I'm not really digging this. She isn't the second coming for me.

Miss Misha B <3

I do prefer Ruth Lorenzo's version but this was almost as good.

The Silas Rate - Week 3

 

Misha || !!! || *.*

 

---

 

Marcus || 10 || My good god. Outstanding. Easily his best performance and finally something that really properly suits him.

Kitty || 10 || Another strong performance from Kitty there, Escala is an 11 and this just wasn't quite there.

Sophie || 09.5 || Brilliant rendition of my favourite Bon Jovi track. Loved it.

Johnny || 08 || This really suited him this week. A fun track with a high register for him. I find him to be amusing.

The Risk || 07 || I do like them, but this was poor for them.

Sami || 06 || Tragic song choice. Good vocals but just so dull. Worst performance by her for me.

Janet || 05 || Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.

Craig || 04 || DULL DULL DULL. And I usually like him.

Rythmix || 03 || Not in the slightest bit rock. Just don't like their vocals.

 

--

 

Frankie || Too dire to rate || ABYSMAL. Seriously awful vocals, what a bloody rape of a really great Primal Scream track.

Misha B - Purple Rain

 

I love this because it's like Misha is doing a really good cover of Ruth Larenzo rather than Prince. Forget the comparisons because Misha took something Ruth did perfectly and made it her own. She is easily the best of the girls category - consistantly strong. 9/10

 

Kitty Brucknell = 10/10

Misha B = 9/10

Craig Coulton = 8/10

The Risk = 7/10

Janet Devlin = 7/10

Johnny Robinson = 7/10

Marcus Collins = 6/10

Sophie Abibis = 6/10

Sami Brooks = 5/10

Frankie Cocozza = 5/10

Rhythmix = 5/10

Oh. I'm disappointed. I thought that was really oversang in parts :( I thought there was a chance she could be better than Janet for the first time but I wouldn't even put that in my top 3 of the night.

 

Rates 2011 (week 3)

9.0 Janet Devlin - Sweet Child O' Mine

8.5 Kitty Brucknell - Live And Let Die

7.0 The Risk - Crazy

7.0 Misha B - Purple Rain

7.0 Sami Brookes - If I Could Turn Back Time

6.5 Marcus Collins - Are You Gonna Go My Way

5.0 Johnny Robinson - I Believe In A Thing Called Love

5.0 Sophie Habibis - Livin' On A Prayer

4.5 Craig Colton - Stop Crying Your Heart Out

4.0 Frankie Cocozza - Rocks

0.5 Rhythmix - TiK ToK / Push It

Edited October 22, 201113 yr by Bré

Not so sure I agree with Tulisa saying that... but honestly I can see Misha being a total c*nt backstage and I wouldn't want to get on her bad side!

Oh dear-Misha-gate!

Tulisa/Louis trying desperately to sabotage Misha's chances? :rolleyes:

 

I think Tulisa is worried she will be losing another act tomorrow night.

If Misha is a total bitch like Keisha Buchanan she just got more amazing.

Never argue with Kelly, Louis. She will 'put you down'.

Misha - One of my favourite performances tonight. But my, what a bitchy panel! It made for great telly though!

01 Kitty - f*** IT. I LOVE IT. 9.5/10

02 Misha - Very good, obviously. Not amazing for me, but very good. 9/10

03 Johnny - I'll probably never be taken seriously again on this forum for giving him a 9/10 - but I just adored that. 9/10

04 Janet - Okay, so the Diana Vickers / Ellie Goulding thing is gone. She's gone thoroughly down the Florence & The Machine route! Really enjoyed that. 8.5/10

05 Marcus - Oh, that was a great opener to the show! So energetic, yet it didn't lose tune. The performance in general. VERY impressed, because unlike most on here - I wasn't sold on the Russian Roulette or Moves Like Jagger performances. 8.5/10

06 Sophie - I really liked the whole atmospheric feel of it, as usual. She wasn't very good when she tried to up the notes though, which I'll penalise her for. Enjoyed it though! 8/10

07 The Risk - I'm getting pretty bored, and my comments are showing. As crap as he is - thank GOD Johnny is next. 6.5/10

08 Craig - It's slowly getting more and more... okay. Jar Of Hearts was superb, Best Thing I Never Had was okay, and this was okay too. Nothing else to say really. 6.5/10

09 Sami - She does have a good voice, she can sing almost every note in tune. But, is that gonna stop people thinking she's cruiseship/karaoke? Absolutely not, her weakest performance yet for me. 6/10

10 Rhythmix - I love Rhythmix, and I'm Like A Bird was my favourite performance of last week. But, this was vocally weak - a ridiculous song choice, and I'm disappointed. 5.5/10

11 Frankie - Shite. 0/10

 

I think bringing backstage antics up is fair game in all honesty. Anyway that was strong and confident and she owned the stage. The only minus point I'd give would be the slightly unadventurous choice of song but she delivered as ever.

 

9.0 Kitty

8.7 Misha B

8.2 Sophie

8.0 Craig

7.9 Janet

7.8 Marcus

7.7 Johnny

7.5 The Risk

6.8 Sami

4.4 Rhythmix

4.0 Frankie

 

Misha - Liked that a lot....probably my favourite from her since it was so raw. 8.5/10

 

Janet - 9/10

Kitty - 9/10

Misha - 8.5/10

Sophie - 8.5/10

Johnny - 8/10

Craig - 7/10

Sami - 7/10

Marcus - 6.5/10

Rhythmix - 6/10

The Risk - 3.5/10

Frankie - 0/10

 

Feel a bit like Louis & Tulisa could be trying to play up the apparent "attitude" of Misha for their own benefit....

 

Disappointed with Sophie tonight, she was the weakest of the girls for the first time. (imo)

 

Janet & Kitty were the highlights of tonight for me....and if I had my way the bottom two would The Risk & Frankie.

Edited October 22, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf

Never argue with Kelly, Louis. She will 'put you down'.

LOL

Kelly and Gary have been twats tonight, seriously. Ganging up on Tulisa due to differing opinions. Gary has been down right insulting to some contestans aswell. His efforts to copy Simon as "Mr Nasty" are cringe worthy and he is taking it too far, especially with Sami. I agree with Louis and Tulisa though, if Micah bullying other contestants that's completely unacceptable and I think it's right that she is called out on it. I don't know who Kelly thinks she is getting Tulisa's face then when she criticized Micah's behaviour

Hold on, have they missed out Sami from the recap? :o

 

Edit; she was included. Just rewound Sky+ - I wasn't paying attention but it just passed me by unnoticed. :lol: :ph34r: That's probably not a good sign for tomorrow night. :o

So, for me, the bottom 2 should be: Frankie & Rhythmix.

Not too surprised there have been complaints about Misha. Never really liked her too much.

 

I don't know why Kelly and Gary were saying they shouldn't get involved if there is bullying, surely they should help their contestants if they are being bullied? They both seemed to criticize everything Tulisa said tonight, also. -_-

Edited October 22, 201113 yr by Aidan

So it'll be Frankie vs. Rhythmix tomorrow surely? That's certainly what it should be. I don't really care that much who goes as long as it's not Janet, Misha, Kitty or The Risk though. Or Marcus because I did really like him last week but was a bit disappointed this week. Those 5 are much better than the rest (on reflection I gave Sami far too high a score today, it was more like 5.5).

Edited October 22, 201113 yr by Bré