A few months ago, we held a survivor to find the Ultimate Madonna #1 from the US and/or the UK. Here are the results: http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=238401

 

We are now going to move to those unlucky singles that just missed out on the top spot. Included in this series are all songs that peaked at #2 in the UK and/or the US. Therefore some of the songs were #1 in one of the countries and #2 in the other and so have been included!

 

Here is the list of songs to be included and which country they reached #2 at:

 

The songs

Holiday (UK)

Borderline (UK)

Material Girl (US)

Crazy For You (UK)

Live to Tell (UK)

Causing a Commotion (US)

Express Yourself (US)

Cherish (US)

Hanky Panky (UK)

Justify My Love (UK)

I'll Remember (US)

Frozen (US)

Ray of Light (UK)

Beautiful Stranger (UK)

American Life (UK)

Hollywood (UK)

Me Against the Music (UK)

 

Playlist

 

First round is a DOUBLE ELIMINATION so please select your TWO least favourite songs!

I am certain of 'Hanky Panky' :kink: but after that, it's already super tough!!! I feel like 'Cherish' is going to get my second vote, but I will relisten to a few before committing to my choice :'(

This will be fun.

 

Hanky Panky

Me Against The Music

WAIT YES OF COURSE, 'Hanky Panky' and 'Me Against the Music' - 'Cherish' can get my vote next round :lol:

Same two for me, only I’d have Me Against the Music last

If we were judging Madonna's part only on 'Me Against the Music' then I'd say that would be one of my picks, but overall I really like the song. Maybe 'Hanky Panky' and 'Material Girl' for me.

Hanky Panky :puke2:

Me Against The Music

Hanky Panky

Me Against The Music

I would have to choose Me Against The Music and Hanky Panky

 

 

Picked 'Hanky Panky' (the worst here by far) and 'Causing a Commotion' - I love 'Me Against The Music' oops

Like so many others... Hanky Panky.

 

My second choice was Beautiful Stranger, which I just never took to (I also don't like Austin Powers, so I'm sure that had influence on my decision).

 

I know what I'll vote out next too... and that will be an unpopular opinion as well :unsure:

I know what I'll vote out next too... and that will be an unpopular opinion as well :unsure:

Intrigued about what this could be. My guess is one of the American Life singles?

Hanky Panky

Me Against The Music

 

 

Edited February 19, 20214 yr by Bjork

Intrigued about what this could be. My guess is one of the American Life singles?

 

Do you know, I kind of glazed over those when I first looked through the list... so Holiday may not be my next to vote out after all!!!

Closing today!

I've gone with 'Material Girl' and 'Hanky Panky' - I actually really enjoy the latter and was toying with picking something else... a shame to see it set to leave so early but not surprising really.

 

'Causing a Commotion' on four votes. :( It's Top 5 on this list for me!

Hanky Pany and Causing a commotion easily.

Hanky Panky and Beautiful Stranger.

CLOSED.