Welcome to a new series of polls, pitting Harry's solo music against the 1D group singles! Poll 1 will focus on their respective first single, before poll 2 focuses on single 2, etc. At the end I'll total up who's won the most polls! Vote for your favourite in the poll above and tell us below what you've voted for.

 

Harry: Sign of the Times

 

 

One Direction: What Makes You Beautiful

 

Went for 'Sign of the Times'!

This is probably going to be the toughest poll, because these are two of my favourite songs of the 10s decade. I've voted for Harry though, as Sign of the Times stops me in my tracks every time it comes on. A breathtaking song. WMYB has many memories with it for me though, I love it a lot :heart:

What Makes You Beautiful

Both genius debut singles

 

Although personally I prefer Sign Of The Times

What Makes You Beautiful!

This will be the hardest one as both are 10/10 tracks. What makes you beautiful just pips it for me though.

If I go by my eoys it would be 'What Makes You Beautiful' as that was 30 whereas Sign was.. 75 :lol:

 

I really enjoy Sign more nowadays though so actually gone for that. WMYB is a very solid boy group debut song though. Not an easy choice.

What Makes You Beautiful

 

A stormer of a debut single.

I really like both of these in different ways, both were great lead singles.

What Makes You Beautiful.

 

It's Top 3 1D and was just an immediate banger the second you heard it.

 

Sign of the Times is good... but it goes on a bit for me.

Harry - Sign of the Times

It’s been a longer length of time since Sign of the Times’ release, than between that and What Makes You Beautiful… that feels weird to me!

 

What Makes You Beautiful to Sign of the Times: 5 years, 7 months

Sign of the Times to now: 6 years, 1 month