November 13Nov 13 I’ve always wondered whether the easier option is just to gradually increase the ACR ratio beyond what it is now as weeks on chart increase … We’ve seen from the album chart having a high turnover that it does incentivise interest in the charts. E.g. James Blunt this week.
November 13Nov 13 2 hours ago, AcerBen said:Don't see why the calculations need to be easy to understand. I'd rather they made the rules more complicated but resulted in a "better" chart.If the way a chart is compiled is easy to understand then joe public will want to understand and follow it and more people following it means more people noticing the new entries and getting them a bit further up the chart the next week etc. When the chart was essentially straight sales figures, with no streaming involved, then it was clear what it represented and therefore clear that it was definitive and meant something. Nowadays the chart rules are so complex that it has really got to the point that it barely means anything anymore because, as someone else said, the OCC could just be pulling the figures out of their ass since they don't directly correlate to anything in the real world now (even checking Spotifycharts won't help you know for sure where any given track ought to be in the OCC chart, what with ACR, three tracks per artist rules, uncertainty about what is or isn't reset in terms of older tracks, different ratios for different streaming services and for different groups of user within the same streaming service, and artists (or their management) deciding for themselves when to mail out pre-orders, and how many of them to mail out each week, for best chart advantage, when really all pre-orders should probably just be acrued to the first week of release). I just feel that if the chart represented something more meaningful and tangible then more people would follow it and more songs would get noticed and climb up the charts, improving turnover. It feels like the OCC's priority in the last decade or more has probably been to make a chart that no other company or market research body could ever replicate, thus ensuring no-one can check their workings and no other company/research body can get in on the act and sell a truly comparable chart to theirs instead of them selling their one, but that same process that ensures the OCC have a unique chart product also erodes the actual meaningfulness of the chart and the interest in it.
Saturday at 09:485 days I really don't think it's the formulation of the chart that makes people not interested in it anymore. There are so many other factors.All the little tweaks they've made are an effort to keep the chart a bit fresher and making sense. They are blunt instruments but precisely so that they are (relatively) easy to understand. Really the chart is halfway between the simple counting that the pure streaming chart is and the more dynamic chart I'd like to see with more sophisticated formulas. I'd like to see them go much further. I don't think getting rid of all these rules would make the charts more interesting to people. We'd have just had Rein Me In at number 1 for even longer probably. Edited Saturday at 09:515 days by AcerBen
Monday at 12:443 days Regrettably, AcerBen is right there - if anything, we already know that the 'real combined Top 200', i.e. the old-school literal rankings of combined consumption over eligible formats without any caps or exclusions applied, is even more stagnant and slow-moving that the manipulated version of it we get to see in the official 100. Okay, some weeks when a major new album is released that chart would see an en-masse invasion of some or all of the tracks from that long-player, which would shake things up hugely, but in most cases that effect would only last one or two initial weeks and then swiftly (excuse accidental pun!) die away, leaving the actual true weekly charts pretty unchanged from one week to the next, one month to the next, and even to some extent nowadays one year to the next, owing to the long-term impact of saturation streaming of the relatively few songs which become categorised as 'hits' and which appear on every pre-conceived (and a fair number of personally-compiled) playlist on the major providers' sites. And in any case, most agree that seeing a chart which is peppered with tracks from just one artist's latest release does not represent a more 'interesting' or appealing countdown, and is of course the main reason the primary artist cap of three songs was brought in ten years ago. Don't get me wrong; I dislike the Top 100 in a number of ways. In many contexts it'd be simpler, more honest, easier and in a lot of respects 'better' to have the real Top 200 chart instead of the semi-artificial one we get. It would suit purists who simply want the true, actual ranking of popularity, without sweeping exclusion or other rules that falsely change positions, however skewed or 'inconvenient' it would sometimes look, and those who'd like to have a current chart that's more readily comparable to those of previous eras (notwithstanding the inevitable complications brought about by the awkward but necessary juxtaposition of two entirely distinct forms of music consumption into one tabulation). But anyone wanting a weekly countdown that's characterised by more current material, possibly excluding a lot of catalogue songs, that moves more quickly, and arguably thereby generates wider public interest, the 'real chart' is not for you. So that inherently means that if such people are ever to be satisfied, the only solution would be some form of 'massaged' or, more bluntly, falsified, countdown that filters out what many are in agreement are undesirable features of how the real numbers look these days. Some would argue that's what we've already got and while no solution is ideal or pleases all, it does well enough for its purposes. The trouble will rule tweaks tends to be that while they might help resolve one issue, they could well exacerbate and worsen others. Personally, I think I'd just like to have sight of the real Top 200 just to compare it with the official one, to see what historical record really should've looked like, however sluggish, however dull and however many weird weeks of single-act divebombing there may be! But of course we all understand why the OCC will never allow it to see the light of day. Ironically, if they did, or if it were to be leaked, that might actually be the impetus for more people to show more interest in the singles charts, albeit probably only for a short while after, and with the inevitable debates that would ensue about whether it's right to manipulate 'official' positions and if so, to what extent (i.e. what the likes of us have been arguing about for over a decade on fora like these!!).
