In relation to the current 4th season of The Traitors UK, who do you think is the secret traitor?

I've set this up to close at 19:55 on Wednesday next week just before their identity is revealed so get your guesses in ahead of then!

Not listed:

James (confirmed faithful via shortlist)

Maz (confirmed faithful via shortlist)

Reece (confirmed faithful via shortlist)

Rachel (traitor)

Stephen (traitor)

Hugo (traitor, banished)

Ben (murdered faithful)

Judy (confirmed faithful, banished)

Netty (murdered faithful)

Edited Saturday at 21:564 days by JosephStyles
please prefix your tags

I went for Amanda and Fiona in the first poll, and if I had to pick one I’d probably say Fiona. Probably more out of wanting it to be one of them because even as I’m typing I feel like it could be Ross too.

I think the shots of the red cloak we’ve been seeing are probably just of someone from production to throw us off the scent and not just think ‘oh it’s someone tall, slim’ etc.

I'm actually not sure - I don't think it is Harriet though after suspecting it was her. There were massive hints in the episode today that it could be Fiona or Sam. There might have been more too, but in their camera solos they both kind of hinted. I think from an editor point of view, the production team won't want to make it super obvious who it is but nor will they want to at least not hinted who they were in one of the VTs. My other complete wildcard is Ross.

If it is Harriet, then I think she went too early on Hugo and showing her hand to the Faithfuls. Traitor hunters often become suspicious to others later down the line.

I'm sure it's a woman, they just all seem a lot more switched on and game playing. But it could be deceiving edits, Harriet, Fiona, Jade, Roxie and Ellie I think are my main guesses but if I went for one it would be Fiona, the comment about not needing the shield and framing of Hugo and Rachel seems suspicious and she's clearly revelling in being smarter than she looks.

My shortlist is Harriet, Ellie and Fiona.

Of those, I think Harriet is the one, I think the production will have wanted to pick someone they were sure of handling it, and she's shown an ability to craft a plan. If it is her, her move against Hugo was deliberate, has her correctly yet plausibly using the information she has to her advantage, and is a great way to cement herself as a Faithful early on, to give her the time to craft up narratives against other Faithfuls.

Ellie has been shown to be quietly observant and could well have picked those on the shortlists, she is definitely my second guess if only from some of her interactions with the other Traitors around the castle, Fiona I will admit could possibly have something to it based on the latest episode and her hiding some parts of her personality does keep me with her as a possibility, yet I feel her shortlists might have been a bit more random if it were her.

Linda!

No, I think my best bet would be Harriet at this point. I did once think potentially Roxy and she's still giving signs, but that seems too obvious. Also Sam in this episode with his side-eye at the camera "I'm pretty confident people believe I am a faithful" made me think.

Harriet

Ross

Ellie

Ultimately chose Harriet.

I feel like it’s going to be Ellie or Fiona.

Then there was some odd moments with Sam yesterday in his confessionals. He made some weird looks when he said he was a faithful.

In the end I went Fiona

Edited Sunday at 07:534 days by ElectroBoy

Amanda & Sam. Sam if I had to choose one. He just seems too quiet and, unlike Amanda and Fiona(?), the editing doesn't seem to suggest him as the ST - immediate red flag.

I voted Harriet for my ‘final’ guess. She’s been quiet until last night and of course we already knew she could be quite shrewd. Roxy and Ellie are still on my list and also Fiona but I still think they’re teasing her.

I think Fiona is honestly just living her best life.

Based on not much I think Ellie, but think more likely Fiona? I think she used that asking for advice thing from Amanda wisely

7 hours ago, T Boy said:

I voted Harriet for my ‘final’ guess. She’s been quiet until last night and of course we already knew she could be quite shrewd. Roxy and Ellie are still on my list and also Fiona but I still think they’re teasing her.

I think Fiona is honestly just living her best life.

I'd already voted but actually I'd also now go for Harriet. It makes a lot of sense for it to be someone who would go for a traitor at the round table in such a public manner because it is win/win for them

What's sold it for me on Harriet is the storytelling element, barrister v barrister, traitor v traitor etc - Now that Hugo is away it means she can join the other traitors which she probably would want to do before they work out her identity themselves and have her murdered/banished, the longer it goes on the easier it would be for them to guess who the secret traitor is based on who is being shortlisted.

Shortlist: Ellie, Harriet, Fiona, Jade, Amanda

Jade said she wanted to be a faithful though, I believe, so least likely.

I think it’s Ellie.

If it is Ross he's playing an absolute blinder. Getting rid of Netty then Ben on the shortlist and having the traitors do his dirty work.

Faraaz.

No way would the producers pick four white people to be a Traitor. Also he could be shortlisting all the men to be murdered to throw himself off the scent and make it look like the ST is a female?

Edited Monday at 11:243 days by shadow2009

Ellie or Fiona and my bet would be on Fiona.

Any last minute guesses?!

I'm starting to doubt myself and think it might be someone left field like Jessie - I think she would be great as a traitor actually so I wouldn't be mad at that. I think it will be someone people suspect though as surely the producers would want to leave little clues here and there to give the public something to discuss. It wouldn't make much sense to have it be someone with not a lot of airtime