Is there someone who can change my vote? I picked Real Slim Shady instead of Stan :(

 

I rank them-

 

1. Stan (with Dido)

2. Without Me

3. The Real Slim Shady

4. Lose Yourself

5. The Monster

6. Houdini

7. Smack That

8. Like Toy Soldiers

9. Just Lose It

10. Godzilla

11. River

 

^Switched x

 

My ranking (similar favourites to everyone else, he has done some undeniable classics but also some utter crap, the difference in quality between the top 2 and bottom 4 is huge):

 

01; Stan

02; Lose Yourself

 

-slight gap-

 

03; The Real Slim Shady

04; Without Me

05; Like Toy Soldiers

 

-bigger gap-

 

06; Houdini

07; Godzilla

 

-humongous gap-

 

08; River

09; Just Lose It

10; The Monster

11; Smack That

The poll leaders right now reflect my own thoughts exactly - a tossup between 'Stan' and 'Lose Yourself' for the best and between 'Just Lose It' and 'River' for worst. I went with 'Lose Yourself' and 'River' ('Just Lose It' is a complete trainwreck of a song and not in a 'so bad it's good' way but that at least makes it interesting whereas 'River' is just a complete nothing of a song).

 

1 Lose Yourself

2 Stan

3 Godzilla

4 Without Me

5 The Real Slim Shady

6 Like Toy Soldiers

7 The Monster

8 Smack That

9 Houdini (only heard this once so far so not totally sure where to rank it, I found it quite boring on that first listen though - but still could easily jump to #6/7 if it grows on me a bit)

10 Just Lose It

11 River

For me the top 4 in this list (Real Slim Shady, Without Me, Stan, Lose Yourself) are all 9/10 or better and are miles ahead of the rest.

 

Couldn't decide which was my favourite so chose The Real Slim Shady because I once rapped it in full at karaoke

Voted for 'Stan' as the best and 'Just Lose It' for worst.

 

1. Stan

2. Lose Yourself

3. Without Me

4. The Real Slim Shady

5. Like Toy Soldiers

6. The Monster

7. Smack That

8. Godzilla

9. Houdini

10. River

11. Just Lose It

 

1 Stan

2 The Real Slim Shady

3 Lose Yourself

4 Without Me

... 5-10 fairly interchangeable ...

11 River

Great

 

1. Stan

2. Lose Yourself

3. The Real Slim Shady

 

Very good

 

4. Without Me

5. Like Toy Soldiers

 

Ok

 

6. Houdini

7. The Monster

 

Not good

 

8. Just Lose It

9. River

10. Smack That

11. Godzilla

 

The top three are undeniable all-time classics for me, along with many that didn't reach No.1 (My Name Is, Guilty Conscience, Mockingbird, Love The Way You Lie). The next two I also like a lot. Beyond that I'm not interested in the other six, although Houdini is catchy. He is the very definition of a hit and miss artist for me.

Stan BEST

Godzilla Worst

The first 4 are some of the best hip-hop tracks ever made imo :heart: I also really enjoy 5-8. 'The Monster' just felt like too much like a re-hash of 'Love The Way You Lie', it's is better than LTWYL at least. The last two are horrendous, especially that Cheesy Fad collab :puke:

 

1. Lose Yourself

2. Stan

3. Without Me

4. The Real Slim Shady

5. Godzilla

6. Like Toy Soldiers

7. Houdini

8. Smack That

9. The Monster

10. Just Lose It

11. River

1. Lose Yourself

2. Stan (with Dido)

3. Without Me

4. The Real Slim Shady

5. Like Toy Soldiers

6. Smack That (with Akon)

7. Houdini

8. Just Lose It

9 .Godzilla (with Juice WRLD)

10. River (with Ed Sheeran)

11. The Monster (with Rihanna)

1 Stan

2 Lose Yourself

3 The Real Slim Shady

4 Without Me

5 The Monster

6 Like Toy Soldiers

7 Houdini

8 River

9 Just Lose It

10 Smack That

11 Godzilla

 

 

Stan and Lose Yourself would always come very high up in my list of all time favourite #1s

1. Without Me

2. Stan

3. The Real Slim Shady

4. Lose Yourself

5. Smack That (an outlier to rank for obvious reasons and I do associate it more as Akon's song but I do think it's a bop regardless)

6. The Monster

7. Godzilla

8. Like Toy Soldiers

9. Houdini (might move up in future but hasn't massively clicked with me yet)

10. Just Lose It

11. River

 

01. 11.0 | Without Me

02. 10.0 | Lose Yourself

03. 10.0 | Like Toy Soldiers

04. 09.5 | The Monster (feat. Rihanna)

05. 09.5 | The Real Slim Shady

06. 09.0 | Stan (feat. Dido)

07. 08.5 | Houdini

08. 08.0 | Just Lose It

09. 08.0 | Godzilla (feat. Juice WRLD)

10. 07.0 | Smack That (feat. Akon)

11. 06.0 | River (feat. Ed Sheeran)

 

 

I don't know the best, bur River is def the worst by far.