Janet is like watching Ginger paint dry just dull and bland, Vickers had more life.

First Glee, now this.

 

:(

She looks exactly like Florence Welch! Hasn't got half as good vocals though.

NOT AS BAD AS I EXPECTED. 7/10.

Kitty's vocal started off good, but became a bit shaky throughout. Stacey did it a lot better though. Janet is still a screeching mess. I really dislike her vocal, and unfortunately, she butchered a very good song.

 

Mischa 9/10

Sophie 8.5/10

Craig 8.5/10

Frankie 8/10

Amelia 7.5/10

Sami 7.5/10

2 Shoes 7.5/10

Marcus 7/10

Kitty 7/10

James 7/10

Rhythmix 7/10

The Risk 6.5/10

Janet 5/10

Jonjo 5/10

Nu Vibe 3/10

Johnny 0/10

01 Misha 9.5/10 - EFFIN YES. I started to dislike Misha recently, and then she did THAT. So glad to hear Rolling In The Deep done differently, loved the production, the whole thing. LOVE.

02 Janet 9.5/10 - I just love her - I know others don't, but I just find her voice so beautiful and captivating.

03 Kitty 9.5/10 - I hate her. But, that was amazing. Vocally superb, she didn't over-do it. I'm not gonna compare it to Stacey's - I'm just gonna enjoy it for what it is.

04 Craig 9/10 - Fantastic. He showed a great range, he could hit the high pitched notes really well. SO impressed, and I'm a really big fan.

05 Sophie 8.5/10 - Not because she sung Katy Perry - but because of how understated and mellow and OOOH BEAUTIFUL it was.

06 The Risk 7.5/10 - Really enjoyed that, and no, I'm not shocked they were good on 'first time together'. The fact they didn't pull up their shirts helped their likeability too.

07 Amelia 7/10 - Verses good, chorus a bit iffy and strained. I did it enjoy it, but probably only enjoyed it loads because I really wanted to love it.

08 Sami 7/10 - It was pretty good, was really good to see her doing something upbeat. Nothing much to say, but I enjoyed it.

09 2 Shoes 6.5/10 - Gonna rate them on the singing/performance, rather than the fact they're Essex girls. It was good, but only good. Essex Booty Luv FTW.

10 Frankie 6.5/10 - A bit bland, but he was decent - and this is coming from somebody who hates him. It all felt a bit too slow - it was like he wanted to speed it up, but the backing track wouldn't let him. That did suit him though.

11 Rhythmix 6/10 - Better than I expected. It was a bit messy, and the harmonies were off - but there was something weirdly enjoyable about it.

12 Marcus 6/10 - So many 'just good' performances tonight. It was decent, the vocals were very good - but not that interesting. I'll forget about that by the end.

13 Nu Vibe 6/10 - Decent, but it was all a bit too energetic, in that it affected their vocals. And, I've deducted a point for that irritating shirt lift. SRSLY?! WHY?!

14 Jonjo 5/10 - He's not bad, but there's no way to sing that song and not sound karaoke? Poor song choice, decently sung - but overall, pretty forgettable!

15 Jonny 5/10 - 1.5 for vocals, 3.5 for humour. I just kinda sat there shaking my head and laughing. It's exactly how I see Mikey doing a performance, if he were to go on X Factor.

16 James 2/10 - I REALLY wanted him to come out really good, and not be eliminated, because I really like him. But it was boring, and flat.

Edited October 8, 201113 yr by ROBOT

Middle of the road performance from Janet, she has got potential to grow 6.5/10

At the risk of Jark-related death, she is SO MUCH BETTER THAN EVERYONE ELSE (except Misha) it's unbelievable. She has to win.

 

Rates oh-eleven

10.0 Janet Devlin - Fix You

8.5 Misha B - Rolling In The Deep

8.0 Kitty Brucknell - Who Wants To Live Forever

7.5 James Michael - Ticket To Ride

7.5 2 Shoes - Something Kinda Ooooh

7.0 Frankie Cocozza - The A Team

6.5 Amelia Lily - Billie Jean

6.0 Craig Colton - Jar Of Hearts

5.0 Sophie Habibis - Teenage Dream

5.0 Sami Brookes - Free

5.0 The Risk - She Said

4.5 Nu Vibe - Beautiful People

4.0 Jonjo Kerr - You Really Got Me

2.0 Johnny Robinson - Believe

1.0 Rhythmix - Super Bass

 

N/A Marcus Collins - Moves Like Jagger

Janet is a complete one trick pony. But it's a good single trick to have, she's just vastly overrated for someone with no real diversity.

 

 

Silas rates - Wk1

 

Misha - 11/10

2 Shoes - 10/10

Sami - 9/10

Craig - 8.5/10

Kitty - 8.5/10

Janet - 8/10

Sophie - 8/10

Marcus - 8/10

Nu Vibe - 7/10

The Risk - 6.8/10

Cuntie - 6.5/10

Amelia - 6/10

Rhythmix - 4/10

Jonjo - 3/10

James - 2/10

Johnny - 0/10

Janet was bad but not the worst.

 

Sophie-10

Mischa-9

Craig-9

Sami-8.5

Marcus-8

Amelia-8

Kitty-7.5

The Risk-7

Jonjo-7

James-7

2 Shoes-5

Rhythmix-5

Janet-3.5

Nu Vibe-3

Johnny-2

Frankie-1

 

So who SHOULD go tomorrow: Janet, Frankie, Nu Vibe, Johnny

Who WILL go tomorrow: Sophie, James, Rhymix, Jonjo

I really just see her as Diana Vickers pt.II .... they're almost identical from styling, vocals to song choices!

