Aye I'm pleased with all the decisions too apart from 2 Shoes. It's not like they were ever gonna win but at least they'd have brought a bit of humour to the shows rather than having 2 boybands there that are both pretty dull.

If Louis had the groups 2Shoe's would have stayed. However Tulisa is DETERMINED to win this, and she thinks with a business-mind. She knows 2Shoe's have 0% chance of success in music. However her 2 male groups are very marketable obviously, and she genuinely believes she has the best girl group who can actually turn things round for girl groups on The X Factor and make it in the music industry. She thinks with a business head, unlike Louis who thinks of just The X Factor time period.

If Louis had the groups 2Shoe's would have stayed. However Tulisa is DETERMINED to win this, and she thinks with a business-mind. She knows 2Shoe's have 0% chance of success in music. However her 2 male groups are very marketable obviously, and she genuinely believes she has the best girl group who can actually turn things round for girl groups on The X Factor and make it in the music industry. She thinks with a business head, unlike Louis who thinks of just The X Factor time period.

 

Which is good. Although Nu Vibe have no chance of winning. The boyband vote is going to go to The Risk. They actually look like a boyband, have better vocals and I think they'llonly get better. I don't think they'll win, but I can see them having a career. One Direction might not have had the best vocalists they possibly could have had, but Danny is a very good singer. You don't get that with Nu Vibe. Perhaps Tulisa should have put 2 Shoes through but we'll see.

 

The only contestants that have a hope of winning are Frankie, Janet, Craig and Marcus. Perhaps The Risk.

Which is good. Although Nu Vibe have no chance of winning. The boyband vote is going to go to The Risk. They actually look like a boyband, have better vocals and I think they'llonly get better. I don't think they'll win, but I can see them having a career. One Direction might not have had the best vocalists they possibly could have had, but Danny is a very good singer. You don't get that with Nu Vibe. Perhaps Tulisa should have put 2 Shoes through but we'll see.

 

The only contestants that have a hope of winning are Frankie, Janet, Craig and Marcus. Perhaps The Risk.

 

 

Exactly completely agree. The Risk will completely over shadow NuVibe thats why i see them going very soon BUT just from looking at her 4 she has to think which 3 will sell, and 2Shoe's is definitely not in those 3 so thats why they didnt go through.

Think Amelia should of stayed she had more potentail than sophie but apart from that they made the right decisions although i did like 2 shoes

Sad that 2 Shoes & Amelia went but estatic Sophie was saved :D

I quite frankly think they're all pretty dreadful. Even with the circus that was last year, you could still pick out the really decent singers, but I wasn't overwhelmed by any of them at all last night. Craig was fairly decent but I feel that whoever does win will be facing a Leon Jackson type career in the long run.

Digital Spy predicted Amelia to win the thing a few days ago :lol: and you thought it was bad that they had Nicolo down to come 4th last year...

I'm annoyed Amelia went through these circumstances. She really had the most potential out of everyone I thought and we definitely hadn't seen the best she was able to offer. Kelly most certainly wouldn't have lost an act had it been a public vote as normal this week and it was a double eviction instead. But seeing as we knew the "twist" it was understandable that she left over the other 3. She was probably the weakest of the girls last night.

So typical of people on here to love 2 Shoes, ugh. They have good voices, and amazing personalities, but they don't really have the X Factor to me. They struggled to sing the Girls Aloud song, and relied on gimmicks, it was just such a joke. Plus one of them would be heavily pregnant during the final week, and let's face it, cheesy pop duos? Who the hell buys their music?

So typical of people on here to love 2 Shoes, ugh. They have good voices, and amazing personalities, but they don't really have the X Factor to me. They struggled to sing the Girls Aloud song, and relied on gimmicks, it was just such a joke. Plus one of them would be heavily pregnant during the final week, and let's face it, cheesy pop duos? Who the hell buys their music?

 

They didn't rely on any of it though. Tulisa picked the song and decided to make them a gimmicky act even after saying at Judges Houses that they weren't gimmicky. Louis did the exact same thing to Johnny Robinson and Gary picked up on both. They couldn't have made last night's performance any better because of the choices made by their mentor.

Plus one of them would be heavily pregnant during the final week

 

I don't think anybody here would have really expected them to make it to the final week.

Edited October 10, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf

Of course not, but they'd have provided quality entertainment for another couple of weeks at least.

