Jump to content

Featured Replies

Just now, danG said:

what is this “well done Dan”, I could feasibly be behind any of the remaining acts here o

or maybe I’ve just been eliminated o

DarinG?

  • Replies 2.7k
  • Views 149k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • WELL WELL WELL... it was me, who'd have guessed?! Surprisingly, not everyone! I really f***ed this round up for myself and I knew it from the minute I opened the thread, to be honest. I just took the

  • The next two MALES through to Boot Camp: Part Two... are... and...

  • Not a common phrase on Buzzjack but WE LOVE THE BUSH <3

Posted Images

Sorry for Kate and Sam, both @Jade and @Jack have showcased their acts so well, so glad Babooshka was played it’s my ultimate fave Kate song, gutted dancing with a stranger didn’t get its time, I suspect it might have been on its way!

Edited by Spiceboy

Oh wow I thought Jack was Marina!!!!!!!!

you did well with Sam though!

Not really a massive fan of their music, but I was surprised I liked more than I thought x

Edited by ElectroBoy

Me each time I was linked to the Bush:

the-s-impsons-bush.gif

Thank you so much for the write-up, Calum. ❤️

Commiserations Jack! My favourite Sam-related song is 'Latch', so a shame that didn't get to be played, but you did a great job with them.

(I prepared an entire strategy dissertation at the weekend when I thought 'Army Dreamers' might knock me out LOL, which I slightly amended earlier, better go and fetch that xx)

Congrats @Jack and @Jade really great performances! Thanks for show casing your artists really well. cheer

So yeah, here's one I prepared earlier...

Firstly, Bré's suspicions of me sending Gary Numan / a man was solid logic after I'd previously competed with a female act in series 1 and a group last time. In fact, I was planning to complete the set this time, but plans were altered after Calum announced a changing of the parameters for series 3. The man I had in mind wasn't European so I panicked! My heart was set on a certain person, so I mulled it over and decided to push back 'completing the set' to a future edition.

I thought it'd probably be now or never for Kate as I suspected some others might want her in a European-only field. A few people linked me and the Bush early on amongst the sea of Fontaines guesses (which were understandable, considering how much I love them, like a lot of people pinning me down as ROSALÍA last time!) - Dandy and Scene on the forum, plus Chez off-site on SyncTube (either at a BJSC or '80s listening session, where the topic of Pop Factor came up) - the latter was quite mysterious about his suspicions. I soon thought... hang on... Chez mentioned he was beaten to his first choice and I publicly announced that I had got my first choice, while swept up in the excitement of it all. Had I beaten him to Kate? I probably would've represented a male artist on this occasion if Chez hadn't already sent Bowie to the last edition... so maybe this time I had snatched a potential artist off his list in return thinking especially as our music taste is so similar. Apologies if this was the case! If not then I'm intrigued about your early suspicions.

I had a lot of fun in the previous two editions as the mentor for Addison Rae and Blondie, but it was frustrating to miss out on the live shows on both occasions, 'Diet Pepsi' just 1 point away from advancing and 'Call Me' 3 points away in a year where the '1 act per category' rule had not yet come to fruition. So I was delighted that it was indeed third time lucky for me with Kate Bush! I learnt so much from my previous two experiences that I could apply this time. So, let's dive into strategy...

Round 1: 'Hounds of Love' (free choice)

I could immediately apply a lesson learnt from playing Addison here! I sent 'Aquamarine' for her in round 1 and thought I'd be safe as houses with that banger, but she actually struggled more than anticipated. So I remembered this time that the female category can be seriously competitive and people might want to arrive on a strong note. Indeed this category was once again a bloodbath - who would've predicted Tove Lo out first?! I thought I'd arrive with a fairly strong Kate pick, so not top tier like 'Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)' or 'Wuthering Heights' yet, but also not something too risky. I felt the well regarded 'Hounds of Love' was a happy medium and sonically it is very urgent sounding, so tied in well as an arrival song. This pick did the business for her so I was happy with my round 1 performance!

