Is it me or is this sounding like a Westlife performance without stools, it felt a bit ropey in places 3.5/10

The gospel choir at the end was literally the only good thing about that performance.

 

Nicholas McDonald - Just the Way You Are | 8/10

Sam Bailey - How Will I Know? | 10/10

Tamera Foster - We Found Love | 7/10

Luke Friend - Skinny Love | 9.5/10

Rough Copy - Every Little Step/She's Got That Vibe | 0.5/10

 

Nicholas McDonald - Greatest Day | 3.5/10

Sam Bailey - Clown | 11/10

Luke Friend - I Will Wait | 10/10

Tamera Foster - The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face | 9.5/10

Rough Copy - I Believe I Can Fly | 1/10

That was an improvement vocally on the first performance TOGETHER but were dodgy vocally again. It was good, but extremely predictable - they're definitely the weak link for me now. 6.5/10

And BEST GROUP EVER ON X FACTOR. Oh, DO ONE NICOLE.

Tamera

Luke

Sam

 

=====

 

Bottom 2

Rough Copy

Nicholas

10.0 Luke Friend (2)

10.0 Luke Friend (1)

10.0 Nicholas McDonald (1)

09.5 Nicholas McDonald (2)

09.5 Sam Bailey (2)

09.0 Tamera Foster (2)

09.0 Sam Bailey (1)

08.5 Rough Copy (1)

08.0 Rough Copy (2) - hardly paid attention but it was good. Not great, but good.

07.5 Tamera Foster (1)

Edited November 30, 201311 yr by JosephStyles

And BEST GROUP EVER ON X FACTOR. Oh, DO ONE NICOLE.

 

Best MALE group MAYBE, vocally anyway. 1D were much better overall.

And BEST GROUP EVER ON X FACTOR. Oh, DO ONE NICOLE.

Nicole's love for Rough Copy is just so RANDOM. She's a bit of a lost cause this year. :lol:

19.5 Luke Friend

19.0 Nicholas McDonald

17.0 Tamera Foster

16.5 Sam Bailey

12.0 Rough Copy

08 Tamera Foster - The First Time Ever Saw Your Face

08 Tamera Foster – We Found Love

08 Luke Friend - Skinny Love

07 Nicholas McDonald - Just The Way You Are

06 Luke Friend – I Will Wait

06 Sam Bailey – How Will I Know?

06 Nicholas McDonald – Greatest Day

06 Sam Bailey - Clown

06 Rough Copy – Every Little Step/She’s Got That Vibe

05 Rough Copy - I Believe I Can Fly

Nicole's love for Rough Copy is just so RANDOM. She's a bit of a lost cause this year. :lol:

 

 

Well I can see Nicole saving them if they are bottom 2 along with Nicholas tomorrow, depends which way Sharon votes.

Sam Bailey | 21.0

Luke Friend | 19.5

Tamera Foster | 17.0

Nicholas McDonald | 11.5

Rough Copy | 1.5

That was so dull and lifeless, it made Nicholas' performances look like a rave concert... They didn't seem to put anything into it at all, mehhh.

 

Round 2 rank:

01 Tamera Foster - First Time Ever I Saw Your Face 10/10

02 Sam Bailey - Clown 10/10

03 Luke Friend - I Will Wait 10/10

04 Nicholas McDonald - Greatest Day 3/10

05 Rough Copy - I Believe I Can Fly 2/10

 

Overall:

01 Tamera Foster - The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face 10/10

02 Sam Bailey - Clown 10/10

03 Luke Friend - I Will Wait 10/10

04 Luke Friend - Skinny Love 9.5/10

05 Sam Bailey - How Will I Know? 9.5/10

06 Tamera Foster - We Found Love 8.5/10

07 Nicholas McDonald - Just The Way You Are 5.5/10

08 Nicholas McDonald - Greatest Day 3/10

09 Rough Copy - I Believe I Can Fly 2/10

10 Rough Copy - She's Got The Vibe 1/10

 

01= Sam Bailey 19.5/20

01= Luke Friend 19.5/20

03 Tamera Foster 18.5/20

04 Nicholas McDonald 8.5/20

05 Rough Copy 3/20

 

Still think Tamera might be bottom 2... :(

Engelbert Humperdinck *.* HOW RANDOM

Best MALE group MAYBE, vocally anyway. 1D were much better overall.

 

I would argue JLS were much better vocally.

And BEST GROUP EVER ON X FACTOR. Oh, DO ONE NICOLE.

I honestly prefer Jedward.

 

JLS are certainly better vocally, even if I try and look objectively.

10.0 Luke - Skinny Love

9.5 Luke - I Will Wait - somehow made this song bareable to listen to

8.5 Sam - Clown

8.5 Tamera - First Time Ever I Saw Your Face - one of her best for me

7.0 Sam - How Will I Know

6.5 Nicholas - Greatest Day - was ok but forgettable

6.5 Tamera - We Found Love - step up from the last couple weeks, but it's an energetic song and she didn't really add any energy to it

5.0 Rough Copy - Every Little Step - kinda liked it in a cheesy way, but not enough for me to want them to go any further

4.0 Nicholas - Just The Way You Are - yawn

1.0 Rough Copy - I Believe I Can Fly - doesn't help that this is one of my least favourite songs ever. do not get why the judges love them so much

 

Didn't expect Luke to become my favourite this series, but he's really grown on me the last couple weeks.

 

Hoping Nicholas or Rough Copy leave tomorrow. Doesn't matter which one. Though, I'd love it if Barlow had no acts in the semi-finals :lol:

Pretty great night! Luke & Sam were miles ahead of everyone else tonight I felt

 

Nicholas McDonald - Just the Way You Are - 6/10

Sam Bailey - How Will I Know? - 8/10

Tamera Foster - We Found Love - 7/10

Luke Friend - Skinny Love - 10/10

Rough Copy - Every Little Step/She's Got That Vibe - 6/10

 

Nicholas McDonald - Greatest Day - 6/10

Sam Bailey - Clown - 10/10

Luke Friend - I Will Wait | 10/10

Tamera Foster - The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face - 6/10

Rough Copy - I Believe I Can Fly - 7/10

Edited November 30, 201311 yr by Jade

Digital Spy poll (who sang best):

 

Sam Bailey - 37.14%

Luke Friend - 29.43%

Tamera Foster - 16.30%

Rough Copy - 10.36%

Nicholas McDonald - 6.77%

Is there a bottom 2 this week? I hope Rough Copy leave.

 

Sam Bailey & Luke were amazing last night.