1 minute ago, Henessy Lake said:

Need the 2 huntrx to be top 10 with golden

Would be perfect but its probably too late now if they were all allowdd to chart at peak popularity they probably would of though

'Rein Me In' could be challenging 'Bad Dreams' for most Top 10 returns at this rate!

I'm honestly so sick and tired of Sam Fender by now. His new track sounds exactly the same, as well. And where was Elton John?

8 Olivia Dean - So Easy (To Fall in Love)

3 minutes ago, Johann said:

I'm honestly so sick and tired of Sam Fender by now. His new track sounds exactly the same, as well. And where was Elton John?

Elton is playing piano not singing

7 Olivia Dean - Nice to Each Other

6 Taylor Swift - Elizabeth Taylor

4 minutes ago, ___∆___ said:

Elton is playing piano not singing

Yeah my issue with this is that he shouldn't get a credit for playing the piano - otherwise anyone who plays the piano on any track should get a credit! It's a bit unfair IMO

 

10 minutes ago, 777666jason said:

Would be perfect but its probably too late now if they were all allowdd to chart at peak popularity they probably would of though

* would have

1 minute ago, Mangø said:

Yeah my issue with this is that he shouldn't get a credit for playing the piano - otherwise anyone who plays the piano on any track should get a credit! It's a bit unfair IMO

There's no reason it can't happen otherwise, it's just that Elton's a bigger name so I don't see why they wouldn't want to draw attention to Elton's presence on the track!

5 Taylor Swift - Opalite

He's been a feature before when only playing the piano. Some people have Rock artists just playing guitar on their songs and credit them as a feature. So not just Elton John who does it

1 minute ago, JosephBoone said:

There's no reason it can't happen otherwise, it's just that Elton's a bigger name so I don't see why they wouldn't want to draw attention to Elton's presence on the track!

But my issue is that it counts towards his chart tally which I don't think is fair.

 

Just now, Henessy Lake said:

He's been a feature before when only playing the piano. Some people have Rock artists just playing guitar on their songs and credit them as a feature. So not just Elton John who does it

But plenty don't too so it's inconsistent. Taking the guitar example, Slash played guitar (quite prominently) on Michael Jackson's #2 hit 'Give In To Me'. So why should Elton get a chart hit for this but Slash didn't get one for that?

2 minutes ago, Henessy Lake said:

He's been a feature before when only playing the piano. Some people have Rock artists just playing guitar on their songs and credit them as a feature. So not just Elton John who does it

Remember Paul McCartney on Rihanna + Kanye's Fourfiveseconds and Brian May on Dappy's Rockstar?

5 minutes ago, Mangø said:

Yeah my issue with this is that he shouldn't get a credit for playing the piano - otherwise anyone who plays the piano on any track should get a credit! It's a bit unfair IMO

 

* would have

Nope @JosephBoone didnt correct im sticking with it 🤭

Edited 18 hours ago18 hr by 777666jason

1 minute ago, Mangø said:

But my issue is that it counts towards his chart tally which I don't think is fair.

It's the same principle as something like Paul McCartney getting a credit on FourFiveSeconds, or even Calvin Harris on Eliza Rose's Body Moving where he's "just" the producer. It's just label politics and taking advantage of name-power, credits are far from being "fair" or consistent anyway (see Aloe Blacc not getting to officially claim a #1 for Avicii's Wake Me Up, for example)

4 RAYE - WHERE IS MY HUSBAND!

3 Olivia Dean - Man I Need

4 minutes ago, Mangø said:

But my issue is that it counts towards his chart tally which I don't think is fair.

 

But plenty don't too so it's inconsistent. Taking the guitar example, Slash played guitar (quite prominently) on Michael Jackson's #2 hit 'Give In To Me'. So why should Elton get a chart hit for this but Slash didn't get one for that?

Demi Lovato included him as a credited feature on sorry not sorry Rock version.

So would it be an all female top 10 without that sam fender track

Throw him off