Jump to content

Featured Replies

Lead Singles Rank:

 

01. 'My Life Would Suck Without You' >> Shut it, Jark! ;D <<

02. 'Underneath The Tree'

03. 'Breakaway'

04. 'Heartbeat Song'

05. 'Mr. Know It All'

06. 'Never Again'

07. 'Catch My Breath'

08. 'Miss Independent'

  • Replies 299
  • Views 17.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

01. 'My Life Would Suck Without You'

02. 'Breakaway'

03. Mr. Know It All'

04. 'Underneath The Tree'

05. 'Heartbeat Song'

06. 'Never Again'

07. 'Catch My Breath'

08. 'Miss Independent'

 

It's funny, so many of her lead singles have been far inferior to their followups.

 

- This was just on Capital, too.

Edited by Joe.

1. My Life Would Suck Without You

2. Breakaway

3. Never Again

4. Underneath The Tree

5. Heartbeat Song

6. Miss Independent

7. Mr Know It All

8. Catch My Breath

I love and enjoy all of those except CMB which is a bit average for me.

Edited by Rob S

1. My Life Would Suck Without You

2. Breakaway

3. Underneath The Tree

4. Catch My Breath

5. Heartbeat Song

6. Miss Independent

7. Mr Know It All

8. Never Again

 

Her lead singles have never been particularly strong have they? Only the top 3, 4 with a stretch, are good to flawless

Yeah, it's mainly just that 2/3 of her most iconic singles have been followups.

 

I'm really hoping 'Heartbeat Song' does well, and some comes back with another iconic single next.

01 Never Again

02 My Life Would Suck Without You

03 Breakaway

04 Mr Know It All

05 Catch My Breath

06 Underneath The Tree

07 Miss Independent

08 Heartbeat Song

 

The top 2 are both in my top 40 songs of all time, and Breakaway isn't far out. The rest are still 10/10 pretty much, except Miss Independent which is maybe a 9 and Heartbeat Song is 8 or 8.5.

01. Never Again

02. My Life Would Suck Without You

03. Heartbeat Song

04. Breakaway

05. Catch My Breath

06. Miss Independent

07. Mr. Know It All

 

Never Again slays lives.

01. Breakaway

02. Miss Independent

03. My Life Would Suck Without You

04. Never Again

05. Catch My Breath

06. Underneath the Tree

07. Mr. Know It All

08. Heartbeat Song

 

 

Yeah, it's mainly just that 2/3 of her most iconic singles have been followups.

 

I'm really hoping 'Heartbeat Song' does well, and some comes back with another iconic single next.

Already Gone, Stronger, People Like Us and Because of You slay all her leadsingles tbh

1. Never Again

2. Catch My Breath

3. Breakaway

4. Underneath The Tree

5. My Life Would Suck Without You

6. Miss Independent

7. Mr. Know It All

8. Heartbeat Song

 

I do love them all, although really only the top 3 are amazing, most of her 2nd or 3rd singles from the albums are normally better imo

Advance warning, anyone placing My Life and Never Again below this risks a warning tbh. Such taste shouldn't be displayed in public :smoke:

1. Catch my breath

2. Underneath the tree

3. Mr know it all

4. My life would suck without you

5. Never again

6. Heartbeat song

7. Breakaway

8. Miss Independent

  1. "Breakaway"
  2. "My Life Would Suck Without You"
  3. "Catch My Breath"
  4. "Underneath the Tree"
  5. "Never Again"
  6. "Miss Independent"
  7. "Heartbeat Song"
  8. "Mr. Know It All"

though with a big gap between "Breakaway" and "My Life". I love "Breakaway" because it made ten-year-old me want to do wingspan movements every time I heard it. Also they showed the video on Disney Channel every two hours back then and it's so endearingly 2004 with its awkward Princess Diaries 2 tie-in (videos for movie tie-ins today would be too self-aware to have their singers attend a fake movie premiere I feel like).

Play-listed on Capital!

 

I actually didn't expect her to ever get major support in the UK again so having Capital and (probably) radio 1 on board is great. Just wish I enjoyed the song a bit more.

01. 'My Life Would Suck Without You'

02. 'Breakaway'

03. Mr. Know It All'

04. 'Underneath The Tree'

05. 'Heartbeat Song'

06. 'Never Again'

07. 'Catch My Breath'

08. 'Miss Independent'

 

It's funny, so many of her lead singles have been far inferior to their followups.

 

- This was just on Capital, too.

 

Cannot agree with this more!

 

For me, I think Never Again and this are probably her weakest leads.

 

EDIT: Will rank later on when can be bothered :lol:

Edited by Sean.

Play-listed on Capital!

 

I actually didn't expect her to ever get major support in the UK again so having Capital and (probably) radio 1 on board is great. Just wish I enjoyed the song a bit more.

 

I don't really why you didn't expect her to get playlisted by Capital. They were a big supporter during Stronger and played "Underneath The Tree" a lot.

 

I prefer the pre-chorus to the chorus, it feels like such a great build up but then falls a bit flat.

 

01. "Catch My Breath"

02. "Never Again"

03. "My Life Would Suck Without You"

04. "Breakaway"

05. "Mr. Know It All"

06. "Heartbeat Song"

07. "Miss Independent"

 

The top 3 are interchangeable.

1. My Life would suck without you (11/10)

2. Mr know it all (11/10)

3. Heartbeat Song (9/10)

4. Never Again (9/10)

5. Breakaway (8/10)

6. Miss independent (7/10)

7. Underneath the tree (7/10)

8. Catch my breath (4.5/10)

 

Agree that her best songs are the followups apart from those top 2

I would rank my lead singles like this.

 

01. 'My Life Would Suck Without You'

02. 'Heartbeat Song'

03. 'Breakaway'

04. Mr. Know It All'

05. 'Underneath The Tree'

06. 'Catch My Breath'

07. 'Never Again'

08. 'Miss Independent'

Having two 11's kind of defeats the purpose of having an 11 doesn't it?

Not when it's Kelly it doesn't :smoke: More than one 11 is required.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.