Beyoncé has been replaced at the survivor table by an empty seat. In the #29 survivor this reached the final so 4th here is something of a comedown. The single reached #4 in November 2004, and was the follow up to the chart topping “Déja Vu” but has proved to be much more enduring than that.

4th: Beyoncé - Irreplaceable

5th: Mariah Carey - All I Want For Christmas Is You 14/30 votes (47%)

6th: All American Rejects - Gives You Hell 16/35 votes (46%)

7th: Goldtrix - It’s Love (Trippin’) 16/33 votes (48%)

8th: Hear’Say - Everybody 16/30 votes (53%)

9th: Wyclef Jean featuring The Rock and Melky Sedeck - It Doesn’t Matter 9/29 votes (31%)

10th: Jennifer Lopez featuring Fat Joe - Hold You Down 12/32 votes (38%)

Looks like Nelly’s on for a second straight bronze medal, which is where I place her in this.

On 11/07/2025 at 09:06, awardinary said:

  On 08/07/2025 at 09:29, awardinary said:

Love this top 3

Hard to pick one to vote but I love the other 2 a lot so going for Avril

I've gone Avril here, but that's a tough choice between those three

Difficult choice here, but I've decided on Snow Patrol

Sticking with Run.

Nelly Furtado to leave

Snow Patrol but I like all of these

Avril.

Listen, I like Nelly Furtado as much as the next homosexual but let's not act like this song is on the same level as the other 2 here.

As pleasant as it is, the other 2 are career defining tracks for them, songs that absolutely showcased the best of those artists and are standout songs associated with those artists, All Good Things... is simply an enjoyable track within Nelly's discography that doesn't stand in the same way.

That being said, this is a very strong final 3 admittedly

Speak for yourself, 'All Good Things (Come To An End)' is my favourite song from her x

Snow Patrol but all are fabulous!

Nelly Furtado to go this time.

6 hours ago, Brer said:

Speak for yourself, 'All Good Things (Come To An End)' is my favourite song from her x

Like I said, great song and whilst some may see it as their personal favourite of hers, it is not her career defining song to the point of if you surveyed x many people to name a song by her, it is likely it would not be the most named.

Whereas Run and I'm With You, you could make the argument that they could very well be, that's all