Jump to content

AF idol 28 members have voted

  1. 1. Vote for your favourite

    • Family Portrait
      12
    • F**kin Perfect
      15

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted
For the next round, myself and Tboy have decided between family portrait and f**kin perfect. Help us decide which one to send by voting in the poll :cheer:
  • Replies 15
  • Views 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I went with 'Perfect'. I think nostalgia could benefit this one, I can remember the video being a big talking point growing up. It's also a more immediate, anthemic song too.

 

Listening to it now for the first time in forever and what a song! *.* I just wish the explicit version had that big "you're perfeeeeeect, to me!" at the end like the clean version has.

I went with 'Perfect'. I think nostalgia could benefit this one, I can remember the video being a big talking point growing up. It's also a more immediate, anthemic song too.

 

Listening to it now for the first time in forever and what a song! *.* Very likely to receive my vote.

 

I’ve gone for Family Portrait for similar reasons like nostalgia. But I guess with a young memberbase that could benefit Perfect more?

 

I personally think FP is more stand out. But happy to go with however the poll ends.

I think the relative recency of Perfect will give it a leg up, like you said, with some of the younger members, so I gave it my vote. Personally I don't really mind, I love both songs similarly!
I’ve gone for Family Portrait for similar reasons like nostalgia. But I guess with a young memberbase that could benefit Perfect more?

 

I personally think FP is more stand out. But happy to go with however the poll ends.

Yeah that's true about 'Family Portrait' too, but like you say I think there's a bigger demographic of members that would remember 'Perfect'. I also think there's going to be some big songs being sent through this round and think 'Perfect' might be better equipped to compete with them.

Family Portrait!

 

I actually think its popularly is massively underestimated on this forum.

Perfect is an 11/10 song, Family portrait maybe a 5/10
Perfect is an 11/10 song, Family portrait maybe a 5/10

 

Get out.

I prefer 'Family Portrait'!

 

I'm indecisive about which would do better. 'F**kin' Perfect' has the benefit timeline-wise for sure, but I'm not sure how loved it is? I could see it being, like, a lot of people's 9th favourite or so. I think 'Family Portrait' stands out more, especially lyrically, and is the kind of song that could make an immediate impact for first-time listeners, but it would be risky to rely on first-time listeners in a round probably full of well-known songs.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.