It seems like the fanbase is split three ways for what Gaga should announce as the 4th single from MAYHEM.

So pick a team! Vote in the poll and discuss your reasoning and choices below.

Garden of Eden vs Vanish Into You vs How Bad Do U Want Me

I change my preference daily

GARDEN OF EDEN!!!! It is by far my most favourite track on the album (with ‘Abracadabra’ following closely behind)!

I’m at this point where I’m unsure which 3 would smash hardest, probably ‘How Bad Do U Want Me’, but equally I think all 3 have potential to reach the same level that ‘Abracadabra’ did on the charts.

Honestly I think any of these would make a good choice. I feel like 'Garden of Eden' makes the most sense though and could become a classic single for her, that chorus is big.

Vanish Into You, but I don't think it matters, all these songs can go and live on their own without being "official" singles (whatever that means these days). All will also reach 100 million streams on Spotify fairly soon.

I have voted Vanish Into You which I am shocked at because it was below the other two on release week but over time I have grown to see its real, incredible beauty. I think it's also the most user-friendly one and the GP should lap it up!

But as others have said, all three would do the job and deserve a shot in the limelight.

YES!

Any of these would likely be a fine choice commercially but gave 'Garden Of Eden' the edge as it's my favourite quality-wise by far 💗

This is tricky and I kind of have a case for all three here which I’ll explain!

So I voted Vanish Into You as that’s my personal favourite and I think it’s different from both Disease and Abracadabra to showcase versatility on MAYHEM. It’s got a classic feel to it and would sound great on radio!

How Bad Do U Want Me is what I think would do the best mainstream wise however. It’s pure pop but unlike anything she’s ever pushed before. I think it has crazy potential to go viral and it feels like a major hit in the making.

Garden of Eden visually I think would make the best music video but as it’s charted already in the UK i kinda want something else to be pushed so she can achieve more charting singles here! I think Garden of Eden is also similar ish to Abracadabra so the other two choices show more versatility! Like someone who wasn’t keen on Abracadabra and prefers the softer side of Gaga may like Vanish Into You for example!

Any I’d be happy enough with but I think How Bad Do U Want Me is what would do the biggest numbers!

(Shadow of A Man would’ve been the lead in an alternate reality becoming a Grammy winning global #1 but will settle For this being a fan favourite) x

Edited May 1May 1 by Jordanlee1402

Agree with all of that Jord! Including the Shadow Of A Man part

I'd go for HBDYWM having the most commercial appeal otherwise VIY for being the best of the three just about

I think pushing GOE any further than the album launch promo track status it had would be a mistake

I am PASSIONATELY team Vanish Into You now. It's becoming an ANTHEM for the fandom + the GP would love it too I'm sure.

Either way ANNOUNCE SOMETHING WHILE THE IRON IS HOT MOTHER

I’ve heard another rumour that the 4th single announcement and video won’t drop now until August…

Vanish Into You (May)

How Bad Do U Want Me (August/September)

Would be ideal. If we got Shadow of a Man too as the final single I’d die but I doubt she’d give us that many singles/videos

I've voted for Garden of Eden because that's my favourite track of the three and I'd like to see it get its moment - but I still think that How Bad Do You Want Me is the one most likely to smash, but I think that would happen regardless of when it was released in the campaign - just don't mess it up team Gaga please!

I did think GOE should have been pushed alongside the album but now we are rolling into summer HBDYM is I think is the obvious choice as it just fits that summer vibe.

In a perfect world I’d push HBDYM in June and then ZB in September with SOAM in January.

WHERE is the official announcement of the next single/video Gaga!!?!?!?!

The hype for ‘Mayhem’ is dying down and all its singles is falling down the chart now, she needs to quickly release something soon!

She better not do what she did with Chromatica and cut the era dead again at album release.

Interestingly Vanish Into You was the only non-single performed at the YouTube event. Make it a single already!!

1 hour ago, HausofMayhem said:

Interestingly Vanish Into You was the only non-single performed at the YouTube event. Make it a single already!!

Perfect Celebrity was also performed?? But would do terrible as a single, hopefully it’s coming after Singapore.