Hello all and welcome to, quite simply, the biggest undertaking this forum (or perhaps any artist forum on this site) has ever done.

 

Over the course of the next few months, we will be conducting the Ultimate Madonna Rate. "But we've done this before!!1" you might say... not like this :o In the past we have held 80s singles rates, rates for all of her singles across the years but never have we rated every single song that Madonna has released.. until now!

 

In order to make this mammoth task feasible, we have decided to separate her huge, decade-spanning career into sections, starting here with the 80s. Below is every song released by Madonna in the 80s. Rate them. One 11, one -1. Simple ~

 

We will then do the same for other eras of Madonna's career, before eventually presenting every single song as rated by you.

 

 

Lucky Star

Borderline

Burning Up

I Know It

Holiday

Think of Me

Physical Attraction

Everybody

 

 

Material Girl

Angel

Like A Virgin

Over and Over

Love Don't Live Here Anymore

Dress You Up

Shoo-Bee-Doo

Pretender

Stay

 

 

Papa Don't Preach

Open Your Heart

White Heat

Live to Tell

Where's the Party

True Blue

La Isla Bonita

Jimmy Jimmy

Love Makes the World Go Round

 

 

Like a Prayer

Express Yourself

Love Song

Till Death Do Us Part

Promise to Try

Cherish

Dear Jessie

Oh Father

Keep it Together

Spanish Eyes

Act of Contrition

 

 

Who's That Girl

Causing a Commotion

The Look of Love

Can't Stop

 

 

Spotlight

Into the Groove

Crazy For You

Gambler

Ain't No Big Deal

Supernatural

xx Lucky Star
xx Borderline
xx Burning Up
xx I Know It
xx Holiday
xx Think of Me
xx Physical Attraction
xx Everybody

xx Material Girl
xx Angel
xx Like A Virgin
xx Over and Over
xx Love Don't Live Here Anymore
xx Dress You Up
xx Shoo-Bee-Doo
xx Pretender
xx Stay

xx Papa Don't Preach
xx Open Your Heart
xx White Heat
xx Live to Tell
xx Where's the Party
xx True Blue
xx La Isla Bonita
xx Jimmy Jimmy
xx Love Makes the World Go Round

xx Like a Prayer
xx Express Yourself
xx Love Song
xx Till Death Do Us Part
xx Promise to Try
xx Cherish
xx Dear Jessie
xx Oh Father
xx Keep it Together
xx Spanish Eyes
xx Act of Contrition

xx Who's That Girl
xx Causing a Commotion
xx The Look of Love
xx Can't Stop

xx Spotlight
xx Into the Groove
xx Crazy For You
xx Gambler
xx Ain't No Big Deal
xx Supernatural

I will do this soon, that's a lot of songs to rate though, a lot of them I haven't heard I don't think. 'Into The Groove' is easily my favourite though of her 80s stuff.

I will do this soon, that's a lot of songs to rate though, a lot of them I haven't heard I don't think. 'Into The Groove' is easily my favourite though of her 80s stuff.

Excited to see your rate *.* A great choice for favourite of this bunch.

 

And yep, there is (and will be) a lot of songs to get through but that's part of the fun! Try and do as many of the songs as you can - it'd be greatly appreciated if you could do all of them of course, but as many as you can will be great :D

 

Lucky Star 8

Borderline 10

Burning Up 9

I Know It 7

Holiday 9

Think of Me 7

Physical Attraction 6

Everybody 7

 

Material Girl 7

Angel 8

Like A Virgin 7

Over and Over 8

Love Don't Live Here Anymore 6

Dress You Up 8

Shoo-Bee-Doo 5

Pretender 5

Stay 5

 

Papa Don't Preach 9

Open Your Heart 8

White Heat 7

Live to Tell 10

Where's the Party 8

True Blue 8

La Isla Bonita 9

Jimmy Jimmy 6

Love Makes the World Go Round 6

 

Like a Prayer 9

Express Yourself 8

Love Song 6

Till Death Do Us Part 9

Promise to Try 9

Cherish 8

Dear Jessie 7

Oh Father 10

Keep it Together 6

Spanish Eyes 7

Act of Contrition -1

 

Who's That Girl 8

Causing a Commotion 7

The Look of Love 7

Can't Stop 7

 

Spotlight 6

Into the Groove 10

Crazy For You 11

Gambler 7

Ain't No Big Deal 4

Supernatural 4

 

 

 

 

 

 

We have our first rate! Thanks vibe :wub:

Fab 11/10 song there! :wub: 'Crazy for You' may have been her first own ballad but it still rates as one of her very best.

 

I feel like my Like a Virgin rate will leave a few question marks...

I feel like my Like a Virgin rate will leave a few question marks...

Song or album? :o

Song or album? :o

I was referring to the album but in a way that includes the song!