Monday at 12:513 days Yesterday there were a heap of re-entries on the Big Top 40 and some interesting new entries which even pushed out Rein Me In. Any reason why?
Monday at 14:423 days 1 hour ago, Sami Hook Jama said:Yesterday there were a heap of re-entries on the Big Top 40 and some interesting new entries which even pushed out Rein Me In. Any reason why?The Big Top 40 doesn't have anything to do with The Official UK Top 100., sorry to disappoint you there.
Monday at 21:453 days They should change the rules and move songs over 3 years old into a new singles chart and keep the main singles chart just for songs that are under 3 years old
Monday at 22:023 days On 10/08/2026 at 17:13, PeteFromLeeds said:The alternative would be leaving the charts as they are and 'revamping' the niche charts like the Rock / Dance charts to make success on there a more prestigious thing, so getting into the 'main' chart is less of an event.Given that so far this year we've seen the UK Christian Chart, Homegrown Albums Chart, UK R&B Chart and UK Rap Chart launched, I'm starting to wonder whether the OCC are taking this route and seeing the 'solution' as giving more artists the opportunity to get onto some kind of chart rather than trying to fix a main chart which they see as unfixable.
Tuesday at 02:172 days 4 hours ago, Hadji said:They should change the rules and move songs over 3 years old into a new singles chart and keep the main singles chart just for songs that are under 3 years oldJust want to note that Australia effectively does this and we're on 3 weeks in a row without a top 50 debut, potentially 4 weeks in Friday, but ironically we wouldn't be if older songs could chart freely. Cheap band-aid solutions never fix the root of the issue and require increasingly great suspensions of disbelief when we pretend to ascribe significance to what's left over.
Tuesday at 11:142 days 22 hours ago, Gambo said:Regrettably, AcerBen is right there - if anything, we already know that the 'real combined Top 200', i.e. the old-school literal rankings of combined consumption over eligible formats without any caps or exclusions applied, is even more stagnant and slow-moving that the manipulated version of it we get to see in the official 100. Okay, some weeks when a major new album is released that chart would see an en-masse invasion of some or all of the tracks from that long-player, which would shake things up hugely, but in most cases that effect would only last one or two initial weeks and then swiftly (excuse accidental pun!) die away, leaving the actual true weekly charts pretty unchanged from one week to the next, one month to the next, and even to some extent nowadays one year to the next, owing to the long-term impact of saturation streaming of the relatively few songs which become categorised as 'hits' and which appear on every pre-conceived (and a fair number of personally-compiled) playlist on the major providers' sites. And in any case, most agree that seeing a chart which is peppered with tracks from just one artist's latest release does not represent a more 'interesting' or appealing countdown, and is of course the main reason the primary artist cap of three songs was brought in ten years ago.Don't get me wrong; I dislike the Top 100 in a number of ways. In many contexts it'd be simpler, more honest, easier and in a lot of respects 'better' to have the real Top 200 chart instead of the semi-artificial one we get. It would suit purists who simply want the true, actual ranking of popularity, without sweeping exclusion or other rules that falsely change positions, however skewed or 'inconvenient' it would sometimes look, and those who'd like to have a current chart that's more readily comparable to those of previous eras (notwithstanding the inevitable complications brought about by the awkward but necessary juxtaposition of two entirely distinct forms of music consumption into one tabulation). But anyone wanting a weekly countdown that's characterised by more current material, possibly excluding a lot of catalogue songs, that moves more quickly, and arguably thereby generates wider public interest, the 'real chart' is not for you. So that inherently means that if such people are ever to be satisfied, the only solution would be some form of 'massaged' or, more bluntly, falsified, countdown that filters out what many are in agreement are undesirable features of how the real numbers look these days. Some would argue that's what we've already got and while no solution is ideal or pleases all, it does well enough for its purposes. The trouble will rule tweaks tends to be that while they might help resolve one issue, they could well exacerbate and worsen others.Personally, I think I'd just like to have sight of the real Top 200 just to compare it with the official one, to see what historical record really should've looked like, however sluggish, however dull and however many weird weeks of single-act divebombing there may be! But of course we all understand why the OCC will never allow it to see the light of day. Ironically, if they did, or if it were to be leaked, that might actually be the impetus for more people to show more interest in the singles charts, albeit probably only for a short while after, and with the inevitable debates that would ensue about whether it's right to manipulate 'official' positions and if so, to what extent (i.e. what the likes of us have been arguing about for over a decade on fora like these!!).Surely you can get a good idea of what it'd look like by looking at the Official Streaming Chart? Isn't that basicallyn the "pure chart", minus any sales, which probably don't affect it much? Edited Tuesday at 11:142 days by AcerBen