Round 2: 'The Man With the Child In His Eyes' (free choice)

One element to my strategy that people may, or may not, have noticed was that I wanted to challenge myself by never repeating the same era twice in a row! So I moved from the Hounds of Love album over to Kate's debut, The Kick Inside, this time. I'd survived a strong first round and thought I had a bit more breathing room this time. I selected the lovely 'The Man with the Child In His Eyes', quickly showing off Kate's sonic diversity with a slower pick, plus it was a top 10 hit - so not exactly super risky to me on paper. However, this did struggle a bit more than expected, as I think it was bottom 3! So that was food for thought. But, at the end of the day, I wasn't last - so this had still done enough and I could move forward. It was nice to see some appreciation for this song all the same! One comment that stuck with me was Rollo pointing out that Kate wrote this song when she was just 13 years old, a fact that has always stayed with me too. Very impressive!

Round 3: 'Reaching Out' (should've been a single)

Now I thought I'd test out another Kate era, The Sensual World, a personal favourite for both me and Robert Smith. I remember Chez commenting that he would've liked something from The Ninth Wave section of Hounds of Love for this round, but I was 100% planning to send something from that later on in the contest. Perhaps that would've been a safer move at this point but I was hoping 'Reaching Out' would be enough for round 3 nevertheless. I think Kate sounds incredible on this song and the chorus really stuck with me after I first explored her albums years ago, so thought it would be a viable single, in an alternate universe. However, this is one of those occasions when my personal taste wasn't quite in line with the forum and I came close to leaving, bottom 2 drama I noticed quite a lot of comments about how Kate sounded amazing but that the song itself didn't do much for them. On a positive note, Dandy's comment stuck with me, that after repeated listens he could see how this would've made sense as a single choice. So yeah... I was playing dangerously here in the end but once again had avoided coming last, which was all that mattered at the end of the day. I quickly realised just how competitive this category was and needed to switch things up a bit now!

Round 4: 'Cloudbusting' (free choice)

Kate was losing momentum after a couple of low finishes and people were beginning to write her off. So now felt like time to go bigger again! I thought I'd mine from the classic Hounds of Love singles run once more, like in round 1. 'Cloudbusting' is one of my favourite songs of hers, well regarded and known despite only peaking at #20 and has an extra layer of familiarity thanks to the 'Something Good' dance reworkings by Utah Saints (something that would become relevant later on in the contest...), but wasn't a top tier trump card I'd need later on, so felt like the right level to send at this point. I felt validated when Rich commented that 'Cloudbusting' was the exact song he expected Kate's mentor to send to this round! It worked and Kate felt like a bit more of a contender again; I was happy with this performance. I didn't know at the time that this would make 'Something Good' ineligible for the remix round but at the end of the day, it would've been criminal to not send the original 'Cloudbusting' at any point!

Round 5: 'This Woman's Work' (Six Chair Challenge)

Now I wanted to continue with a strong choice while sticking to my rule of not repeating the same era twice in a row. So it was back to The Sensual World for a much loved Kate song and another personal favourite, what a stunner. I think a few people had recently mentioned how much they liked this song too so it was also on my mind for that reason. It was a shame this didn't get full public attention, due to the powers falling into the hands of our judges this time, but never mind! So yeah, Six Chair Challenge, utter chaos! lol I consider Iz to have quite similar taste to me, but the judge I hoped for most was actually Jaz, just because I noticed him putting Kate top / near the top of his votes quite consistently so far, whereas MARINA appeared to be the act Iz had most loyalty towards. So Jaz seemed like the one who would most likely be in Kate's corner. But Iz was still a great, forensic judge to have and his alt leanings could work in her favour nevertheless. I also felt 'This Woman's Work' would probably stand out in a crowd, when trying to assess this logically. I was delighted Iz saw the magic in this song and sent Kate through! Although it was of course sad to lose the two women who did end up departing.

