Hate the X Factor winners single type production they put on this! It's a beautiful understated song, and he overdid it far too much :(

That was a really fantastic perf. I'm shocked. He has stage presence despite not looking like a popstar. I hope he's bulimic by week ten.

Oh bugger. Janet is last. Well that's an overrated way to end the show.

 

It may be Kitty. :P

 

-x-

 

Craig, again he was good but not very interesting.

 

Rates oh-eleven

8.5 Misha B - Rolling In The Deep

7.5 James Michael - Ticket To Ride

7.5 2 Shoes - Something Kinda Ooooh

7.0 Frankie Cocozza - The A Team

6.5 Amelia Lily - Billie Jean

6.0 Craig Colton - Jar Of Hearts

5.0 Sophie Habibis - Teenage Dream

5.0 Sami Brookes - Free

5.0 The Risk - She Said

4.5 Nu Vibe - Beautiful People

4.0 Jonjo Kerr - You Really Got Me

2.0 Johnny Robinson - Believe

1.0 Rhythmix - Super Bass

 

N/A Marcus Collins - Moves Like Jagger

I'm very disappointed with Tulisa's song choices tonight - another karaoke performance from The Risk. Didn't like it at all; they're good vocalists, but the performance was weak. Craig is brilliant! Such a good singer, and I love the tone to his voice.

 

Mischa 9/10

Sophie 8.5/10

Craig 8.5/10

Frankie 8/10

Amelia 7.5/10

Sami 7.5/10

2 Shoes 7.5/10

Marcus 7/10

James 7/10

Rhythmix 7/10

The Risk 6.5/10

Jonjo 5/10

Nu Vibe 3/10

Johnny 0/10

They're really bringing out the great performances near the end, aren't they! That was actually properly amazing. If it wasn't for Misha, that would be the performance of the night. I love the song, so I might be a little biased, but that performance was absolutely superb. Really felt something there.

 

Rates

Misha 10/10

Craig 10/10

Marcus 8/10

Sophie 8/10

The Risk 8/10

Sami 7/10

Amelia 6/10

2 Shoes 6/10

Johnny 5/10

Jonjo 4/10

Nu Vibe 4/10

James 2/10

Rhythmix 2/10

Frankie 0/10

 

BTW, Louis, I would love it if JOH gets a #1 out of this, but I can't see it happening. It's already peaked.

01 Misha 9.5/10 - EFFIN YES. I started to dislike Misha recently, and then she did THAT. So glad to hear Rolling In The Deep done differently, loved the production, the whole thing. LOVE.

02 Craig 9/10 - Fantastic. He showed a great range, he could hit the high pitched notes really well. SO impressed, and I'm a really big fan.

03 Sophie 8.5/10 - Not because she sung Katy Perry - but because of how understated and mellow and OOOH BEAUTIFUL it was.

04 The Risk 7.5/10 - Really enjoyed that, and no, I'm not shocked they were good on 'first time together'. The fact they didn't pull up their shirts helped their likeability too.

05 Amelia 7/10 - Verses good, chorus a bit iffy and strained. I did it enjoy it, but probably only enjoyed it loads because I really wanted to love it.

06 Sami 7/10 - It was pretty good, was really good to see her doing something upbeat. Nothing much to say, but I enjoyed it.

07 2 Shoes 6.5/10 - Gonna rate them on the singing/performance, rather than the fact they're Essex girls. It was good, but only good. Essex Booty Luv FTW.

08 Frankie 6.5/10 - A bit bland, but he was decent - and this is coming from somebody who hates him. It all felt a bit too slow - it was like he wanted to speed it up, but the backing track wouldn't let him. That did suit him though.

09 Rhythmix 6/10 - Better than I expected. It was a bit messy, and the harmonies were off - but there was something weirdly enjoyable about it.

10 Marcus 6/10 - So many 'just good' performances tonight. It was decent, the vocals were very good - but not that interesting. I'll forget about that by the end.

11 Nu Vibe 6/10 - Decent, but it was all a bit too energetic, in that it affected their vocals. And, I've deducted a point for that irritating shirt lift. SRSLY?! WHY?!

12 Jonjo 5/10 - He's not bad, but there's no way to sing that song and not sound karaoke? Poor song choice, decently sung - but overall, pretty forgettable!

13 Jonny 5/10 - 1.5 for vocals, 3.5 for humour. I just kinda sat there shaking my head and laughing. It's exactly how I see Mikey doing a performance, if he were to go on X Factor.

