Jump to content

Featured Replies

'Feel' is my favourite Robbie song as well but I guess I didn't realise that was such a popular opinion :lol:
  • Replies 278
  • Views 17.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I feel like most of Robbie's best songs made #4 - aside from 'Feel' and 'Angels', there's also 'Come Undone' (which is easily one of my faves by him), 'Supreme' and 'Strong', I can't recall how those did in this. And there's also 'Rudebox' which got critically panned but which I unashamedly love :wub: #sorrynotsorry - I know that went out way early though!

Edited by Mangø

J didnt know Angels was poached from someone!
  • Author

6. Erasure - A Little Respect 1359pts

 

Writers - Vince Clarke, Andy Bell

Top scores - Leonardo 50, dandy* 50, Shoat 48, Boymetworld91 48, StoneDragon 48

Low scores - garyfeld 6, Chez Wombat 6, Dot Branning 7

Average score - 28.9

 

Taken from their album 'The Innocents', this was Erasure's fifth top 10 single. In 2015, it was adopted by rugby league club Hull Kingston Rovers as their official song for the Challenge Cup Final which they ended up losing 50-0. Andy Bell performed the song at one of their home matches the following year.

 

  • Author

5. Robbie Williams - Feel 1380pts

 

Writers - Robbie Williams, Guy Chambers

Top scores - Roba 49, Brer 48, rio309 45, Mack 45

Low scores - JackJones 8, jimwatts 9, AH Gold 10

Average score - 29.4

 

Feel was Robbie Williams' fourteenth top 5 single and his best selling in Europe where it was also the most played song on radio in 2003.

 

I think I had heard that Erasure song before this but it's not one that I was super familiar with, definitely worthwhile relistening for this as it is great so cool to see it finishing this high! (I think there are a couple of songs still to come that I can say the same about, so I must just be a little out of touch on these songs rather than them not actually being that well known :lol:)
This is a super-strong top 10! Everything in it so far I love and/or is an all time classic

A Little Respect is Erasure's best, same for Robbie's Feel, 2 great tracks. It's a pity Feel wasn't released prior to the album, would have been a sure #1

 

Out of all of Robbie's #4s my fav is Strong, with Feel being a close 2nd, Angels maybe 3rd.

Edited by Bjork

A Little Respect isn’t one of my personal Erasure favourites - in fact I prefer Love To Hate You which missed the final.

 

Amazing to see Keane up there again after Somewhere Only We Know was 3rd in the #3 contest. For me 3 of the top 4 are brilliant and the other I can live (with or) without.

Yeah I agree, 'A Little Respect' is a great song but 'Love To Hate You' is my favourite, I would happily have seen that in the top ten instead.

 

Were the top ten (in no particular order) posted? Not sure if I missed it but do we know what songs are left in the top 4?

Edited by Mangø

Just based on what I don’t remember having seen (apologies if one of these dropped out and I missed it!):

 

Everybody’s Changing

True Faith

No Surprises

With Or Without You

 

Happy for any of the Top 3 to win. I know I’m not judging the latter fairly but unfortunately it’s another one that Fox FM just wouldn’t leave alone when I was growing up. :(

A little respect is a great song. Respect for its top 6 placing.

 

I heard it a lot in the lgbt+ bars growing up in Cardiff :D

Not a fan of the top 4 !!

 

Love A Little Respect tho !

surprised at that top 4, all being alt/indie/rock!

3 songs are an 11/10 (No Surprises, With or without you, Blue monday), while the Keane song is a more of an 8/10

No Surprises to win please, probably will be Blue Monday

^ you mean True Faith not Blue Monday...

I agree it's a strong final few. In the #1 and #2 rates a few years ago, I felt those had great final 100s but their top 10s were a little hit and miss. Last year I thought the #3s had a strong final 50 and especially the top 10. This year I didn't think the quality of the final 50 was quite the same, but the top 10 has delivered again - even the songs I gave relatively low scores I can appreciate as one of the highlights from the respective artists.

  • Author

4. New Order - True Faith 1386pts

 

Writers - Gillian Gilbert, Stephen Hague, Peter Hook, Stephen Morris, Bernard Sumner

Top scores - Ansel 50, Grandwicky 50, Shoat 49, StoneDragon 49, dandy* 49

Low scores - chrissmith276 2, Alex! 3, Dj Cheeky Magpie 4

Average score - 29.5

 

True Faith was one of two new songs recorded for New Order's singles collection 'Substance' and was their first top 100 hit in the US. The video won the award for best video of the year at the 1988 Brits. A remix of the song reached number 9 in 1994.

 

  • Author

3. U2 - With Or Without You 1426pts

 

Writers - U2

Top scores - Boymetworld91 49, Achabaan 49, jimwatts 49

Low scores - JulianT 4, garyfeld 10, brokenrecords 10

Average score - 30.3

 

From the same year as True Faith, With Or Without You was the first single released from the Joshua Tree album. It was U2's fourth top 10 hit and the first of their eight US number 1 singles.

 

Edited by King Rollo

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.