Two singles were released from Ultimate Kylie, but which is best?

Love both but slightly prefer giving you up.

This one is hard.

Both songs are very enjoyable and at times i prefer one to the other and then it switches again.

Right now, as it was a hit around this time of year im going with I Believe In You.

Giving you up deserved to have been put on giving you up, really disappointed it hasn't.

I Believe In You was the stronger choice and one of Kylie's best singles for me. Giving You Up is also good though, it's one of those that is better than I think it's going to be when I do hear it.

'I Believe In You' is the stronger of the two but I do really like both!

Both are strong singles from Kylie.

I Believe In You was a stand out when released.

Beautiful cover sleeve too.

 

It's a shame Ibiy went up against band aid for number 1 as it could went number 1 for her.

I believe in you is miles better. This is where her last proper greatest hits did well with a good lead single instead of a reject from her last album.

It had a great lead single a which helped hugely and giving you up is great too. SBIT has far more to offer but a poor reject of a single to promote it was bad and the song is nearly an insult to everything else on the akbum, this is prob bmg,s worst decision so far.

I Believe In you is a bop.

Giving You Up by milles.

Both are Bops, at this time Kylie was coming up with consistent excellent material.

She had an album of type of material in her at that a.c and I think we would have got a great pop dance style album.

Kylie was also working closely with Jake Shears who was highly popular and their work was very appealing.

'Giving You Up' is far better for me. I do really like IBIY of course, but it's not a favourite of mine. She does that annoying thing with her vocal that she sometimes does, and I find hard to enjoy properly.

Edited December 16, 20195 yr by Tawdry Hepburn

I Believe In You, easily out in front now.

In large, it was always the most popular of the 2 songs.

I Believe In You - Hands down, no competition...