Welcome to Ultimate Anastacia Singles Rate. :cheer:

I decided to do a rate of her singles only (instead of her albums) since pretty much all of her singles were released from the beginning till the end of 00-09 decade.

Without further ado, please see below:

• Rate each song between 0 and 10.
• ".5" scores are allowed but please NO 0.5 or 10.5 scores.
• No -1's please - but you are allowed to give one song an 11.
• Deadline is August 31st 11:59 PM .

xx.x "I'm Outta Love"
xx.x "Not That Kind"
xx.x "Cowboys & Kisses"
xx.x "Made for Lovin' You"
xx.x "Paid My Dues"
xx.x "One Day in Your Life"
xx.x "Why'd You Lie to Me"
xx.x "You'll Never Be Alone"
xx.x "Left Outside Alone"
xx.x "Sick and Tired"
xx.x "Welcome to My Truth"
xx.x "Heavy on My Heart"
xx.x "Pieces of a Dream"
xx.x "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)
xx.x "I Can Feel You"
xx.x "Absolutely Positively"
xx.x "Defeated"

09.5 "I'm Outta Love"

10.0 "Not That Kind"

09.0 "Cowboys & Kisses"

06.5 "Made for Lovin' You"

09.5 "Paid My Dues"

08.5 "One Day in Your Life"

07.5 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

09.0 "You'll Never Be Alone"

10.0 "Left Outside Alone"

08.5 "Sick and Tired"

09.0 "Welcome to My Truth"

11.0 "Heavy on My Heart"

08.0 "Pieces of a Dream"

06.0 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

07.5 "I Can Feel You"

05.0 "Absolutely Positively"

05.0 Defeated

 

I may edit the ratings as I'm gonna have a re listen but from memory that's them. Used to be obsessed with Anastacia ❤️

Edited August 19, 20204 yr by Lukuzz

9 "I'm Outta Love"

7.5 "Not That Kind"

5.5 "Cowboys & Kisses"

5.5 "Made for Lovin' You"

10 "Paid My Dues"

9 "One Day in Your Life"

9 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

9 "You'll Never Be Alone"

10 "Left Outside Alone"

10 "Sick and Tired"

10 "Welcome to My Truth"

11 "Heavy on My Heart"

10 "Pieces of a Dream"

8.5 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

8 "I Can Feel You"

7.5 "Absolutely Positively"

10 "Defeated"

Absolutely love Anastacia :wub:

 

09.5 "I'm Outta Love"

09.0 "Not That Kind"

06.0 "Cowboys & Kisses"

10.0 "Made for Lovin' You"

08.0 "Paid My Dues"

10.0 "One Day in Your Life"

07.0 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

09.5 "You'll Never Be Alone"

11.0 "Left Outside Alone"

07.5 "Sick and Tired"

10.0 "Welcome to My Truth"

08.0 "Heavy on My Heart"

06.0 "Pieces of a Dream"

07.5 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

05.0 "I Can Feel You"

04.0 "Absolutely Positively"

08.0 "Defeated"

07.0 "I'm Outta Love" - fun in itself, but marred by becoming a Heart FM receptionists-do-karaoke-hell anthem

07.5 "Not That Kind"

08.5 "Cowboys & Kisses" - as nice as this, I'm still glad she didn't pursue a dull country music route. Sounds out of place within her discography.

03.5 "Made for Lovin' You" - like one of those pisspoor "Ameritz Karaoke" covers of I'm Outta Love

06.0 "Paid My Dues" - fun but the arrogance of this after just one album. The prototype for Jessie J.

05.0 "One Day in Your Life" - I'm Outta Love part III

05.0 "Why'd You Lie to Me" - Destiny's Child D-side

09.5 "You'll Never Be Alone" - refreshing at a time when overblown 80s power ballads had been out of fashion for a few years. First sign of things to come.

10.0 "Left Outside Alone" - one of the best pop songs of the noughties

10.0 "Sick and Tired" - at the time this would have got the 11. Unusually understated and soulful for her, although in retrospect the melody feels slightly awkward in places.

11.0 "Welcome to My Truth" - at her most banshee

08.0 "Heavy on My Heart" - the flat backing singers in the chorus let this down

06.0 "Pieces of a Dream" - 18 months into "sprock", and at time when everyone from Kelly Clarkson to Ashlee bloody Simpson were hiring guitarists, this did not stand out

08.5 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti) - ridiculous cheese that even Celine would have wrinkled her nose at. Love it.

