Plenty of albums to discuss, please vote for your favourite album in each category

Tangled Up

Cinderella's Eyes

Ten

 

are my favourites! :wub: Great poll!

Tangled up

Cinderellas Eyes

Ten

 

Its always close between tangled up and out of control for me as i really like both albums, i have to say none of their solo albums are big stand outs for me, nicolas i like some songs but i had always hoped to enjoy more of their solo stuff than i actually did.

Tangled Up.

Insatiable.

Ten.

Great start for tangled up.

Due to the time of the release, Ten offers much more.

Sound of, was a huge commercial success and will always remain their best seller.

I’d say Ten is the best hits album because it has more material on it. Like it covers their entire career really (well from 02-12).

 

In terms of the groups studio albums I’m in the minority here but Out Of Control wins hands down for me. Tangled Up being a close second. They really had two fantastic albums with their final two studio albums.

 

Solo wise, Cheryl’s debut wins for me. A Million Lights and Only Human are strong as whole albums as well for me (Messy Little Raindrops however was a bit rushed due to her huge profile at the time anything she’d have released would’ve smashed definitely the weak link of solo Cheryl though). Nicolas debut is strong too but Cheryl wins for me.

 

I’m yet to hear solo Kimberley but as it’s a covers album idk if I’ll be keen on it. Nadines is ok but let down by production more than anything else.

Ten as the best of album, as I think some of their strongest singles (The Promise, Call The Shots, The Loving Kind) were released after the first greatest hits.

 

Studio album wise I have to go for Chemistry, as that album will always hold a special place in my heart.

 

Solo wise absolutely Nicola, hands down no competition.

Tangled Up/3 Words/Ten

Best Girls Aloud album: 'Tangled Up' hands down :wub: pop perfection.

Best Solo Album: Cheryl's '3 Words', partially due to nostalgia but there are some great songs on there.

Best Greatest Hits: 'Ten' as it came 6 years later so it's more comprehensive. However, I do resent the lack of 'Long Hot Summer' -_-

If they reunite we will prob get another greatest hits in some format.

Out Of Control

 

A Million Lights

 

Ten

Cheryl should probably put out a GH and tack Let You and Love Made Me Do It onto it.

I agree, if she leaves it much longer it will never happen.

It could be launched with a new single if she records one.

I was expecting her to release a greatest hits when she released her last 2 singles.

Chemistry

Cinderella’s Eyes

Ten

I can't see a Cheryl Greatest Hits ever being greenlighted... to me it seems pointless and not a release that would have significant commercial viability to warrant releasing it.

 

It's been 6 years since her last album and #1 hits. 8-11 years since the singles and album eras that were very successful. It's just been too long - how would she make the public care to invest in those hits? I think that would be a major struggle. She's far from being Kylie Minogue, whose last Greatest Hits was justified because of Glastonbury, touring and coming off the back of a #1 album.

 

I think the last feasible time a Cheryl GH could have happened, and perhaps been successful, would have been late 2015. She was still an X Factor judge that year and her music career at that time would have still been considered current/memorable.

Chemistry

Cinderella Eyes

Ten

I can't see a Cheryl Greatest Hits ever being greenlighted... to me it seems pointless and not a release that would have significant commercial viability to warrant releasing it.

 

It's been 6 years since her last album and #1 hits. 8-11 years since the singles and album eras that were very successful. It's just been too long - how would she make the public care to invest in those hits? I think that would be a major struggle. She's far from being Kylie Minogue, whose last Greatest Hits was justified because of Glastonbury, touring and coming off the back of a #1 album.

 

I think the last feasible time a Cheryl GH could have happened, and perhaps been successful, would have been late 2015. She was still an X Factor judge that year and her music career at that time would have still been considered current/memorable.

 

What you are saying is valid but she has had a few big hits that can sell a greatest hits, i think if she is ever to release an album again it would have to be a greatest hits as it might have some chance of success as i cant see a new studio album her doing much at all.