Tuesday at 14:292 days Yeah I guess so, on most weeks where relatively few sales per release have been made. I suppose what I was driving at, somewhat frustratedly, is that the 'real deal' as it were with singles is consistently hidden from public view. And as I said, I understand the reasoning, but it has always jarred with me as a longstanding chart watcher that there's no real way of accessing the true chart in its Top 200 form - even UKChartsPlus cannot have it. This feels particularly galling as we did have over ten straight years of what was more-or-less a restrictions-free official chart, Top 100 via OCC and 200 if you were a UKCP subscriber. From 1 January 2007 to 29 June 2017 it existed free of manipulations and while it doesn't represent my personal halcyon period in terms of the popular music it was monitoring, when I look at it with my 'technical chart hat' on, it stands out as the perfect decade of DUS-era reality, as most other periods before and since were/are dogged by some form of restrictions that deliberately skewed the real rankings (however understandable the reasons for it), or in the earlier years before such rules were applied (pre-July 1975), it was simply inconsistent, tardy and sometimes dishonest manual records from stores included in the panel sales system and limited compiler capacities which made for an often inaccurate or incomplete weekly chart. But nevertheless, as I concluded, what we presently have is likely as reasonable a compromise in a difficult situation as it might get, and endless tweaks probably won't result in giant gains and definitely won't please all of us. It is just a crying shame that musically, a lot of the decent stuff across many genres seldom gains any traction on the main chart, and that's not really the chart or the OCC's problem - as long as vast numbers more people keep streaming the same old crap most of the time, that's what'll get reflected in the weekly rundown. 'twasever thus as they say.
Tuesday at 14:342 days I feel like scrapping ACR but bringing in the recurrent system the New Zealand chart has would be clever. They have a catalog chart but with the exception of Christmas iirc, songs with 76+ weeks on the chart or ancient songs are instantly thrown to the catalog chart, keeping in the newer songs. I believe this system works amazingly. Would keep the chart relatively fresh.
Tuesday at 14:532 days This topic is constantly dug up isn't it 🤣I've said my views on what would improve things many times... Counting a solitary listen definitely won't do anything. It really depends what the OCC are trying to capture with the charts...Assuming it's "what were the most listened to songs this week?", then what they're doing currently is best without ACR, and shouldn't really be impacted by premium vs free. It sets a limit per day, for each user, to prevent abuse of the system. And it assigns a very high value for each actual sale, based on the assumption that someone purchasing a record will listen to it alot.If the question being answered is "what songs are people investing in for the first time?", the current model isn't suitable at all. With this method, which would be more akin to the calculations before streaming was factored in, you would need a lifetime cap on streams per song, for each user. 1 is definitely too low, that means even curiosity streams by those that don't like the song would be counted, and 100 is probably far too high. I think you'd need a rough average of how many times people listen to songs they repeatedly listen to, and set it a little lower than than (I've always spouted 10, at a guess).I've always leant towards the second method being a better way of doing it if we want a quicker/fresher chart that isn't clogged up with everyone's favourite classics that we already know are popular - that still allows for old songs getting a surge in popularity from a new generation of people to chart. But the fact is, without the data, none of us know how that would play out.All I know for certain is that ACR/different ratios for paid vs free streams/different rules for resets (depending on whether the OCC want to follow them or not)/whatever else make for a highly artificial chart that is really fairly meaningless, and I'm not sure why the OCC think that that's particularly sustainable in the long run. It's not exciting for most people that care about having accurate data, it's not exciting for people who might find keeping an eye out on new releases thrilling, and surely it's not that useful to the industry if their consumption isn't being displayed in a meaningful metric where everyone's on the same playing field...