00.0 "I Can Feel You" - DISGUSTING. Having finally hit her stride and found her "sound", her record company decide to push out this remedial nonsense that felt 36 evolutionary stages before Not That Kind. The lyrics are outdated generic drivel, the chorus falls into a black hole, and who thought 57 year old foghorn Anastacia was suddenly going to sell SENSUAL?

02.0 "Absolutely Positively" - take the I'm Outta Love backing track for the 43rd time, halve the tempo, add nursery rhyme lyrics, and you have BOREDOM

03.0 "Defeated" - self-help anthem written by a 15 year for GCSE poetry before being posted as an Facebook status (u OK hun?)

Edited August 22, 20204 yr by Shoat

Edited mine a few have higher scores now 😉

This is a rate we needed! Love this woman!

 

10 "I'm Outta Love"

09 "Not That Kind"

07 "Cowboys & Kisses"

07 "Made for Lovin' You"

10 "Paid My Dues"

09 "One Day in Your Life"

07 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

09 "You'll Never Be Alone"

11 "Left Outside Alone"

09 ‘Sick and Tired"

10 "Welcome to My Truth"

09 "Heavy on My Heart"

08 "Pieces of a Dream"

10 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

06 "I Can Feel You"

04 "Absolutely Positively"

07 "Defeated"

 

If she hasn’t released Heavy Rotation she’d had been a perfect 2000s artist. I do enjoy it but I’m very aware of what a step down it was (more like a few storeys down if we’re being honest.)

 

Anastacia was one of the most perfect albums, I still enjoy every song and I don’t think I’d give anything on there less than an 8. I loved listening to her greatest hits on rotation back in sixth form.

09.0 "I'm Outta Love"

08.5 "Not That Kind"

06.5 "Cowboys & Kisses"

08.0 "Made for Lovin' You"

09.0 "Paid My Dues"

10.0 "One Day in Your Life"

06.5 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

05.0 "You'll Never Be Alone"

10.0 "Left Outside Alone"

11.0 "Sick and Tired"

07.0 "Welcome to My Truth"

06.0 "Heavy on My Heart"

07.5 "Pieces of a Dream"

xx.x "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

xx.x "I Can Feel You"

xx.x "Absolutely Positively"

xx.x "Defeated"

I am shocked finding out that I Belong To You was never released in UK...it was a huge #1 hit in many other european charts!!!

7.5 "I'm Outta Love"

6.0 "Not That Kind"

5.5 "Cowboys & Kisses"

6.5 "Made for Lovin' You"

5.0 "Paid My Dues"

7.0 "One Day in Your Life"

5.0 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

7.5 "You'll Never Be Alone"

11 "Left Outside Alone"

9.0 "Sick and Tired"

7.0 "Welcome to My Truth"

8.5 "Heavy on My Heart"

8.0 "Pieces of a Dream"

10 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

3.0 "I Can Feel You"

4.0 "Absolutely Positively"

1.0 "Defeated"

09.5 "I'm Outta Love"

08.0 "Not That Kind"

07.5 "Cowboys & Kisses"

07.0 "Made for Lovin' You"

09.0 "Paid My Dues"

10.0 "One Day in Your Life"

07.5 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

08.0 "You'll Never Be Alone"

10.0 "Left Outside Alone"

11.0 "Sick and Tired"

09.0 "Welcome to My Truth"

09.5 "Heavy on My Heart"

08.5 "Pieces of a Dream"

09.0 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

06.5 "I Can Feel You"

07.0 "Absolutely Positively"

05.5 "Defeated"

10 "I'm Outta Love"

09 "Not That Kind"

08 "Cowboys & Kisses"

06 "Made for Lovin' You"

09 "Paid My Dues"

10 "One Day in Your Life"

09 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

07 "You'll Never Be Alone"

11 "Left Outside Alone"

06 "Sick and Tired"

08 "Welcome to My Truth"

07 "Heavy on My Heart"

08 "Pieces of a Dream"

06 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

06 "I Can Feel You"

05 "Absolutely Positively"

05 "Defeated"

10 "I'm Outta Love"

07.5 "Not That Kind"

06.5 "Cowboys & Kisses"

05 "Made for Lovin' You"

08.5 "Paid My Dues"

08 "One Day in Your Life"

06 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

05 "You'll Never Be Alone"

11"Left Outside Alone"

09 "Sick and Tired"

08 "Welcome to My Truth"

07 "Heavy on My Heart"

