRAMA

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.