I wish I hadn't predicted Amelia to go now - I'm really not convinced she's staying tomorrow, for some reason :lol:

To go home tomorrow:

 

Boys: James Michael

Girls: Sophie (its obvious)

Groups: Rhytmnmix

Overs: Jonjo

Janet - Fix You

 

I still don't understand why everyone is saying she's unique. My nickname for her (Ellie Vickers) is surely apt? Well, she reminds me of them - didn't help when her first audition was a note for note copy of Ellie Goulding's cover of 'Your Song'. At least her version of 'Fix You' was good but compared to Mischa and Craig she misses the mark.

 

Mischa B = 9/10

Craig Coulton = 8/10

Marcus Collins = 7/10

Kitty Brucknell = 7/10

Amelia Lily = 7/10

Sami Brookes = 7/10

Janet Devlin = 6/10

Sophie Habibis = 5/10

Rhythmix = 4/10

The Risk = 3/10

2 Shoes = 2/10

Nu Vibe = 2/10

Frankie Cocozza = 2/10

Johnny Robinson = 0/10

James Michael = 0/10

Jonjo Kerr = 0/10

 

Predictions to go home tomorrow night:

 

Boys: James Michael

Girls: Sophie Habibis

Groups: 2 Shoes

Overs: Jonjo Kerr

Ok, final rate. Janet was good. I love the song, it clearly wasn't up to the original, but a rather enjoyable one nonetheless. I really don't envy Kelly right now. Having to decide...

 

Rates

Misha 10/10

Craig 10/10

Marcus 8/10

Sophie 8/10

The Risk 8/10

Sami 7/10

Janet 7/10

Amelia 6/10

Kitty 6/10

2 Shoes 6/10

Johnny 5/10

Jonjo 4/10

Nu Vibe 4/10

James 2/10

Rhythmix 2/10

Frankie 0/10

 

Were it up to me, I'd get rid of Frankie, Jonjo, Nu Vibe and ... I really don't know.

 

I'd keep Rhythmix, because they have some sort of potential over Nu Vibe. I wouldn't mind if James goes either. My rating system is suggesting Amelia to go out of the girls, but she has so much potential. Janet to go?

 

Pretty much half-and-half opening show. Misha and Craig were stunning. They've got to be the ones to beat now.

To go home;

 

Groups: Nu Vibe

Girls: Sophie (:()

Overs: Johnjo

Boys: James

Misha B: 09.0

Craig Colton 08.5

Sophie Habibis: 08.0

Janet Devlin: 07.5

Marcus Collins: 07.5

Amelia Lily: 07.0

The Risk: 07.0

Kitty Brucknell: 07.0

Frankie Cocozza: 06.5

Rythmix: 06.0

Nu Vibe: 06.0

Sami Brookes: 06.0

2 Shoes: 05.5

James Michael: 05.5

Jonjo Kerr: 05.0

Johnny Robinson: 04.0

 

Sophie and James will be gone for definate. 2 Shoes/Nu Vibe for the groups.. More likely to be 2 Shoes and then I have no idea with the Overs

Janet - I love her voice and she's been my favourite coming into the lives. I do feel like Sophie just beat her out as the best girl tonight though for me. 8/10

 

Craig - 9/10

Sophie - 8/10

Janet - 7.5/10

Sami - 7.5/10

Misha - 7.5/10

Amelia Lily - 7.5/10

Marcus - 7/10

Kitty - 6.5/10

Johnny - 6/10

Rhythmix - 6/10

James - 5.5/10

The Risk - 5.5/10

2 Shoes - 5/10

Nu Vibe - 3.5/10

Frankie - 2/10

Jonjo - 0/10

 

Based on these scores, I want these acts to leave tomorrow:

 

Girls: Amelia Lily

Boys: Frankie

Overs: Jonjo

Groups: Nu Vibe

 

Amelia Lily & Misha were so close for me tonight though. I don't really know at the moment. I want either to go and neither to go at the same time. :S I wish Jonjo could be eliminated four times over instead.

 

I can only pray now that Kelly has faith in Sophie. :(

Edited October 8, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf

Janet - Her voice annoys me so much, however she was in tune and I suppose she seems like a sweet person, but the other girls are so much better, shame one of them has to over her tomorrow. - 4.5/10.0

 

Rates:

Misha - 9.5

Sami - 9.0

The Risk - 9.0

Sophie - 8.5

Craig - 8.0

Kitty - 7.5

Marcus - 7.5

Amelia - 7.0

2 Shoes - 6.5

Jonjo - 6.0

Frankie - 6.0

Rhythmix - 5.5

James - 5.0

Nu Vibe - 5.0

Janet - 4.5

Johnny Robinson - 3.5

So I'm gonna say Amelia, Rhythmix, Craig and Johnny to go out tomorrow. Amelia and Craig weren't my least favourite performances in their group but I think Sophie has the potential to be much better with a better song choice and my opinion of Marcus' performance is practically invalided by my blind hatred of the song, so I'll give him another chance next week. Rhythmix and Johnny were both horrendous and must die imminently.

 

Not sure about who WILL go out - I'll predict James, Amelia, Jonjo and 2 Shoes. But that'll be wrong.

Edited October 8, 201113 yr by Bré