Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 205
  • Views 9.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

So many great songs in this final, with the Prince one being yet another.

 

LOVE that Birdhouse in Your Soul made the final and did very respectably in it as well.

  • Author

16. U2 - I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For 953pts

 

Writers - U2

Top scores - marcinjaro 49, Popchartfreak 47, Jester 47

Low scores - coi 5, JulianT 7, Dotty New Year 10

Average score - 27.2

 

This was U2's fifth top 10 single and their second US number 1. A cover version by The Chimes also peaked at number 6 three years later. The three lowest scores were from the last three voters. Up to that point, the lowest score was 12 points.

 

  • Author

15. Madonna - The Power Of Goodbye / Little Star 961pts

 

Writers - Madonna, Rick Nowels

Top scores - Dante77 50, Mango 50, marcinjaro 50

Low scores - Jason 1, danG 3, jimwatts 4, ElectroBoy 4

Average score - 27.5

 

The Power Of Goodbye was the fourth single released from Madonna's 1998 number 1 album 'Ray Of Light'. Little Star was added as a double A side for the UK market only.

 

Two big favourites in the top 20 so far, Birdhouse in Your Soul is gloriously eccentric, and a likely contender for best song ever written from the perspective of an inanimate object. It's a shame it took Prince's death for Purple Rain to repeak, but it is deserved, a gorgeous epic :wub:
Getting into the realm of wall-to-wall classics by this point. Weird to think that (unless I missed it earlier) the likes of Little Boots (much as I like the song and voted it highly) is ahead of all of these!

And there goes my 50 :( though I am pleased 'The Power Of Goodbye' ended up this high up. Some days I consider it my all time favourite Madonna song but other days it's 'Live To Tell' or 'La Isla Bonita' or 'Frozen' or 'Like A Prayer'... it's firmly in the top 5 anyway, it's an absolutely flawless song in every respect :wub:

 

'Purple Rain' and the U2 song are both fine but overrated as classics IMO... I wouldn't go out of my way to listen to either of them. Both artists have got much better songs in their canons.

U2's was their first chart-topper for me, inspirational yet very downbeat, gospel-tinged listing of everything achieved in life - but that still not being enough. It's both religious and about love, is my take, but it's never overtly clear. The album is one of the greats. Prince's Purple rain is even more one of the greatest albums ever, and in the context of the album, Purple Rain is fine, it adds weight to a varied and vibrant set of tracks, percussive brilliance. Never seen the film, not bothered at all, but Prince was a huge fave in the 80's. Except for this meandering dirge, which I have OD'd on many times over since 1984. Every single track on the album is better than it and the real classic is When Doves Cry, now that's what I call awesome....

 

Madonna also a chart-topper for me, where Frozen and Ray Of Light just missed out :o Another great album that one.

  • Author

14. Lady Gaga - The Edge Of Glory 965pts

 

Writers - Stefani Germanotta, Fernando Garibay, Paul Blair

Top scores - ...ready for it 49, Mack. 48, Mango 47

Low scores - Dante77 1, RabbitFurCoat 2, detonate 3

Average score - 27.6

 

From 2011, this was Lady Gaga's ninth top 10 hit. The saxophone solo was played by Clarence Clemons who had been part of Bruce Springsteen's E Street Band since 1972. The video marked his last appearance before he died.

 

  • Author

13. Electric Light Orchestra - Mr Blue Sky 967pts

 

Writer - Jeff Lynne

Top scores - King Rollo 50, StoneDragon 50, Chez Wombat 50, JulianT 50

Low scores - JackJones 1, Grandwicky 3, xajnipi 4

Average score - 27.6

 

This was the seventh top 10 hit for the Birmingham group and the first of four consecutive singles by them to peak at number 6. It's the final part of the four song suite that makes up the 'Concerto For A Rainy Day' on side 3 of the 'Out Of The Blue' album which explains the "please turn me over" instruction at the end of the song.

 

That's one of Lady Gaga's best singles imo so it's a shame she, rather uncharacteristically, doesn't make the top 10 for once

 

 

There's one song still to come that I'm absolutely amazed is still in

  • Author

12. R.E.M. - Shiny Happy People 969pts

 

Writers - Bill Berry, Peter Buck, Mike Mills, Michael Stipe

Top scores - Jester 48, jimwatts 47, Grandwicky 44, JulianT 44

Low scores - Liamski689 4, Jade 4, AH Gold 9

Average score - 27.7

 

This was the second single released from R.E.M.'s seventh album 'Out Of Time', giving them their first top 10 hit. The guest vocalist was Kate Pierson from the B-52's.

 

That interplay between Kate Pierson and Michael Stipe on Shiny Happy People is just utterly fabulous!

 

I can’t believe ELO missed the Top 10! :nono:

'Shiny Happy People' is such a fun song, super pleased it finished so high - I was expecting it out before the top 30! Hopefully R.E.M. can finish even higher next year. Two songs which dropped out yesterday also made my top 10 - U2 could also do very well in a #7s rate, Prince not so likely.
I bought Shiny Happy People at the time. I can see why Michael Stipe would dislike singing it after it became a hit but it's great fun - I didn't realise until way afterwards that it was Kate Pierson but she definitely adds a lot to the song.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.