Interesting that there are two votes for Jade but not one person has mentioned her in a place above 6th (or even at all in Silas' case lol)

 

Jade having more than Amelle and in particular Heidi amazes me.

Jade having more than Amelle and in particular Heidi amazes me.

 

 

It gags me :lol:

Interesting that there are two votes for Jade but not one person has mentioned her in a place above 6th (or even at all in Silas' case lol)

I only ranked Sugababes members 🤷🏼‍♂️

Will always be Siobhan for me. Sounds beautiful on both albums she features on and her solo stuff is criminally underrated

It gags me :lol:

 

Astounding.

 

I only ranked Sugababes members 🤷🏼‍♂️

 

Brutal, but probably fair.

Basically exactly what blacksquare said.

 

Plus I've come to realise that the tracks that have aged the best are from Siobhan's era and without doubt they work best as a group when she is part of it.

For me the Sugababes have always been MKS. I always saw the other ladies as just replacements, but in saying that I respect their hard work and contribution.

For me the Sugababes have always been MKS. I always saw the other ladies as just replacements, but in saying that I respect their hard work and contribution.

Surely now the Jade votes are just trolling? (No disrespect to Jade)

I only ranked Sugababes members

I’m curious about your reasons why Heidi is so low in your affections these days! (All those “>>>” after Amelle!)

I feel like the shade directed at Amelle, Heidi and Jade is coming across quite childish in some posts. All 6 have moved on, the fans need to as well.

 

Much like the issues with Steps, it’s all in the past now.

That being said, my order is:

 

Siobhan

Heidi

Mutya

Keisha

Amelle

Jade

I’m curious about your reasons why Heidi is so low in your affections these days! (All those “>>>” after Amelle!)

Heidi has always been my least favourite member, by a long way, because she’s by far the weakest live vocalist. I saw 2.0 at the Smash Hit Poll Winners gig in Glasgow in like 2002/3 time and I remember saying after how Mutya and Keisha sounded exactly like the CD but Heidi was rubbish live. My opinion hasn’t changed much over time. Amelle can at least hold a note live

 

 

I’m glad that Heidi is enjoying her retirement. She earned it. She was an important part of the bands legacy. Both the good and the bad

That's fair! I feel like Heidi's strengths (in terms of live performance) was either harmonising, or if any of her solo sections were more vocally restrained. Sometimes her belting just wasn't it... the legendary Rock in Rio performance of Stronger though... you go girl! ( :kink: )

That's fair! I feel like Heidi's strengths (in terms of live performance) was either harmonising, or if any of her solo sections were more vocally restrained. Sometimes her belting just wasn't it... the legendary Rock in Rio performance of Stronger though... you go girl! ( :kink: )

 

Is that the meeee-eeeee-eeeee-eeeee-eeeee thing?

Is that the meeee-eeeee-eeeee-eeeee-eeeee thing?

Yes :lol:

 

 

Heidi and Siobhan.

Both are very unassuming and never veered into the celebrity world the way many others go.

Yes :lol:

 

I need to see this!?!?

 

 

Just remember that you asked to see this 🙈😂

I thought that was edited all this time :(