14 James 2/10 - I REALLY wanted him to come out really good, and not be eliminated, because I really like him. But it was boring, and flat.

 

Craig - Wow.....where did that come from. Really really loved that....actually started getting a bit shivery at some points when he was singing that. Big surprise for me tonight. 9/10

 

Craig - 9/10

Sophie - 8/10

Sami - 7.5/10

Misha - 7.5/10

Amelia Lily - 7.5/10

Marcus - 7/10

Johnny - 6/10

Rhythmix - 6/10

James - 5.5/10

The Risk - 5.5/10

2 Shoes - 5/10

Nu Vibe - 3.5/10

Frankie - 2/10

Jonjo - 0/10

 

I can't believe I wanted him to be in the four leaving....

Edited October 8, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf

Craig - He really is growing at me massively. His performance at judges houses and tonight were really rather good. His vocals are very good and it was a great song choice actually. - 8.0/10.0

 

Rates:

Misha - 9.5

Sami - 9.0

The Risk - 9.0

Sophie - 8.5

Craig - 8.0

Marcus - 7.5

Amelia - 7.0

2 Shoes - 6.5

Jonjo - 6.0

Frankie - 6.0

Rhythmix - 5.5

James - 5.0

Nu Vibe - 5.0

Johnny Robinson - 3.5

I just spotted a LOOK in Craig's eye when he went in for that hug with Dermot. ALL CONSUMING LUST.

 

09.0 Misha

08.5 Sophie

08.5 Craig

08.0 Marcus

08.0 Sami

 

Those lot are well away from the rest of the pack at this stage.

 

That was a really fantastic perf. I'm shocked. He has stage presence despite not looking like a popstar. I hope he's bulimic by week ten.

Sooner than that with Gary starving him.

Craig: Wow great performance, 10/10, and I've just inhaled the Music Week wrapper bag.

I imagine 'Jar of Hearts' will go top 3 on iTunes on the basis of that performance...

Craig Coulton - Jar Of Hearts

 

Sorry Marcus, but Craig has sang the best of all the boys tonight. It was last weekend when he sang 'Halo' that I started taking more notice of Craig. I think he's got a brilliant singing voice and of all the boys, he's still my fave but Marcus could well be the underdog. Very impressed.

 

Mischa B = 9/10

Craig Coulton = 8/10

Marcus Collins = 7/10

Amelia Lily = 7/10

Sami Brookes = 7/10

Sophie Habibis = 5/10

Rhythmix = 4/10

The Risk = 3/10

2 Shoes = 2/10

Nu Vibe = 2/10

Frankie Cocozza = 2/10

Johnny Robinson = 0/10

James Michael = 0/10

Jonjo Kerr = 0/10

The Risk are the best group by a mile (well 2 Shoes should have been better :P ) Craig was very good. I don't remember him being the comedy guy?

 

Sophie-10

Mischa-9

Craig-9

Sami-8.5

Marcus-8

Amelia-8

The Risk-7.5

Jonjo-7

James-7

2 Shoes-5

Rhythmix-5

Nu Vibe-3

Johnny-2

Frankie-1

 

 

All about Craig and Misha.

Misha B: 09.0

Craig Colton 08.5

Sophie Habibis: 08.0

Marcus Collins: 07.5

Amelia Lily: 07.0

The Risk: 07.0

Frankie Cocozza: 06.5

Rythmix: 06.0

Nu Vibe: 06.0

Sami Brookes: 06.0

2 Shoes: 05.5

James Michael: 05.5

Jonjo Kerr: 05.0

Johnny Robinson: 04.0

 

 

 

Craig: Wow great performance, 10/10, and I've just inhaled the Music Week wrapper bag.

...

Really good honest performance there. The slight over production and backing vocals ruined it a little for me.

 

Silas rates - Wk1

 

Misha - 11/10

2 Shoes - 10/10

Sami - 9/10

Craig - 8.5/10

Sophie - 8/10

Marcus - 8/10

Nu Vibe - 7/10

The Risk - 6.8/10

Cuntie - 6.5/10

Amelia - 6/10

Rhythmix - 4/10

Jonjo - 3/10

James - 2/10

Johnny - 0/10

Wow, Craig was amazing.

I bet James is stuffed tomorrow night for sure now.

Edited October 8, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf