1 minute ago, Scene said:

I Trance and Glassheart would've made it interesting.

I was thinking potentially I, Trance for Agnes, but not sure that would have done much more than what HCTN did either tbh. Same for 'Glassheart'. I actually think Leona was DOA as soon as Iz was assigned to the females! Not sure her music really appeals to him (I could be wrong though ofc!) honestly, I think I would have personally chanced 'I See You' from Avatar or her Hans Zimmer collab tbh - something grand/from the movies. I feel bad for their mentors tbh but I also do not begrudge any of those 3 judges. It was a brutal round!

here is how Judge Daniel Gee would have voted based solely on the song choice

Females:

1. Zara Larsson

2. Kate Bush

3. Robyn

4. Sophie Ellis Bextor

5. Adele

6. Marina

7. Agnes (OUT)

8. Leona Lewis (OUT)

Males:

1. Calvin Harris

2. Gary Numan

3. Sam Fender

4. Sam Smith

5. Damien Rice

6. Tom Grennan

7. HRVY (OUT)

8. Darin (OUT)

Groups:

1. Years & Years

2. iamamiwhoami

3. Sade

4. Depeche Mode

5. Fontaines D.C

6. New Order

7. Bananarama (OUT)

8. Texas (OUT)

1 minute ago, Tafty said:

I was thinking potentially I, Trance for Agnes, but not sure that would have done much more than what HCTN did either tbh. Same for 'Glassheart'. I actually think Leona was DOA as soon as Iz was assigned to the females! Not sure her music really appeals to him (I could be wrong though ofc!) honestly, I think I would have personally chanced 'I See You' from Avatar or her Hans Zimmer collab tbh - something grand/from the movies. I feel bad for their mentors tbh but I also do not begrudge any of those 3 judges. It was a brutal round!

Tbf Iz did say that Adele was in real danger of going for that reason but the song choice sent did save her as he ended up quite liking it so I guess the right Leona / Agnes songs could have had the same result for them. Have a read of their thinking a few pages back, it's really interesting actually, you can see all the thought that went into it.

I'm gutted for Leona, she deserved more in her career and more in Pop Factor! 💔

I could imagine Iz saving 'I Trance' maybe. Think that is my favourite Agnes song besides the obvious!

(I didn't vote for 'Here Comes The Night' in PFSC so maybe there's a reason I don't remember it oop, will see if it clicks with me more when I listen to these songs x)

I’ve listened to everything and would have voted like this if I were a judge (I’d have stuck solely to the chosen songs as I think that’s the only fair thing to do):

Females

01: Zara

02: Robyn

03: Kate

04: Marina

05: Adele

06: Agnes

07: Sophie

08: Leona

Top 4 leagues ahead of the bottom 4 for me. Very close between Agnes and Sophie, could easily have swapped them round on another day.

Males

01: Gary Numan

02: Damien Rice

03: Calvin Harris

04: Sam Smith

05: Sam Fender

06: Tom Grennan

07: Darin

08: HRVY

No shock that the twinks would have been in danger if I was deciding. Even the elder twink.

Groups

01: New Order

02: Sade

03: iamamiwhoami

04: Bananarama

05: Depeche Mode

06: Fontaines DC

07: Years & Years

08: Texas

I’ve surprised myself here when I realised I also would have reluctantly had to send Years and Years home.

I don’t know Agnes’ music really as well as I’d like, I shall have to check out all of these suggestions as definitely her earlier songs were very impressive.

With Jonjo’s question, I suppose Leona was in quite a bit of danger with me (I think her best is Better In Time and possibly any dramatic film stuff she’s done I don’t know about) but yeah so were Zara, Adele and SEB from the start.

Here are my actual ranks for posterity:

Females

1. Robyn (Fave)

2. Zara

3. Agnes

4. Sophie

5. Marina

6. Kate

7. Adele

8. Leona

Males

1. Darin (Fave)

2. Calvin Harris

3. Damien Rice

4. Gary Numan

5. Tom Grennan

6. Sam Fender

7. Sam Smith

8. HRVY

Groups

1. Texas (Fave)

2. Bananarama

3. Fontaines DC

4. iamamiwhoami

5. Sade

6. Depeche Mode

7. New Order

8. Years & Years

But I would have had to think beyond song as no way does Sam Smith or New Order deserve to go, for example. Just my preference. All of the group songs are 8/10 and above for me, the strongest category this round imo.

Edited Friday at 16:393 days by gooddelta

Agree with Rich, the groups were the strongest this round

I've had a listen to everything too... tbf I thought every round was really strong. Based on song choices alone this is how I would likely have judged were I one...

Females

1. Kate

2. Sophie

3. Marina (actually really shocked me to rank her so high as I haven't really been blown away by her so far)

4. Robyn

5. Zara

6. Agnes

7. Adele

8. Leona

I feel really gutted for Leona but she would have been my last place vote. Adele would also have likely left compared to the above choices with Agnes scraping through, would have felt very wrong sending her home though. All the songs are really strong tbf, the Leona one is lovely but the only slight weak link for me.

Males

1. Sam Smith (this is probably my ultimate fave Sam song!)

2. Calvin

3. Gary (brilliant, loved this - and he would have been my danger act too so a fab choice)

4. Darin

5. Tom

6. Sam Fender

7. Damien

8. HRVY

The HRVY one did nothing for me personally, and the Damien one neither tbh. The top 6 I really enjoyed and I loved the top 4 so I would have made the same choices.

