Posted November 4, 20204 yr Saw this in the Girls Aloud forum and thought it would be cool to do it in here. Split into three sections vote for your: Favourite Spice Girl - as in Baby, Ginger, Posh, Scary or Sporty in the group. Favourite Solo Spice Music - as in Emma, Geri, Melanie B, Melanie C or Victoria based on their solo music careers. Favourite Solo Spice personality - as in who you like most away from the music, the group etc. PS - This thread is to tell us why you like your favourites not why you don't like any of the others, let's keep it positive and happy guys! B-)
November 4, 20204 yr Author I voted POSH - The movie just clinches it for me she is HILARIOUS! She's always been my favourite Spice character since then :wub: MELANIE C - The one who constantly releases music, she has covered such a wide range of genres and for me personally each album is great in it's own way, there are real gems throughout her back catalogue. Northern Star remains my favourite solo Spice record and she has the most gems in her back catalogue for me personally. MELANIE C - I was torn between Emma, Victoria and Melanie C for this. Victoria because she is hilarious, Emma because she has always been really consistently sweet from the beginning, but in the end Melanie's recent attitude has totally won me over. Have loved seeing her support for the LGBTQ+ community, her utter enthusiasm for all things Spice and solo and also the amount of contact she has had with fans and interviews lately really helped.
November 4, 20204 yr Fave in band - went for Posh, as you said above she is the stand out star in Spiceworld and I just loved how she was different to the rest of them, although early in their career Ginger was my clear fave. And now there's no Posh in current line up, Scary is stepping up. Fave music - Geri for me has all solid singles and I was obsessed with her music. Mel C is a very very close 2nd especially with her latest album being amazing. Personality - has to be Mel B she's just so out there and seems the most genuine to me, although I love Victorias sense of humour.
November 4, 20204 yr Favourite Spice Girl in the band: Ginger. She was basically Spice Girls for me and her queer anticts were so mesmerising, new and eye-catching at the time lol. I'm still leaning towards that ginger when it comes to pick a fav SG girl. Favourite Solo Spice music: Melanie C. Without a doubt! Her music is incredible! Favourite Solo Spice personality: Melanie C. Although I love Mel B's personality so much, Melanie C has won me over with her down to earth personality over the years. I find her quite relatable, accessible and friendly.tht Edited November 4, 20204 yr by Pearll
November 4, 20204 yr Mel B Emma Emma It used to be all Emma but last year's tour really turned it around for me with Mel B eating that stage alive, Also her passion for the band is palpable and she has always been a driving force behind it, always supporting the band. Emma has the presence and the talent just as much as Mel B but MB really brought the charisma last year, which took it another notch up for me! Scary and Baby Forever :wub:
November 4, 20204 yr Posh (my favorite Spice Girl will always be Melanie C but my favorite nick/role/personality in the group at the moment it's the Victoria's one✌️🌐) Melanie C Melanie C Edited November 4, 20204 yr by SouthernStar88
November 5, 20204 yr Favorite Spice Girl: I have always been a Mel B fan. Favorite Solo Spice music: Victoria Favorite Solo Spice personality: Mel B
November 5, 20204 yr Queen C x 3 Even though when it comes to the band, I love Mel B, she’s great on stage, I love the way she moves. She’s a perfectionist, at least on stage. Third Posh, she was great during the Forever era. She defo was my fave. Emma, meh. As for Geri, oh dear.
November 5, 20204 yr Favourite Spice Girl in the band - voted for Ginger Spice, a really interesting and larger-than-life character who felt like a particular poster girl for 'girl power' Favourite Solo Spice music - Melanie C, definitely. 'Northern Star' is my favourite solo Spice record and she still makes great music even now! Favourite Solo Spice personality - I'd say Emma has been the most consistently enjoyable for me over the years, so lovely.
December 19, 20204 yr Favourite Mel C - as she had the best solo material I think especially Turn To You and When You're Gone and I like Mel C's tattoos and iconic look too. Edited December 19, 20204 yr by Road Salt Mixer