Round 6: 'Wuthering Heights' (top 10 most streamed)

My lessons learnt from Blondie were now kicking in at this point. This was: don't be afraid to go BIG when the occasion calls for it, as I really kicked myself for not using 'Heart of Glass' at the opportune moment. It wasn't quite time for Gamu yet, like in that situation, so Kate's biggest trump card felt a bit premature. Instead, I wasn't going to be afraid to send her second most loved song and my own personal favourite, as this category was just ridiculously competitive. I thought I just need to get past the females and will have a bit more room to breathe if she makes it to the lives later on. So 'Wuthering Heights' it was. Maybe I could've got away with 'Babooshka' but who knows, I wasn't taking any chances... seems like other mentors had similar ideas as 'Murder On The Dancefloor' and 'With Every Heartbeat' showed up !!! So this wasn't even Kate's chance to win a round, settling for 3rd behind those two juggernauts, but they seemed to be quite a clear cut top 3 with the public. I was a tiny bit worried that Kate's striking vocal performance would be a bit much for some (indeed a couple commented on it) but overall, the strength of this classic came through. The Bush was still fighting.

Round 7: 'Experiment IV' (bottom 10 streamed)

I panicked a bit when I saw this theme and thought oh gosh, am I going to have to send birdsong, or the one where her and Stephen Fry list different types of snow (even if that is genuinely my favourite from its parent album haha)?! But then, I looked at her list and thought I'd lucked out, when I remembered her Best Of The Other Sides compilation was only uploaded to streaming last year. 'Experiment IV' is genuinely a favourite for me so I was delighted when I realised it was her 9th least streamed, due to how recently it had been uploaded. A single and everything. I remember dropping pretence a tiny bit here to serve #facts when people accused Kate of cheating, which was understandable as she had so much junk on her Kworb list below 'Experiment IV' at a quick glance, but it was mostly just a bunch of remastered duplicates and live versions that needed to be removed. Once that was applied, this indeed qualified for the round. However... this is one of those instances when my own taste does not match up to the general Pop Factor audience; this got some harsh comments even during a private voting round lol this experiment sadly did not work out, a distant last even below a demo (no shade to Zara - just funny that a single wasn't enough to beat a demo!!) - was gutted to have been tripped up on a 'dregs' round, even if with a song I really like. Flashbacks to Ariana being lumbered with 'Beauty and the Beast' in an AF Idol 'flops' round x Still, Kate had her trump card, so I wasn't going to give up on her yet... This round was also a bit of a blessing in disguise (unless Kate had not come back in the end, then boo hiss x) as I probably would've sent 'Experiment IV' to one of the live shows, due to it being a personal favourite. Maybe that wouldn't have been as much of a disaster outside of the competitive female category, but yeah, I didn't have to find out now.

Round 8: 'Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)' (Gamu)

Now it was 100% time for Kate's golden ticket! Upon submission, I was confident this would see her through, as it's so beloved and with a unique level of generational crossover - with those who remember it from the '80s, the 2012 Olympics, plus from Stranger Things. However, I must say I was a little concerned for Kate's chances when an Agnes campaign seemed to be forming in the thread. I wasn't going to play dirty though and submitted honestly as ever, ranking 'Release Me' as high as 3rd (what a banger!) behind my own Kate classic and 'Stan', as I decided not to penalise Dido and just go on song quality. Turns out I didn't need to be worried as Kate was just about the most comfortable winner of the three categories, despite being a person down (Robyn/Dandy much missed </3) in a victorious outcome for retro acts! I felt so bad for Agnes' mentor as they'd had rotten luck with their trajectory so far. But as for Kate, I was so happy she managed to win a round and FINALLY got me a route to the live shows after missing out with both of my previous acts, yay!!

Round 9: 'Babooshka' (Live show 1, free choice)

I wondered if people would go big and use this round as the opportunity for a reset. Many factors were making 'Babooshka', Kate's last big hitter, the one for me. I really didn't want to make it to the live shows for the first time only to go out in round one. I also thought it'd be pretty neat timing for the witchy 'Babooshka' as the round coincided with Halloween. In addition to this, I realised I hadn't sent anything from Never for Ever yet, so would be good to showcase another Kate era, especially as I continued to ban myself from sending something from the same album twice in a row. Finally, I quite liked the idea of a freeing, experimental run once this big hitter was played. So I just thought... let's see how far she can go and I'll continue to send choices I love. 'Babooshka' it was and Kate's live show experience began on a high, including some notable love from members who weren't always her biggest fan. Rob ranking this 2nd comes to mind! Oh and Rob... I always think of that holistic vocal coach woman from X Factor when I hear this song too lol this did the business for Kate and saw her through comfortably. Now it was going to get seriously interesting for my game plan!