Tuesday at 14:592 days One quick fix is to change the 25% increase rule for SCR back to 50% like it used to be. Surely then you'd still get the HUGE impacters rightfully re-chart but you wouldn't get resets for songs just because the singer sneezed one week.
Tuesday at 18:132 days Quickest and easiest "fix" is to remove ACR and any other limitations and report the data as is. While that will almost certainly lead to a reasonably static chart, it would reflect what people are 'listening' to...It's fascinating how things have changed. Prior to streaming, all the UK chart compilers were strongly against recording what people were listening to rather than what they purchased. Now that the way most of us(?) consume music has changed (not for me, but others), everything is more about listening than purchasing.... Edited Tuesday at 18:422 days by braindeadpj
Tuesday at 18:332 days Don't include playlisted songs provided byspotify apple Amazon etc in charts hot hits etc etc etc Edited Tuesday at 18:342 days by Scone1
Tuesday at 18:352 days 2 minutes ago, Scone1 said:Don't include playlisted songs provided byspotify apple Amazon etc in charts hot hits etc etc etcWelcome to a chart with even fewer new songs and even more "golden oldies".
Tuesday at 19:132 days 4 hours ago, Dobbo said:One quick fix is to change the 25% increase rule for SCR back to 50% like it used to be. Surely then you'd still get the HUGE impacters rightfully re-chart but you wouldn't get resets for songs just because the singer sneezed one week.Also change ACR slightly so that it's a decrease over a period of weeks such as a decline in 3 of the last 4 weeks. That will stop a lot of songs dodging ACR when on DLC-2/gaining minimally to be back to SCR before going back to DLC-1 the week after. With both suggestions songs like "Die With A Smile" would have declined out of the chart quicker and not be reset so often. Edited Tuesday at 19:132 days by Envoirment
Tuesday at 19:262 days 4 hours ago, Gambo said:Yeah I guess so, on most weeks where relatively few sales per release have been made. I suppose what I was driving at, somewhat frustratedly, is that the 'real deal' as it were with singles is consistently hidden from public view. And as I said, I understand the reasoning, but it has always jarred with me as a longstanding chart watcher that there's no real way of accessing the true chart in its Top 200 form - even UKChartsPlus cannot have it. This feels particularly galling as we did have over ten straight years of what was more-or-less a restrictions-free official chart, Top 100 via OCC and 200 if you were a UKCP subscriber. From 1 January 2007 to 29 June 2017 it existed free of manipulations and while it doesn't represent my personal halcyon period in terms of the popular music it was monitoring, when I look at it with my 'technical chart hat' on, it stands out as the perfect decade of DUS-era reality, as most other periods before and since were/are dogged by some form of restrictions that deliberately skewed the real rankings (however understandable the reasons for it), or in the earlier years before such rules were applied (pre-July 1975), it was simply inconsistent, tardy and sometimes dishonest manual records from stores included in the panel sales system and limited compiler capacities which made for an often inaccurate or incomplete weekly chart.But nevertheless, as I concluded, what we presently have is likely as reasonable a compromise in a difficult situation as it might get, and endless tweaks probably won't result in giant gains and definitely won't please all of us. It is just a crying shame that musically, a lot of the decent stuff across many genres seldom gains any traction on the main chart, and that's not really the chart or the OCC's problem - as long as vast numbers more people keep streaming the same old crap most of the time, that's what'll get reflected in the weekly rundown. 'twasever thus as they say.But that chart is still manipulated because the way the count the streams and combine with sales. You can't have a completely pure chart anymore. If you want a chart that is pure counting, then that's the Streaming Chart anyway.
Create an account or sign in to comment