Jump to content

Featured Replies

So glad Goodbye is out. One of Spice Girls’ worst.
  • Replies 522
  • Views 24.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Ew. And you two are two of my faves on here... Gtfo.

 

'Goodbye' has always been a Spice fave for me :o 'Independent Women' can get f***ed though. Awful and bland. 'Bootylicious' is overrated af too. I agree with Jade who said it's become more of a novelty hit now over time.

 

'Wake Me Up' is a bit of a guilty pleasure for me. It was definitely helped by nostalgia for me. 'In The Middle' though, I remember really loving it at the time, but amongst their back cat now, it sounds a bit dated and annoying. :(

Jade/Joe... goodbye. x

 

Jonjo... yay for supporting Goodbye, but as for that Independent Women hate - get out. x

Goodbye is gorgeous .

 

Prob their most mature sounding ballad .

Goodbye is a bit bland but I don't find it *that* offensive, I'd agree it's probably one of their weaker songs though (I ofc have a much more offensive Spice ballad opinion that's well documented :kink:).

 

I think I underrate both In The Middle and Wake Me Up until something like this reminds me of them being bops!

Spice girls are overrated.
For what they did for girl groups and pop music in general, overrated really can't be the word to describe Spice Girls. Whether you love them or hate them, I don't think you can call them overrated. :o Fair enough if you're not a fan, but "overrated" is thrown around far too loosely nowadays, imo.

 

It's like calling The Beatles, Madonna or Michael Jackson overrated, imo. They changed the landscape not only for girl groups but pop in general. Especially as it was dominated by boy bands and "brit pop" at the time!

  • Author

I'm fine to continue the results but if anyone wants to volunteer so the results can be posted more frequently, it'd help!

 

Otherwise I'll post 5 a day Mon - Fri.

For what they did for girl groups and pop music in general, overrated really can't be the word to describe Spice Girls. Whether you love them or hate them, I don't think you can call them overrated. :o Fair enough if you're not a fan, but "overrated" is thrown around far too loosely nowadays, imo.

 

It's like calling The Beatles, Madonna or Michael Jackson overrated, imo. They changed the landscape not only for girl groups but pop in general. Especially as it was dominated by boy bands and "brit pop" at the time!

 

 

Awwww you sweet Little Mix loon :wub: :wub: :wub:

 

So true though... every... single... word! :heart:

Beep is far too low, it is a classic!
The Beatles are overrated. Spice Girls outsold
  • Author
60 | Pussycat Dolls (ft. Busta Rhymes) - Don't Cha| 7.19 (more 10's)



UK Peak: 01
US Peak: 02

UK Chart Run: 10/09/2005 44-01-01-01-02-03-03-05-06-06-08-12-12-17-24-32-40-23-17-23-27-34-37-40-46-52-52-49-62-65-64-53-67-70-68-69-71-73-> 38wks

LOVED IT:,
SamJudd, Liam, Rush, NickF1, UltraReputation (10)

HATED IT:
Hayzayy (-1) missingyou (1)

At #60 is the debut single from the Pussycat Dolls, 'Don't Cha'. It was a huge hit in both the UK and the US and I think remains to be their biggest hit ever. I remember it being absolutely everywhere and it is often referenced, it is now seen as an iconic song even if a bit novelty in the same way 'Bootylicious' ended up. I personally think the girls have better but it's still a lot of fun and I remember thinking they would be a one hit wonder at the time!
  • Author
59 | The 411 - Dumb | 7.20



UK Peak: 03
US Peak: DNC

UK Chart Run: 04/09/200403-06-10-15-19-23-37-49-58-70-> 10wks

LOVED IT:,
Jack, Simon, missingyou, Liam, Mikee1981, HarryEzra, shindymindy, NickF1

HATED IT:
Spiceboy (1) HausOfTroye (2) michaelking21 (3)

At #59 is 'Dumb' by shortlived girlgroup, The 411! It was a Top 5 hit for them in the UK after (iirc) it was heavily featured in an advert. It followed debut single 'On My Knees' and did considerably better than that. I'm personally surprised to see it as high as this but surprised, it's still a bop and still somehow sounds fresh hearing it now! A somewhat forgotten gem, but thankfully not on BuzzJack!

Shocked don’t chandidnt reach number 1 in America .

 

Dumb is a tune. Shame the video is hideous.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.