Jump to content

Featured Replies

Thought of another two:

 

Elbow (11 years): Red (#36, 2001) -> One Day Like This (#4, 2012)

Joni Mitchell (27 years): Big Yellow Taxi (#11, 1970) -> Got 'Til It's Gone (#6, 1997) [samples the former]

  • 1 month later...
  • Replies 58
  • Views 15k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Gezza's 1991 thread has reminded me of another, with the same song fulfilling both: The Doors (24 years): Light My Fire (#49, 1967 -> Top 10 in 1991) There was also one last week: James Blake (15

  • OP has been given an uplift ~

  • GreyAsh
    GreyAsh

    It may have been noted before – I haven’t read all of the comments - but I’m assuming that Santana hold the record for reaching the top 10 with a new recording.

Following the discussion in the #4s thread of whether Aerosmith's first officially credited Top 10 hit was Walk This Way or I Don't Want To Miss A Thing (I'd say the former; the latter could see them included here), I've thought of another two:

 

Clubhouse (11 years): Do It Again - Billie Jean (Medley) (#11, 1983) -> Light My Fire (#7, 1994)

Nine Inch Nails (14 years): Head Like A Hole (#45, 1991) -> The Hand That Feeds (#7, 2005)

  • 5 months later...

We can now add to this list:

Mattafix (17 years): Big City Life (#15, 2005) -> Big City Life [Luude & Mattafix] (#10 so far, 2022)

and another older one not mentioned yet:

Santana (26 years): Samba Pa Ti (#27, 1974) -> Smooth (#3, 2000)

  • 3 months later...
  • 2 months later...

A couple more I've thought of - nowhere near the new record for Bobby Helms, but still over 10 years:

 

Scorpions (12 years): Is There Anybody There / Another Piece Of Meat (#39, 1979) -> Wind Of Change (#2, 1991)

 

Sting (12 years as a solo artist): Spread A Little Happiness (#16, 1982) -> All For Love (#2, 1994) [with Bryan Adams and Rod Stewart] -> When We Dance (#9, 1994) [first fully solo Top 10 hit]

  • 1 year later...
  • 7 months later...

Gezza's 1991 thread has reminded me of another, with the same song fulfilling both:

The Doors (24 years): Light My Fire (#49, 1967 -> Top 10 in 1991)

There was also one last week:

James Blake (15 years): Limit To Your Love (#39, 2010) -> History (#9, 2025)

  • 5 months later...

Was hoping we could add Hans Zimmer to this list, but the chance appears to be fading now.

I have remembered another couple though:

13 years, 7 months - Jeff Buckley

'Last Goodbye' (#54, May 1995)

'Hallelujah' (#2, December 2008)

10 years, 8 months - Incognito

'Parisienne Girl' (#73, November 1980)

'Always There' (#6, July 1991)

It may have been noted before – I haven’t read all of the comments - but I’m assuming that Santana hold the record for reaching the top 10 with a new recording.

On 11/04/2026 at 23:46, jimwatts said:

10 years, 8 months - Incognito

'Parisienne Girl' (#73, November 1980)

'Always There' (#6, July 1991)

Naive me always assumed that these were different bands. I always thought of Incognito as newcomers in the 1990s.

  • 7 months later...

We have a new addition this week:

20 years, 4 months - Justice

'We Are Your Friends' (#20, July 2006)

'Flower In A Hurricane' (#9 to date, November 2026)

Here's another I realised following the 1980s sessions:

15 years, 0 months - Shannon

'Let The Music Play' (#51, November 1983; then #14, 1984)

'Move Mania' (#8, November 1998)

I think 80s Shannon will be sampled eventually in a house hit like Colonel Abrams - Trapped was for Kolter!

20 minutes ago, jimwatts said:

15 years, 0 months - Shannon

It took me a long time to realise it was the same Shannon! Largely because of the huge gap. One was before my time, but with a much loved classic, and the other was out when I finally started going clubbing.

Is there anyone else who reads an old post, and is about to make a comment before realising they’ve said exactly the same thing before 🤣

Both Incognito and Clubhouse I didn’t realised they had had hits before their top 10 hits - in the same way that I said for Shannon.

And Santana is definitely the king here, as he reignited his career with not only a brand new song, but a brand new album with at least two massive hits on it, the other being ‘Maria Maria’ which has been sampled multiple times.

Edited by GreyAsh

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.