Jump to content

Who should be the next Labour leader? 42 members have voted

  1. 1. Who should be the next Labour leader?

    • Keir Starmer
      7
    • Angela Rayner
      13
    • Rebecca Long-Bailey
      4
    • Hillary Benn
      0
    • Dianne Abbott
      1
    • Emily Thornberry
      0
    • Jess Phillips
      5
    • Yvette Cooper
      0
    • Dan Jarvis
      2
    • Other. Name please.
      2

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

As I've said in the other thread, the ideal candidate should be someone who is not intrinsically linked to the Corbyn project i.e didn't serve in his Shadow Cabinet or wasn't as prominent in it, represents a constituency in the North, preferably in a town rather than a university city (and definitely not in London), is able to build bridges to the more conservative-minded working class voters Labour lost in this year's election, and of course, should preferably be Catholic. I was surprised to learn that Rebecca Long-Bailey, one of the possible front-runners, matches at least two of those requirements (although not what I would deem the most important one).

 

One candidate that fitted the bill when I looked in to it was Conor McGinn. He represents a northern town (St. Helens), famous fell out with Jeremy Corbyn after Coybyn allegedly threatened to phone his father, and of course is Catholic. One potential drawback is that his father was a Sinn Fein councilor - given the scrutiny that Corbyn got for his links to the IRA, McGinn being leader would open many cans of worms.

  • Replies 165
  • Views 11.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I am currently rather ambivalent about the Labour leadership. I expect to form a stronger opinion on who I want when the frontrunners emerge, though either Starmer or Rayner seem okay at this point.

 

The one thing you can't say about Jess Phillips is that she wouldn't be boring or dull and we certainly need a charismatic candidate. At times she can really attract a rather violent type of hate though. It might be the difference needed.

I am currently rather ambivalent about the Labour leadership. I expect to form a stronger opinion on who I want when the frontrunners emerge, though either Starmer or Rayner seem okay at this point.

 

The one thing you can't say about Jess Phillips is that she wouldn't be boring or dull and we certainly need a charismatic candidate. At times she can really attract a rather violent type of hate though. It might be the difference needed.

 

The problem with Jess Phillips is she isn't going to be a unifying leader at all — there is a large percentage of the membership base that cannot stand her. I would fully expect there to be more in-fighting if she is chosen, although I find it unlikely that she will.

 

Rayner and Starmer are the correct choices for me.

  • Author
Rayner and Starmer are the correct choices for me.

 

 

 

Those two seem to be the ones that can maybe bring unity.

  • Author
The one thing you can't say about Jess Phillips is that she wouldn't be boring or dull and we certainly need a charismatic candidate. At times she can really attract a rather violent type of hate though. It might be the difference needed.

 

 

She was on TV this morning and is certainly not dull or boring as you say. She came across quite well.

Edited by Crazy Chris-tmas

  • Author
Was reading about the female front-runners and Angela Rayner had a son at 16 and was a grand-mother at 37. Not that it matters but wonder if the Tories may get a few digs in.

Edited by Crazy Chris-tmas

Was reading about the female front-runners and Angela Rayner had a son at 16 and was a grand-mother at 37. Not that it matters but wonder if the Tories may bet a few digs in.

 

At least she has been perfectly open about the number of children and grandchildren she has.

  • Author
At least she has been perfectly open about the number of children and grandchildren she has.

 

 

 

Yes she has and she's a huge supporter of the NHS as one of her younger sons had health problems and she says they were brilliant.

I'd like to see Chaos with Ed Miliband back in the Shadow Cabinet - he's still got a lot to offer IMO.

 

😂 I love that twitter post - retweeted it quite a lot over the past 4 years.

One candidate that fitted the bill when I looked in to it was Conor McGinn. He represents a northern town (St. Helens), famous fell out with Jeremy Corbyn after Coybyn allegedly threatened to phone his father, and of course is Catholic. One potential drawback is that his father was a Sinn Fein councilor - given the scrutiny that Corbyn got for his links to the IRA, McGinn being leader would open many cans of worms.

 

Would be quality if it was Conor but I'd say making it in the shadow cabinet would be his aim this term! They'd probably accuse him of being on the army council if he got it.

Was reading about the female front-runners and Angela Rayner had a son at 16 and was a grand-mother at 37. Not that it matters but wonder if the Tories may get a few digs in.

 

Why would they? Would look pretty terrible if they did!

Has to be Angela Rayner for me. I think it has to be somebody who can bridge the gap between the two "wings" of the Party (although she's been loyal and been out to bat for the Corbyn leadership, she isn't really what you'd call an out and out Corbynite) and is somebody whose backstory of growing up in poverty and working shit jobs for crap pay but whose life was improved by the things a Labour government put in place would be easy to sell to voters, especially in the north. My only worry is that she won't want to run against Rebecca Long-Bailey and that she'll end up running for the Deputy rather than the Leader which would be completely the wrong way round.

 

Keir Starmer would be my second choice as a solid, dependable, keep the ship steady and do the necessary work to purge the party of antisemitism and the cranks for five years Kinnock style choice before passing the torch on to a new generation in 2024. Of the other candidates, Emily Thornberry would be fabulous from a Gay Icon perspective but I think she gives off too much of a "Posh woman sneering" vibe, Jess Phillips I wouldn't trust not to do something lowkey racist or transphobic and end up being "cancelled" by the Twitterati plus I don't think she'd have support in the membership and Lisa Nandy is all "we have to listen to the concerns of small towns" and then no policy suggestions and just gets on my tits!

 

This is all assuming that there isn't another candidate waiting in the wings that nobody's heard of yet but is worth taking a chance on. Frankly after the last nine years I think it might be worth taking a punt on a relative unknown?

The more I think about it, the more I really want Angela Rayner to be the next leader. I love her so much!

 

This!

 

Corbyn mlced the Overton Window. She can get Labour in and Bojo out.

  • Author
The more I think about it, the more I really want Angela Rayner to be the next leader. I love her so much!

 

 

Steady on. :o Think she has a partner. :D

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.