04.5 Nu Vibe 'With Or Without You' [They really are not a boyband! I haven't seen the results yet, but I have a feeling that already they'll be bottom 2!]

07.0 Sami Brookes 'I Will Always Love You' [she belted the big notes, for sure. But that was very karaoke! (As per)]

07.0 Craig Colton 'Best Thing I Never Had' [He did far better last week. Wasn't too fussed about this performance and I can't get over how much his mannerisms remind me of Adele though! Lol]

08.0 Janet Devlin '(I Can't Help) Falling In Love With You' [One of the most beautiful songs ever and Janet did it very well. But her performances are getting predictable and "same old, same old".]

01.0 Frankie Cocozza 'The Scientist' [That was abysmal. :mellow: He IS capable of doing so much better, but his song choices are too predictable. He should have nailed this really, but it was awful and bland.]

00.0 Johnny Robinson 'Can't Get You Out of My Head' [That was... I dunno. He looked and sounded pretty bored to me. He's terrible.]

06.5 Marcus Collins 'Russian Roulette' [Love Marcus, usually. But that was my least favourite performance I've seen from him :( He sang it all in one key. I dunno. I think he could have done better. Maybe my standards were set too high for him as I have him down as the true under dog.]

09.0 Rhythmix 'I'm Like A Bird' [That was incredible. I loved what they did with the song and I am loving the vibe and freshness they are bringing to this competition for girl groups.]

05.5 Misha Bryan 'Would I Lie to You?' [i think I have found the problem I have with her, I just don't think I "get" her. I don't really know or understand her and I find her vocals generally terrible and monotonous. I know me and Doug are generally on our own with our opinions of her, but meh.]

08.5 The Risk 'Just the Way You Are' [i like what they did with the song! They gel so, so well together as a group and I'm pretty much looking forward to what else they can and probably will bring to the table in this competition.]

08.5 Sophie Habibis 'Wherever You Will Go' [Predictable song choice, due to the cover version that's going around, but that was still brilliant. The only problem is, I can't give her a much higher mark as it wouldn't be fair on Frankie or Janet, considering we've heard it before from her. But beautiful performance nonetheless.]

09.0 Kitty Brucknall 'It's Oh So Quiet' [i enjoyed that, far more than I ever should have! It was brilliant. Whether you love her or hate her she brings something completely different to the X factor and it's of star quality.]

 

ORDER:

01| Rhythmix

02| Kitty Brucknall

03| Sophie Habibis

04| The Risk

05| Janet Devlin

06| Craig Colton

07| Sami Brookes

08| Marcus Collins

09| Misha Bryan

10| Nu Vibe

11| Frankie Coccoza

12| Johnny Robinson

 

Just about to watch the results (not read this thread yet or seen anything) but I have a feeling Nu Vibe and Johnny could be in danger and I have to say I will be pretty pleased with them two as bottom 2! :D

My 2 least favourite acts appeared in the bottom 2. FABULOUS :D

Frankie and Nu Vibe were rightfully in the bottom two last night. Frankie in particular has annoyed me since his first audition and he MURDERED 'Red' (which I adore.) HE'S JUST NOT GOOD. I'm glad the public got it right so soon in the competition and have probably shocked Gary into realising he's not as popular OR as good as the judges have so far made out.

Silas, I don't want to steal your thunder and open a week 3 thread because you have created the other two, so could you start one please.

 

Theme been announced:

Motown/R&B

 

 

 

Misha B and Marcus

should storm it this week and

Janet and Frankie

should be a car crashes. Bring it on.

Edited October 17, 201113 yr by Davidson

Silas, I don't want to steal your thunder and open a week 3 thread because you have created the other two, so could you start one please.

 

Theme been announced:

Motown/R&B

 

 

 

Misha B and Marcus

should storm it this week and

Janet and Frankie

should be a car crashes. Bring it on.

 

I hope the theme is right a huge fan and hopefully we will finally see Marcus shine and Misha smash it.American Idol also did it this year and it was very good.

what a horrible theme. however I'd love janet to prove everyone wrong here and prove that she can do something upbeat. her part in 'hello' last night was really good and surprised me. maybe there is a chance?

As someone suggested on DS, Janet would be great doing Forget You. She did the song on one of her YouTube vids - amazing!!! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZhDccH7X40

As someone suggested on DS, Janet would be great doing Forget You. She did the song on one of her YouTube vids - amazing!!! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZhDccH7X40

oh yeah, I forgot about that!

she

did that really well, but

would that not really make it a bit more of a predictable choice for her?

Speaking of Janet, I noticed the DS morons gave up on Matt Cardle and have started picking on Janet for walking off stage when she got through. Apparently not blubbering and hugging everyone and basically making a complete tool of herself makes her come across awfully. I have to say, I'm no fan of Janet, but are people seriously sad enough to moan about that?

On DS they are yes. The same people who had BURNING hatred for Josie Gibson for no reason, and moan about how fixed X-Factor is, and yet still cling onto it as their entire life.