Jump to content

Katy vs. Taylor: 1989 v. Teenage Dream

UltraCruelSummer
in Taylor Swift

Featured Replies

Posted

http://i.imgur.com/9vPmp28.png

http://i.imgur.com/Va9TrcV.png

 

Hey guys and welcome to the first round of Katy Perry vs. Taylor Swift which is the battle of both of their biggest albums to date, 1989 v Teenage Dream.

Both albums turned each artist into the world's biggest popstars and set records worldwide. Teenage Dream is the second album in history (the first by a woman) to have five number ones from one album and the third album in history to produce eight top five hits. 1989 was the biggest selling album of 2014 in America and won the Grammy Award for album of the year, making Swift the first female artist to win this award twice.

 

A few quick rules to get through:

- Please vote based on the SONGS. Idc if utterly hate Katy or utterly hate Taylor and want to snub them completely cos of their personality, put that to one side and judge based on the songs.

- Plz try and listen to all the songs. Spotify & Youtube & Apple Music all exist and this is a great way to discover new songs and check out albums you may have not listened to yet!

I think that's everything but I probs forgot something

 

Voting:

- Vote in the same style as BJSC/Eurovision. However we are using the +18 format so please vote in this style (so 18pts/15pts/13pts/12pts/11pts/10pts/9pts/8pts/7pts/6pts/5pts/4pts/3pts/2pts/1pts). This means you are voting for 15 songs and they must be in order of favourite to 15th favourite.

- As this round is in the Taylor forum, please pm your votes to either myself or Liam. We'll probs be using the same spreadsheet to add it up so it doesn't rly matter if you send it to Liam or myself!

 

Deadline: coming soon

 

Tracks: (in alphabetical order, Red = Taylor/1989, Purple = Katy/Teenage Dream)

If anyone wants to make a spotify playlist for this that'd be fab and I'll add a link here!

(I think this is all the songs, plz tell me if I've missed something asap)

All You Had To Do Was Stay

Bad Blood (solo version)

Bad Blood (ft. Kendrick Lamar)

Blank Space

California Gurls (ft. Snoop Dogg)

Circle The Drain

Clean

Dressin Up

E.T. (solo)

E.T. (ft. Kanye West)

Firework

How You Get The Girl

Hummingbird Heartbeat

I Know Places

I Wish You Would

Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F) (solo)

Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F) (ft. Missy Elliott)

New Romantics

Not Like The Movies

Out Of The Woods

Part Of Me

Peacock

Pearl

Shake It Off

Style

Teenage Dream

The One That Got Away

This Love

Welcome To New York

Who Am I Living For

Wide Awake

Wildest Dreams

Wonderland

You are In Love

  • Replies 23
  • Views 3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Voted!

 

Pretty difficult but I think its going to be worse with Prism included as I'm not a massive fan of Teenage Dream to begin with

Voted, I think this is definitely gonna be the hardest of all the comparisons :lol:
This was TOUGH because I love both albums loads. Ended up including 8 Katy tracks and 7 Taylor tracks which is probably right, I do think I slightly prefer Teenage Dream.
Missed the deadline:(

 

 

OMg have I missed the deadline :(

 

 

No it's the 9th :lol:

No it's the 9th :lol:

I know :P Sam's comemnt said 9th August :kink:

 

I will vote on this today tbh I need to both albums have fab tracks on them.

  • 2 weeks later...
This was a tough one as both these albums are fantastic and are the best of their careers, I tried to be as fair as I could to try and include an equal amount from both albums.
Actually finding it really interesting that both of the fourth singles were given single mixes with featured rappers.
Sent! I would've included both versions of one of the songs because it's that good but I'm all for ACR and letting otherwise forgotten songs in~
Go to topic listing

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.