Jump to content

Featured Replies

To my ears Loving You, to Buzzjack I don't know.
  • Replies 644
  • Views 26.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

Okay firstly I'm shocked we survived Round 13! Pessimistic Jay strikes again!

 

 

It's interesting that On the Horizon has a few mentions, because a lot of Melanie C fans say they dislike it. I've always liked it! I prefer it to Loving You :lol: but then there might be certain posters who remember when Loving You was a hit and would still like it now.

 

Here's every choice we have by the way:

 

#11 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) [spice Girls]

#13 Word Up [Mel B]

#13 Lullaby [Mel B]

#14 On the Horizon [Melanie C]

#14 Loving You [Melanie C]

#15 Crickets Sing for Anamaria [Emma Bunton]

#18 If That Were Me [Melanie C]

#20 We're Not Gonna Sleep Tonight [Emma Bunton]

#22 Desire [Geri Halliwell]

#24 I Want Candy [Melanie C]

#27 Melt [Melanie C]

#27 Yeh Yeh Yeh [Melanie C]

Mel C - If I Were You is the best by miles but I don't have the average voter taste :D

I WANT CANDY :w00t: ... kidding :lol:

 

I thought Loving you was our best chance initially when I saw this round, it’s the biggest seller out of the above. Interesting people have said on the horizon I love that song too. Crickets is one of those love hate ones (hate from me) which could smash or bomb. 💣 Hmmmm come on we need more opinions.

I love Crickets but something in me just can't see it doing well at all oop. Crickets could be an apt title for the number of votes it gets though :kink:

Edited by Andrew.

I suppose Loving you may pick up a few extra votes in any Matt Cardle fans too? Not that I think there are many of them on Buzzjack :lol: Maybe we post Jay's thirsty cover to entice votes? :P

'Loving You' is my favourite. But 'On The Horizon' is very likeable too ... unless your name's Melanie Chisholm.

 

I think 'Headlines' would be suicide.

I am sorry but how on earth did Crickets make it to number fifteen???!!! That song is NO NO NO.
I’m gonna be honest Loving You might be the 1st time I wouldn’t vote for Spice. It’s so dull

Loving You is my favourite I think!

 

But Headlines is actually rather safe for this round in terms of their choices although it is the only song what fits this round what’s a Spice Song it is remembered enough it’s in own right.

 

 

I never understood the huge deslike for Headlines, of course it's not a classic materspiece, but it's not bad.

Interesting to see they've never charted between 28-40, it's quite a wide range.

 

Either Headlines, On the Horizon or Loving You would be fine for me, but it's going to be hard to survive this one.

Hm, I think this will be a hard round.

 

I'd personally pick either On The Horizon or Headlines.

Even spice fans hate headlines.

 

 

  • Author

I've listened to Loving You for the first time since 4th September 2016 (!) and it's reminded me that it's such a strong song!

 

I'm surprised it could be thought of as being dull, I think it's quite a rousing song :o

 

As a matter of interest, when is the last time you all listened to Loving You? If it's been a while, I wonder whether you'd think differently of it now than a few years ago?

 

On the Horizon and Headlines perform quite a bit worse in rates. :( Even though a few have pointed out that they like either or both of these songs, are they really strong enough to enter into this round?

Right decision

 

I listen to it all the time !! And will vote for it !

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.