#1: Tim McGraw (3), Teardrops on My Guitar (7)

#2: Teardrops on My Guitar (3), Our Song (4)

#3: Picture to Burn (3), Our Song (4)

#4: Our Song (2), Should've Said No (4)

#5: Should've Said No (2), Love Story (3)

#6: White Horse (1), Love Story (7)

#7: Love Story (3), You Belong With Me (8)

#8: Fifteen (1), You Belong With Me (8)

#9: Fearless (2), You Belong With Me (3)

#10: Mine (3), You Belong With Me (5)

#11: Back to December (5), You Belong With Me (7)

#12: Mean (2), You Belong With Me (10)

#13: The Story of Us (0), You Belong With Me (5)

#14: Sparks Fly (2), You Belong With Me (5)

#15: Ours (1), You Belong With Me (6)

#16: We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together (5), You Belong With Me (6)

#17: Begin Again (2), You Belong With Me (7)

#18: You Belong With Me (5), I Knew You Were Trouble (7)

#19: 22 (2), I Knew You Were Trouble (9)

#20: Red (2), I Knew You Were Trouble (7)

#21: Everything Has Changed (2), I Knew You Were Trouble (8)

#22: The Last Time (0), I Knew You Were Trouble (7)

#23: Shake It Off (4), I Knew You Were Trouble (11)

#24: I Knew You Were Trouble (5), Blank Space (7)

#25: Blank Space (5), Style (9)

#26: Bad Blood (6), Style (10)

#27: Style (6), Wildest Dreams (8)

#28: Out of the Woods (5), Wildest Dreams (6)

#29: New Romantics (2), Wildest Dreams (7)

#30: Look What You Made Me Do (3), Wildest Dreams (11)

#31: ...Ready For It? (3), Wildest Dreams (7)

#32: End Game (0), Wildest Dreams (12)

#33: New Year's Day (0), Wildest Dreams (10)

#34: Gorgeous (0), Wildest Dreams (14)

#35: Wildest Dreams (6), Delicate (7)

#36: Getaway Car (6), Delicate (9)

#37: ME! (3), Delicate (18)

#38: You Need to Calm Down (1), Delicate (11)

#39: Lover (3), Delicate (11)

#40: The Man (3), Delicate (8)

 

How this works (rules used from Shawn forum):

 

Each round, we'll pit two songs against one another. You vote for your favorite song of the two and the winner will advance to the next round where it will duel against another song - it'll stay in until it's knocked out by another song.

Open until Tuesday.

'cardigan' :wub:

I swear I voted for delicate and it added it to Cardigan 🤷🏼‍♂️🤔

cardigan! :heart:

Delicate.

 

I like Cardigan but it's a bit further down in the singles ranking for me.

 

I *might* do a ranking after the rate is completed tbh.

I love both, but I have to go with Delicate again.

Cardigan is much much better, the lyrics in particular are a million times better

cardigan! kind of feels weird to have something from folklore winning the whole thing tho, I figured "blank space" would've cruised all the way through.

Missed the last couple rounds but yeah it was obviously delicate was gonna obliterate the whole lover era! I’m shocked how little the title track put up a fight too, thought that would’ve done better than that!

 

Anyway this round is impossible, I adore both so goddamn much and are all time Taylor faves but I’m gonna throw my vote to delicate <3

Gonna go with 'Delicate'

cardigan! kind of feels weird to have something from folklore winning the whole thing tho, I figured "blank space" would've cruised all the way through.

 

Tbf the format of this does kind of heavily bias more recently released songs... :kink: