I prefer Poker Face so I voted for it. However both are fantastic though! Shallow would stand out for a couple of reasons - being more recent and likely to be entirely different to what the other songs sent. Poker Face is obviously the more established classic. I'm sure both would see Gaga through!

That’s tough! Either really but I think Shallow has a stronger reach

Edited June 11, 20205 yr by Spiceboy

Shallow.

 

It feels more classic. Maybe it has more to do with the emotional link to the movie and what that film means to me. Whereas with PF, I've played it to hell and back. I love it as a pop song but I can't hear it too often :lol:

Poker Face por favor x

ppppoker face pppoker face

Easiest poll I've seen in my life

 

'Poker Face' 100%

Poker Face by a COUNTRY mile.

I prefer Shallow these days but tbh I'd expect either to sail through!

Poker Face and I've voted in every AFI round!

Poker Face.

Slay!

I ADORE Shallow, it would 100% get my vote over anything else the other AFs have to offer!

 

I do think Poker Face would be an easy win too, either way Gaga is perfectly fine :lol: I would love for Shallow to get a moment in AF Idol though

Shallow.