Jump to content

Featured Replies

Sad to see Lisa so low but Air are doing very well so nothing else matters.

 

EDIT: OOoooh, congrats Kylienips! :cheer:

Glad there are so many Cherry Blossom Girl fans here :D

 

Very pleased with 2nd on the re-run! Plus great winner of course.

  • Replies 59
  • Views 6.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

WHAT!!!! :o I actually won something... second time lucky.
Largely very agreeable results there! The right song won (and a very good top 5 as a whole) and the right song came last. Shame about 'Igri Bez Granici' getting so little support, one of the very few decent discoveries, though I can see why it did so badly.
YES! :cheer: Congrats Mart!n!! The Verve is a worthy winner of what was generally a frightfully horrific contest. :nocheer:

Air snatching that 2nd place *.*

 

Bittersweet Symphony is pretty much iconic, very much a rightful winner. Great top 3 overall!

 

God, those results are worse than the originals! At least a few discoveries won out the first time around...still, well done to Miku on finally winning something, and lovely to see Cherry Blossom Girl (which wasn't to my taste but was at least something new!) come out high. I'm quite surprised literally nobody other than myself had Say It's Possible in their top ten, especially with this dreadful a line-up.

 

Ouch at Katharine McPhee's fall as well. It's not a classic winner but it's pretty Buzzjack bait as a song, and it's way more enjoyable than most of the uninspired line-up here was. Negative points is really surprising!

 

When's III? I'm frothing away waiting for X to roll around, so it'd be nice if we could fit in the smaller contests a bit more quickly - or is there already a timetable?

CHRIST The Verve's vocals are annoying (not too much of a problem given the rest of the tracks!!). The Air track was lovely and not something I've actually heard before, and I was reminded that 8+ years ago, Pink wasn't too bad! So obviously not a discovery, but I don't feel bad for giving 10 points to that reminder.

 

There were some complete HORRORS here, including almost every B-side Leona Lewis-esque ballad (thank christ these have died a swift death recently), Clea, Aly & AJ, and artists like September, Girls Aloud and Dragonette that could all do better.

When's III? I'm frothing away waiting for X to roll around, so it'd be nice if we could fit in the smaller contests a bit more quickly - or is there already a timetable?

There is a very flexible timetable. We're alternating Re:LOADED and themed spin-off's throughout the year at roughly one a month with a break for BJFest and TBO (as they are technically spin-offs).

 

Might change it for next year but for now we're just seeing how it goes. ^_^

  • Author
God, those results are worse than the originals! At least a few discoveries won out the first time around...still, well done to Miku on finally winning something, and lovely to see Cherry Blossom Girl (which wasn't to my taste but was at least something new!) come out high. I'm quite surprised literally nobody other than myself had Say It's Possible in their top ten, especially with this dreadful a line-up.

 

Ouch at Katharine McPhee's fall as well. It's not a classic winner but it's pretty Buzzjack bait as a song, and it's way more enjoyable than most of the uninspired line-up here was. Negative points is really surprising!

 

When's III? I'm frothing away waiting for X to roll around, so it'd be nice if we could fit in the smaller contests a bit more quickly - or is there already a timetable?

 

I was thinking the same about Everything You Said as you with Say It's Possible (which is nice but a bit inessential). It sounds pretty Buzzjack friendly to me, even if it is a bit sub-Kelly C. :( I thought about entering Cori myself back in 2012.

 

III with 26 songs and IV with only 20 should be a breeze to do soon. Very nice for filling in the months where there isn't a themed spinoff planned. I'm glad they're finally on a timetable of sorts.

Definitely the best possible winner despite it's obvious classic status - would've had an even bigger lead if I'd been able to vote for ten songs :P I will hopefully be able to vote in one of these soon.
I really can't see that happening at all. Does give an insight as to what the contest would be like sans veto though. (Hideous)

just :manson:

Don't Stop The Music was cheap by BJSC II standards FFS

I didn't see you complaining at cheap entries succeeding in Reloaded I when it was a Rontvia + Ashton a.k.a. an intrepid, inventive and obscure Delta Goodrem + Sugababes top two - in fact, you were celebrating!

 

Belatedly pointing this out but I had to SORRY.

Edited by Harve

9th is way better than 18th so yay for that! Stumble is a gorgeous song. Well done Martin and I'm glad the incredibly pedestrian Dangerous did nothing this time around.
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 1 month later...
  • 1 month later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.