06.5 "Pieces of a Dream"

04 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

05 "I Can Feel You"

02 "Absolutely Positively"

05 "Defeated"

 

10 "I'm Outta Love"

05 "Not That Kind"

06 "Cowboys & Kisses"

05 "Made for Lovin' You"

09.5 "Paid My Dues"

07 One Day in Your Life"

06 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

05 "You'll Never Be Alone"

11"Left Outside Alone"

07 Sick and Tired"

08 "Welcome to My Truth"

07 "Heavy on My Heart"

06 Pieces of a Dream"

04 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

05 "I Can Feel You"

06 Absolutely Positively"

02 Defeated"

 

08.5 "I'm Outta Love"

09.0 "Not That Kind"

07.5 "Cowboys & Kisses"

06.0 "Made for Lovin' You"

10.0 "Paid My Dues"

09.0 "One Day in Your Life"

08.0 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

07.5 "You'll Never Be Alone"

10.0 "Left Outside Alone"

11.0 "Sick and Tired"

09.5 "Welcome to My Truth"

08.5 "Heavy on My Heart"

07.5 "Pieces of a Dream"

07.0 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

05.5 "I Can Feel You"

06.0 "Absolutely Positively"

06.5 "Defeated"

 

Her three first era's were basically flawless and I still don't understand what happened after that.. Talk about a fall from grace.

08 "I'm Outta Love"

07 "Not That Kind"

05 "Cowboys & Kisses"

05 "Made for Lovin' You"

06 "Paid My Dues"

09 "One Day in Your Life"

09 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

07 "You'll Never Be Alone"

11 "Left Outside Alone"

08 "Sick and Tired"

07 "Welcome to My Truth"

07 "Heavy on My Heart"

06 "Pieces of a Dream"

04 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

05 "I Can Feel You"

05 "Absolutely Positively"

6.5 "Defeated"

10.0 "I'm Outta Love"
08.5 "Not That Kind"
07.0 "Cowboys & Kisses"
06.5 "Made for Lovin' You"
09.0 "Paid My Dues"
10.0 "One Day in Your Life"
07.5 "Why'd You Lie to Me"
06.0 "You'll Never Be Alone"
11.0 "Left Outside Alone"
10.0 "Sick and Tired"
09.0 "Welcome to My Truth"
08.5 "Heavy on My Heart"
08.0 "Pieces of a Dream"
05.0 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)
06.0 "I Can Feel You"
04.5 "Absolutely Positively"
05.0 "Defeated"

10.0 "I'm Outta Love"

05.0 "Not That Kind"

06.0 "Cowboys & Kisses"

04.0 "Made for Lovin' You"

06.0 "Paid My Dues"

08.0 "One Day in Your Life"

07.0 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

04.0 "You'll Never Be Alone"

10.0 "Left Outside Alone"

11.0 "Sick and Tired"

03.0 "Welcome to My Truth"

03.0 "Heavy on My Heart"

03.0 "Pieces of a Dream"

XXXX "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

04.0 "I Can Feel You"

04.0 "Absolutely Positively"

03.0 "Defeated"

 

I really rate a lot of her more recent tracks (not on the list)

10 "I'm Outta Love"

09 "Not That Kind"

08 "Cowboys & Kisses"

08 "Made for Lovin' You"

07 "Paid My Dues"

11 "One Day in Your Life"

08 "Why'd You Lie to Me"

08 "You'll Never Be Alone"

09 "Left Outside Alone"

07 "Sick and Tired"

07 "Welcome to My Truth"

08 "Heavy on My Heart"

07 "Pieces of a Dream"

06 "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti)

10 "I Can Feel You"

08 "Absolutely Positively"

09 "Defeated"

xx.x "I'm Outta Love" 9.5

xx.x "Not That Kind" 9

xx.x "Cowboys & Kisses" 8

xx.x "Made for Lovin' You" 7

xx.x "Paid My Dues" 10

xx.x "One Day in Your Life" 10

xx.x "Why'd You Lie to Me" 9

xx.x "You'll Never Be Alone" 10

xx.x "Left Outside Alone" 11

xx.x "Sick and Tired" 10

xx.x "Welcome to My Truth" 9.5

xx.x "Heavy on My Heart" 10

xx.x "Pieces of a Dream" 9.5

xx.x "I Belong to You" (with Eros Ramazzotti) 8

xx.x "I Can Feel You" 5

xx.x "Absolutely Positively" 4

xx.x "Defeated" 4