Round 10: 'The Big Sky (Meteorological Mix)' (Live show 2, club bangers/remixes)

Kate was the butt of the joke when this round was announced as least likely to have a club banger in her repertoire. However, I actually thought I'd hit the jackpot as I assumed I could send 'Something Good' by Utah Saints (albeit a very cheeky move as a repackaged 'Cloudbusting'), but then the rules of no song repeats were laid out, so it was looking a bit more shaky for Kate! The Meteorological Mix of 'The Big Sky' was by far my favourite other option available for her, but I was concerned it would be too long and left-field (didgeridoo in the club anyone?) to make it through. I think M83's initial exit with a long, unconventional pick was in the back of my mind. But still, I really loved this mix, so thought I'd go with my heart and hope it'd find its fans. It'd certainly stand out anyway! The first rank it received in the thread was a last place, so I quickly began to prepare myself for Kate leaving now. However, her fortunes turned around as some of you really seemed to love this! It was particularly amazing to see Rich ranking Kate 1st for the first time <3 I actually did hope he would be a fan, as someone who often comments on percussion, as the drumming on this song is pretty impactful. This choice was a bit too eccentric to properly dominate or anything but it kept Kate safe for another round, which was all that mattered. What a pleasant surprise!

Round 11: 'Army Dreamers' (Live show 3, free choices)

Pete wondered if the rationale behind sending this was because the round fell at the time of Remembrance Day. The answer to that is... not solely, but it was a contributing factor. I once again wanted to avoid repeating an album and 'The Big Sky' is originally from Hounds of Love, so thought I'd wait a little bit longer to unleash some of my favourite album tracks from that record. I looked to Kate's most streamed for some inspiration from another album and was reminded that 'Army Dreamers' is her 2nd most streamed on Spotify (!!! yes, even above 'Wuthering Heights'), so BuzzJack not quite as fond of it as the TikTok youth tongue in all seriousness, I was surprised by this too, but apparently it had a moment on there a few years ago. I slotted this in as an option. I already thought this song was great but properly fell in love with it upon revisiting it for this contest. The lyrics are indeed hard-hitting, as pointed out by some, plus sonically I thought it would continue to show off Kate's versatility, with its waltz-like execution. On top of this, I love a connecting factor, so the timing of Remembrance Day felt like another sign. I assumed it might struggle, despite the streaming numbers, but hoped it could perhaps scrape through. I was fully expecting to walk into a round of 'Venus', 'Blue Monday', 'Personal Jesus' etc., so had a tiny bit more hope for Kate before any votes came in, as the field was more unpredictable than assumed. When it was time for the results, I was now expecting to be straight out, as Bananarama suddenly got a massive surge on the last day and Fontaines seemed to be hanging in there, so I was shocked when New Order were straight out, as they flew under the radar compared to those three who had attracted the danger zone talk in the thread. I hated being up against Fontaines, as they were my favourite in that round, but did hope I could cling on one more time after finding out what the next round was - SO up artsy Kate's street. Thank you judges for saving her even if it was brutal to lose Fontaines D.C. in the same breath! I'm glad we at least received the exact same amount of points though so I wasn't robbing another act who had genuinely been more popular in the voting.

Round 12: 'Hello Earth' (Live show 4, suave, sophisticated, artistic)

I actually assumed this would be a 'slow dance' type round, as Rich suggested, as a companion piece to club bangers. I had already pencilled in 'Hello Earth' for such a round as this haunting song is my favourite Kate album track. However, instead it was this 'suave, sophisticated, artistic' round, which couldn't suit this musical genius more. I thought I would stick with the 'Hello Earth' pick, as it's from the much acclaimed, highly sophisticated art-rock Ninth Wave part of Hounds of Love, so still felt on theme. Something from Aerial or especially The Dreaming would've been a good fit too, as the latter is such an uncompromising body of work, but by this point I was gagging to send 'Hello Earth', after coming so close to not getting to unleash it at all. I suppose an album track was a bit risky but it was such a striking one to me, so I'm pleased Kate got to leave on a high. I particularly loved finding out just now that it was one of Rob's favourite choices for her! If I had to be knocked out by anyone then I'm not mad it's Depeche Mode.