Groups

1. Bananarama (this and I want you back are my favourite Bananrama songs so nothing was going to beat that)

2. Texas

3. Depeche Mode

4. Years & Years

5. Fontaines DC

6. New Order

7. Iamamiwhoami

8. Sade

Again I liked all the songs in this category tbf and I thought this was possibly the strongest of all the categories and really none deserved to go. Sade and Iamamiwhoami would have suffered though sadly, although I will say I think that was Iamamiwhoami's best submission so far.

You all deserve jail ❤️

HRVY coming to troll you all in the Gamu round like:

Just now, Calum said:

You all deserve jail ❤️

HRVY coming to troll you all in the Gamu round like:

It will be nice to see him again... for 5 minutes before he gets sent home again. 🤭

I think my bottom 2s just based on this round’s song would have been:

Adele and Leona

Sam Smith and HRVY

Years & Years and Bananarama

Apple Music – Webplayer

„The Pop Factor: Season 3 • Judges' Houses: Part One in J...

Playlist · 18 Titel

Have just listened through the playlist so here are my rankings x

womenz:

1 MARINA
2 Sophie Ellis-Bextor

3 Kate Bush

4 Robyn

5 Agnes

6 Adele

7 Zara Larsson

8 Leona Lewis

A big divide between the top 4 and the bottom 4 - the Agnes song is actually decent (I remembered it when I heard it, also checked and I ranked it 11th in PFSC so very nearly did vote for it there after all x), the Adele song is ok as well but not really a standout from her, have never been a fan of the last two songs. I forgot how much I liked the Sophie song! Although still an easy win for one of MARINA's best songs x

menz:

1 Gary Numan

2 Calvin Harris

3 Sam Fender

4 Tom Grennan

5 Damien Rice

6 Sam Smith

7 Darin

8 HRVY

Another big divide here but just between the top 6 and bottom 2 so would have been easy picks to eliminate for me - the Darin song is not terrible but not particularly to my taste either, sounded like an Enrique throwaway. I have actually heard that HRVY song before as it sounded familiar, it's shite. All of the top 6 are good picks, another pretty comfortable 1st place for the old man but yay for the moment Tom Grennan locked in and actually made a banger, and that was a lovely discovery from the Riceman.

groopz:

1 Fontaines D.C.

2 Sade

3 Bananarama

4 Depeche Mode

5 New Order

6 Texas

7 Years & Years

8 iamamiwhoami

Groups being the best category as per as 'Sunlight' is definitely by far my favourite of the songs that I'd have thrown out, and 'blue blue' is by far my second favourite of them oops. (Though I did think it was the least good yammy song so far, sorry Pavita, I blame the fact she is ESL so maybe try sending a good Brit or American next time eh). Entirely agreeing with Jaz's decisions on this in the end though as it were! The Texas song is in fact another song I do know quite well but just didn't know it was a Texas song lol, not quite as good as 'Black Eyed Boy' but still nice to make that connection. Think these are my favourite songs by both Bananarama (either this or 'Venus') and Sade (not particularly close out of what I know), enough for them to place ahead of also good as ever picks from the two new wavers. Maybe it's premature to rank this Fontaines song 1st among this bunch but I've already been compelled to listen to it on repeat which is not something I do for many songs x

32 minutes ago, Bror said:

Have just listened through the playlist so here are my rankings x

womenz:

1 MARINA
2 Sophie Ellis-Bextor

3 Kate Bush

4 Robyn

5 Agnes

6 Adele

7 Zara Larsson

8 Leona Lewis

A big divide between the top 4 and the bottom 4 - the Agnes song is actually decent (I remembered it when I heard it, also checked and I ranked it 11th in PFSC so very nearly did vote for it there after all x), the Adele song is ok as well but not really a standout from her, have never been a fan of the last two songs. I forgot how much I liked the Sophie song! Although still an easy win for one of MARINA's best songs x

menz:

1 Gary Numan

2 Calvin Harris

3 Sam Fender

4 Tom Grennan

5 Damien Rice

6 Sam Smith

7 Darin

8 HRVY

Another big divide here but just between the top 6 and bottom 2 so would have been easy picks to eliminate for me - the Darin song is not terrible but not particularly to my taste either, sounded like an Enrique throwaway. I have actually heard that HRVY song before as it sounded familiar, it's shite. All of the top 6 are good picks, another pretty comfortable 1st place for the old man but yay for the moment Tom Grennan locked in and actually made a banger, and that was a lovely discovery from the Riceman.

groopz:

1 Fontaines D.C.

2 Sade

3 Bananarama

4 Depeche Mode

5 New Order

6 Texas

7 Years & Years

8 iamamiwhoami

Groups being the best category as per as 'Sunlight' is definitely by far my favourite of the songs that I'd have thrown out, and 'blue blue' is by far my second favourite of them oops. (Though I did think it was the least good yammy song so far, sorry Pavita, I blame the fact she is ESL so maybe try sending a good Brit or American next time eh). Entirely agreeing with Jaz's decisions on this in the end though as it were! The Texas song is in fact another song I do know quite well but just didn't know it was a Texas song lol, not quite as good as 'Black Eyed Boy' but still nice to make that connection. Think these are my favourite songs by both Bananarama (either this or 'Venus') and Sade (not particularly close out of what I know), enough for them to place ahead of also good as ever picks from the two new wavers. Maybe it's premature to rank this Fontaines song 1st among this bunch but I've already been compelled to listen to it on repeat which is not something I do for many songs x

LOL not me thinking these were your votes for current round and being all... Huh? Agnes and Leona are out!? 😂

52 minutes ago, Spiceboy said:

LOL not me thinking these were your votes for current round and being all... Huh? Agnes and Leona are out!? 😂

Bless, it doesn't take much to confuse you, does it?