LAV is my least fav album apart from mdna , funny this made her a megastar 😉

LAV is my least fav album apart from mdna , funny this made her a megastar 😉

Yup, it's one of my least favourites too. It's just very 80s-by-numbers for me and I hate the vocal pitching.

Lucky Star 6

Borderline 8

Burning Up 6

I Know It 5

Holiday 7

Think of Me 6

Physical Attraction 6

Everybody 6

 

Material Girl 9

Angel 7

Like A Virgin 7

Over and Over 7

Love Don't Live Here Anymore 5

Dress You Up 7

Shoo-Bee-Doo 4

Pretender 5

Stay 5

 

Papa Don't Preach 8

Open Your Heart 9

White Heat 5

Live to Tell 7

Where's the Party 7

True Blue 8

La Isla Bonita 8

Jimmy Jimmy 4

Love Makes the World Go Round 4

 

Like a Prayer 11

Express Yourself 8

Love Song 6

Till Death Do Us Part 7

Promise to Try 7

Cherish 7

Dear Jessie 6

Oh Father 7

Keep it Together 6

Spanish Eyes 7

Act of Contrition -1

 

Who's That Girl 6

Causing a Commotion 7

The Look of Love 6

Can't Stop 7

 

Spotlight 5

Into the Groove 8

Crazy For You 9

Gambler 7

Ain't No Big Deal 5

Supernatural 3

 

09 Lucky Star
10 Borderline
08 Burning Up
07 I Know It
10 Holiday
07 Think of Me
08 Physical Attraction
08 Everybody

10 Material Girl
09 Angel
10 Like A Virgin
08 Over and Over
06 Love Don't Live Here Anymore
10 Dress You Up
04 Shoo-Bee-Doo
09 Pretender
07 Stay

10 Papa Don't Preach
10 Open Your Heart
09 White Heat
10 Live to Tell
10 Where's the Party
10 True Blue
10 La Isla Bonita
03 Jimmy Jimmy
08 Love Makes the World Go Round

11 Like a Prayer
10 Express Yourself
05 Love Song
10 Till Death Do Us Part
10 Promise to Try
10 Cherish
08 Dear Jessie
09 Oh Father
07 Keep it Together
07 Spanish Eyes
03 Act of Contrition

08 Who's That Girl
09 Causing a Commotion
06 The Look of Love
03 Can't Stop

08 Spotlight
10 Into the Groove
10 Crazy For You
06 Gambler
05 Ain't No Big Deal
07 Supernatural

Going off these, Act of Contrition is pretty certain for last place isn't it? :lol:

10 Lucky Star

05 Borderline

08 Burning Up

04 I Know It

10 Holiday

04 Think of Me

04 Physical Attraction

05 Everybody

 

08 Material Girl

09 Angel

07 Like A Virgin

03 Over and Over

09 Love Don't Live Here Anymore

09 Dress You Up

04 Shoo-Bee-Doo

04 Pretender

05 Stay

 

11 Papa Don't Preach

09 Open Your Heart

09 White Heat

08 Live to Tell

09 Where's the Party

07 True Blue

10 La Isla Bonita

03 Jimmy Jimmy

07 Love Makes the World Go Round

 

08 Like a Prayer

08 Express Yourself

03 Love Song

03 Till Death Do Us Part

05 Promise to Try

08 Cherish

07 Dear Jessie

08 Oh Father

06 Keep it Together

05 Spanish Eyes

05 Act of Contrition

 

10 Who's That Girl

10 Causing a Commotion

09 The Look of Love

05 Can't Stop

 

07 Spotlight

09 Into the Groove

08 Crazy For You

08 Gambler

06 Ain't No Big Deal

03 Supernatural

03 Till Death Do Us Part

05 Spanish Eyes

:o

07 Lucky Star

10 Borderline

06 Burning Up

03 I Know It

08 Holiday

04 Think of Me

03 Physical Attraction

04 Everybody

 

06 Material Girl

04 Angel

06 Like A Virgin

02 Over and Over

01 Love Don't Live Here Anymore

06 Dress You Up

00 Shoo-Bee-Doo

01 Pretender

03 Stay

 

10 Papa Don't Preach

10 Open Your Heart

07 White Heat

10 Live to Tell

07 Where's the Party

07 True Blue

10 La Isla Bonita

02 Jimmy Jimmy

04 Love Makes the World Go Round

 

11 Like a Prayer

10 Express Yourself

05 Love Song

10 Till Death Do Us Part

10 Promise to Try

10 Cherish

09 Dear Jessie

10 Oh Father

06 Keep it Together

08 Spanish Eyes

01 Act of Contrition

 

06 Who's That Girl

06 Causing a Commotion

04 The Look of Love

03 Can't Stop

 

07 Spotlight

10 Into the Groove

10 Crazy For You

06 Gambler

03 Ain't No Big Deal

05 Supernatural

Ready for it votes are terrible.

Dandy that Like a Virgin massacre! :mellow: