Jumping on the bandwagon here...!

 

Below is a series of pairings between One Direction's top 10 hits, group and solo. Simply bold your favourite song from each pairing, and the pair with the most votes will go through to round 2. Each pairing has been randomised.

 

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

 

Some of these are tough! Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect :cry: Night Changes vs Best Song Ever :cry:

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

 

...and you chose Watermelon Sugar? :frankie:

The public have also chosen Watermelon Sugar

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up
Strip That Down vs Little Things
Sign of the Times vs History
For You vs Story of My Life
What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town
Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect
PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)
Night Changes vs Best Song Ever
Gotta Be You vs One Thing
Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn
Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands
Adore You vs Steal My Girl
Live While We're Young vs Kiss You
Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

 

Screaming at me actually voting for 'Wishing On a Star' seriously

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

Did not expect to see a Wishing on a Star vote! :lol:

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

 

most of these are extremely easy as they're pitting a song I like against a song that is mediocre at best lol

 

('Wishing On A Star' is also mediocre at best, but you put it against my least favourite of the solo 1D songs on the list :'))

Our votes being exactly the same :cheeseblock:

The taste!

This Town over WMYB though...

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

This Town over WMYB though...

 

One of the best solo songs vs. one of the worst group songs, wbk

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

 

 

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

 

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

I Don't Wanna Live Forever vs Lights Up

Strip That Down vs Little Things

Sign of the Times vs History

For You vs Story of My Life

What Makes You Beautiful vs This Town

Watermelon Sugar vs Perfect

PILLOWTALK vs One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)

Night Changes vs Best Song Ever

Gotta Be You vs One Thing

Just Hold On vs Dusk Till Dawn

Drag Me Down vs Slow Hands

Adore You vs Steal My Girl

Live While We're Young vs Kiss You

Back to You vs Wishing On a Star

 

I had to search Youtube to double check what "For You" was :ph34r: Upon the reminder, it's amazing but "Story of My Life" is something else

 

The hardest cuts were "Perfect" (fab but "Watermelon Sugar" is peak 1D solo), "Night Changes" (THE hardest decision here but I do tend to side with a bop) and "Just Hold On" (:cry: sorry Louis, but Zayn is at his best when there's a female vocal on half the track)