I remember 2 years ago after Cheryl had put through her acts to judges houses and sent home a few of my favourites.. I said that she'd have no chance of winning now because no one would vote for the likes of Joe and Lloyd. and look what happened there ? :lol:

 

So I'm not going to complain really. I'm happy with the boys and groups decision. Overs I couldn't care less whether it was Johnny or Jonjo going, although Johnny will be more entertaining to watch

and with the Girls, I wanted both Amelia and Sophie through. I don't see the fuss with Janet at all and Misha has the strongest voice, but I can't seem to like her. I'd be surprised if either Misha or Janet went on to win

 

Which is good. Although Nu Vibe have no chance of winning. The boyband vote is going to go to The Risk. They actually look like a boyband, have better vocals and I think they'llonly get better. I don't think they'll win, but I can see them having a career. One Direction might not have had the best vocalists they possibly could have had, but Danny is a very good singer. You don't get that with Nu Vibe. Perhaps Tulisa should have put 2 Shoes through but we'll see.

 

The only contestants that have a hope of winning are Frankie, Janet, Craig and Marcus. Perhaps The Risk.

Rooney there is no Danny in One Direction. I'm guessing you mean Harry ? :lol:

 

Never underestimate the power of boyband fans. If they could they'd start voting before they've even heard them sing

Nu Vibe have got a few famous faces campaigning for them too as Ashford's brother plays for Sunderland, so that's got to help. I even saw "Find out who Jordan Henderson is supporting on X Factor" on the Liverpool Official website

http://i55.tinypic.com/20rwfer.png

 

I think they'll revert back to what they did at judges houses/bootcamp with having mainly Ashford singing.. who for me has a strong voice http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G8uB_R71cvQ and Stefan is decent

 

It's a bit like if you had JLS and One Direction in the same year. Who would have done better ? I think JLS were the better performers/singers, but right now it seems as if One Direction have a fanbase a lot bigger than theirs

I agreed with the judges last night except for 2.

 

Johnny should have gone not Jonjo (like Gary said Johnny's just a circus act - Mind you Louis always has to have one)

Misha should have gone not Amelia (Misha's just a shouter)

 

The ones I would send home now.

Overs - Johnny

Groups - Nu-Vibe

Boys - Craig (just)

Girls - Misha

I agreed with the judges last night except for 2.

 

Johnny should have gone not Jonjo (like Gary said Johnny's just a circus act - Mind you Louis always has to have one)

Misha should have gone not Amelia (Misha's just a shouter)

 

Gary also said that Jonjo's performance made Louis' decision 100% easier. And he was right.

 

I think this twist thing was stupid, boring and unnecessarily cruel to the four that went. I'm sure all four of them would have rather taken their chances with the public (although even that is overrided by the judges). I just don't see why they didn't go through to the start of the live finals with three acts each and perhaps and to boost advertising revenue - had the contestants sing two songs each instead of all the useless waffle that the judges give out. Having said that - the show is all about the judges so no - there'd be no point I suppose.

 

I can't stand Kelly (yes I know 99.9% of BJ loves her - but for me she just comes across as totally and utterly false.)

 

Kath

 

 

Anyone know if Rebecca Ferguson will be guesting on the show as she has her single out on December 05.

It's called - Nothing's Real But Love

Digital Spy predicted Amelia to win the thing a few days ago :lol: and you thought it was bad that they had Nicolo down to come 4th last year...

 

When it comes to music and music talent shows, Digital Spy is as bad as Buzzjack (if not worse) when it comes to being unable to see past their own generic preferences (their music reviews in particular are predictably dire - everything the Saturdays or Girls Aloud release is a 5/5). As we do ourselves, they tend to forget that internet-gays make up only a small section of the voting public. The fact that they predicted Two Shoes would finish well ahead of Craig and Misha B says it all I think.

Gary also said that Jonjo's performance made Louis' decision 100% easier. And he was right.

 

I think this twist thing was stupid, boring and unnecessarily cruel to the four that went. I'm sure all four of them would have rather taken their chances with the public (although even that is overrided by the judges). I just don't see why they didn't go through to the start of the live finals with three acts each and perhaps and to boost advertising revenue - had the contestants sing two songs each instead of all the useless waffle that the judges give out. Having said that - the show is all about the judges so no - there'd be no point I suppose.

 

I can't stand Kelly (yes I know 99.9% of BJ loves her - but for me she just comes across as totally and utterly false.)

 

Kath

 

Kath, you just totally PUT IT DOWN with that post :P

Katy Perry on next week again. I don't mind her but they are getting really repetive with guest performers each year. She's not that huge right now but they always seem to love her. I was hoping Kelly Clarkson might have appeared seeing her single is out next week but nevermind. Not too bothered The Wanted are on again. At least it's not Take That who have been on about 3 or 4 times, Westlife & JLS who come on every year. Potentially Amelia and 2 Shoes should have still been there despite being the weakest on Saturday (although Rhyhmix were for me in groups). In a way the twist was interesting for the fact that 2 judges chose the right ones to go but its still quite unfair to chuck 4 out in one week.

Edited October 10, 201113 yr by Rob Summers