Jump to content

Featured Replies

4 minutes ago, Freeze said:

In semi 2, though, oh my! The country at 20th were TIED with Cor Lupus at 55 points! But Cor Lupus did not receive a 10-pointer like the 20th placed country😮

image.png

Oh god

  • Replies 408
  • Views 9.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • The mundane images being used for the DNQ’s are sending me west. What do you mean Brer & Silas are a silver handle and a piece of toast?!

  • To those of you who stayed with me for this long: thank you! I apologize for the late night show. I can only hope that you enjoyed it, regardless of your result. And I promise I'll try to be even

  • blacksquare
    blacksquare

    THE LIFE OF A DNQ

Posted Images

Oh no, that is the worst way to end a long streak :/

In all seriousness, I am actually very surprised, I’m usually quite on it with the pop entries and I didn’t doubt Madonna for one minute. I think it was just a really strong semi final for Pop unfortunately, so inevitably some of them fall to peoples 4s and 5s just one too many times.

My own votes that didn’t make it:

04 Cor Lupus

02 Lentyll

01 FARC

No matter how many times the rationale has been explained for breaking ties by 12s and 10s first in the semis rather than by number of voters as in the final and every other song contest on Buzzjack, I still don't follow the logic.

In my head (and my all time rankings) I would always break ties by highest score instead of most voters anyway!

I feel like less higher scores feels slightly more impressive than lots of lower scores, but that's just my preference! (Just like in my year end chart I apply a weighting based on higher weekly positions which favours those that spend time in the upper reaches over those that spend time at the lower end!)

3 minutes ago, jimwatts said:

No matter how many times the rationale has been explained for breaking ties by 12s and 10s first in the semis rather than by number of voters as in the final and every other song contest on Buzzjack, I still don't follow the logic.

My guess is it's about rewarding passion over breadth?

A song that 10 nations gave a 1 to 3 would beat one that a few nations adored. A semi is also only picking 20 songs, not crowning a winner, so letting the songs with real fans through makes sense to me

Yeah I get that, but I also think a song with a few big fans in its semi is more likely to have benefitted from a lopsided semi distribution (like last month's), and therefore come unstuck in the final if it doesn't find more fans from the other semi, than a song which a lot of people like to some degree. I don't have any stats to back this up though.

3 minutes ago, jimwatts said:

Yeah I get that, but I also think a song with a few big fans in its semi is more likely to have benefitted from a lopsided semi distribution (like last month's), and therefore come unstuck in the final if it doesn't find more fans from the other semi, than a song which a lot of people like to some degree. I don't have any stats to back this up though.

I feel like songs with a few big fans that make it through have already proven they're strong enough, whether the semi is lopsided or not, and from what I can see they don't do any worse in the final either. As we all know, a lot of it is the luck of the draw. They found fans either way, and qualifying doesn't guarantee any of us a top 10

The thing for me is the "lower scores" still feel significant, as people only point the top 10. Especially in a semi this size where voters have 31 (or 32 for the AQers) songs to choose from, so everything they vote for is in their top of 3 tiers.

Unless we're going by the understanding that most people only really care for their top few songs anyway, which may be the case.

2 minutes ago, jimwatts said:

The thing for me is the "lower scores" still feel significant, as people only point the top 10. Especially in a semi this size where voters have 31 (or 32 for the AQers) songs to choose from, so everything they vote for is in their top of 3 tiers.

Unless we're going by the understanding that most people only really care for their top few songs anyway, which may be the case.

That’s fair, and I don’t think either way is perfect.

I would guess people generally care more about their top few songs, and I have (at times) felt like I was padding out my ballot, but you’re right, a voter who gives a lower score has still picked that song over about 20+ others, so it isn't nothing.

I think that's why the tiebreak order works as a rough compromise. It favours the big scores first without ignoring the rest

I said this when the same thing happened to Land of the Tyrants but I stand by it - neither metric is more important than the other. Finding depth of voters - especially in the semis where the draw is more lopsided - is just as important as getting the big love imo. In fact it’s more impressive to get more voters if anything because you beat two thirds of the field to get into a country’s votes - so in that respect I agree with Jim. But of course, songs getting the high votes and big love should be rewarded too, as many songs that people gave top points to as possible should make the final.

Losing a Q place on a tie is so harsh and rare that I would just let the extra song into the final so one metric isn’t judged as more important than another, when it isn’t. Some years this never happens at all, it’s very infrequent.

I do understand that it opens up a can of worms of one semi having 21 qualifiers unless you drag through 21st from the other as well. So do appreciate why it’s a hard call.

It comes down to how you regard getting 1 point.

If you see it as 'just scraping into someone's votes' or 'coming 10th out of 32'....

They're both value judgements.

Edited by Colm

Just now, Colm said:

It comes down to how you regard getting 1 point. If that's 'just scraping into someone's votes' or ' coming 10th out of 32'....

True although there’s not often a lot between my 6/7 pointers and 1/commiserations some months, this month being one of them.

I guess it’s the game. It would never happen but technically 25 people awarding you 2 points and the other five giving 1 point could still see you out.

It’s fascinating to study what happens to these songs that rack up the low votes in the semis but do make it in - their proven consistency across the board in the semi (even if low points) often means their bigger fans are lurking in the other semi and it has had a bad draw. Also low semi votes can turn into high points in the final for some people due to being growers. I’ll always believe most votes is 100% as valid as highest points.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.