Jump to content

Featured Replies

Luke was good, but I really really hate "Your Song". I've heard it way too many times now. 7/10.

 

Hannah 7/10.

Luke 7/10.

  • Replies 310
  • Views 8.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

bit better than last week, sounds very middle of the road though. 5/10

02. Luke Friend | 'Your Song'

 

Good song choice for him I thought. It wasn't "great" but it was good enough, I thought. Again, not his best performance (but 'Kiss From A Rose' is going to be very hard for him to top in all honesty), it was a good version of the song.

 

07.0 out of 10.0

Now I think that was a perfect match of singer and song. That's easily the best he's sounded in the competition thus far.

:lol: Could we have given much more opposite comments?

:lol: Could we have given much more opposite comments?

 

I did think that when I read yours. I seem to be in my own WORLD the last few weeks re. X Factor.

I adore "Your Song", both the Elton original and Ellie cover, but I really wasn't feeling his voice on that at all. :(
Does Mrs O realise that Keith Richards has sung lead vocals on at least 1 song on every Rolling Stones album since the late 60s?

 

Given the state she's in I don't think she realises quite where she is, let alone anything more challenging.

Hannah Barrett - Satisfaction | 5/10

Luke Friend - Your Song | 9.5/10

Sam Bailey - Something | 10/10

 

SENSATIONAL once again :wub:

Now that's what I call a perfect performance 10/10

Sam B - 8.5

Definitely not her best performance. It was very previsible I don't know

 

 

Sam B - 8.5

Luke - 7.5

Hannah - 2.0

Completely "back to form", although that doesn't really make sense, cos she is fab every week. But, that felt like it returned to The Power Of Love standard to me, really effortless but superb from start to finish vocally, rather than the 8.5/10 feels I've been getting in a few weeks. 9.5/10

I didn't really like it. Most likely because I didn't know the song. Vocally on point as usual though. 8/10.

 

Sam B 8/10.

Hannah 7/10.

Luke 7/10.

But yeah that was good, I just caught myself comparing it to DSB and obv she came off poorly

03. Sam Bailey | 'Something'

 

It was powerful, but this is the first time I felt like she struggled with it. It was still vocally on point and in tune, but there was a sign of struggle at points. Better than her 'Make You Feel My Love' performance, but it's her second worst performance for me.

 

08.5 out of 10.0

10.0 Luke Friend

09.0 Sam Bailey - what a VOCAL. So effortless too. Her best in a few weeks.

08.5 Hannah Barrett

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.