These were my future choices:

Round 13: 'The Sensual World' - one I felt was a good combination of personal favourite and with appeal for Pop Factor from the options left; I also thought the folky instruments would stand out

Round 14: 'Jig Of Life' - some more folk instruments if that last choice went down well, another really striking album track from Hounds of Love and has a bit of familiarity for BJSC participants who were in the 100th edition

Round 15: 'Suspended in Gaffa' - the in demand 'December Will Be Magic Again' probably would've been a better competitive choice than some of these, but wanted to stay true to myself and unleash my absolute favourites even if I do enjoy that too. The Dreaming is generally Pop Factor poison, but I still wanted to use something from that era and this is my favourite song from the album <3 would it win against 'Someone Like You'? no, but what a tune x

...and I wouldn't have even got into several other Kate albums I also enjoy yet, like Lionheart or Aerial! I did especially consider 'Nocturn' from the latter album as a huge swerve that could've been a good discovery for some. What a discography, I am honoured to have represented Queen Bush, one of my absolute favourite artists. She's of course a marvel and paved the way for many who came after her. Kate's never been afraid to take some pretty wild risks in her time but could also create something with as much universal appeal as 'Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)'. I greatly admire her!

For those who want to do a bit of further listening (or may be curious because who doesn't love lists on BuzzJack x) - these are my top 3 songs from every Kate album:

The Kick Inside: Wuthering Heights, The Man with the Child in His Eyes, Oh to Be in Love

Lionheart: Hammer Horror, Coffee Homeground, In Search of Peter Pan

Never for Ever: Babooshka, Blow Away, Army Dreamers

The Dreaming: Suspended in Gaffa, Sat In Your Lap, Leave It Open

Hounds Of Love: Hello Earth, Cloudbusting, Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)

The Sensual World: This Woman's Work, The Sensual World, The Fog

The Red Shoes: Top Of The City, Lily, Moments Of Pleasure

Aerial: Nocturn, King Of The Mountain, Aerial

50 Words For Snow: 50 Words For Snow, Misty, Lake Tahoe

(I know Director's Cut counts as a studio album too but I view that in a separate way, since it's reworkings)

Here is also a playlist of all my highlights from her (there are a LOT of them lol), in order of preference (minus a couple of backing vocal highlights/Utah Saints remixes that I stuck at the end), that are available on streaming if anyone is interested in some more expansive inspiration. I was fully behind every song I sent, but there's of course a lot more weird and wonderful stuff I love tucked away here too, that didn't necessarily feel suitable for a Pop Factor audience.

Thank you so much Calum for doing a stellar job with this as ever and being a supportive presence in the background. The contest isn't without its moments of drama, which can be a bit much for me at times, but all of the music and passion, in addition to the hard work from our host keep me coming back for more.

Best of luck to all of those still remaining! I can relax now lol x

So who is left in?

Dan, Spiceboy, Lee, Mango....

Joseph?

Oh - Paddington

Edited by ElectroBoy

Thank you, I was v happy to make it as far as I did!

I'll do a full write up at some point, I wish I didn't use sone of the bigger hits early on but oh well.

Dancing With A Stranger, Unholy and Latch would've been played next in thar order!

well played Jade and Jack

Sam S has always been rather hit and miss for me but glad most of their better songs managed to get played. Nirvana unfortunately wasn’t to my taste and I ranked it last. The Bush I need to familiarise myself a bit more with as the big hitters obviously great and some of the deeper cuts were rather interesting too (will go through that essay later)

I had an inkling Jade was Kate Bush right from the start, the reason that I couldn't reveal until now is that she was my first choice artist that I was beaten to! Of those inhumanly quick typers I'd seen had confirmed before I even opened the form, I just couldn't seen Kate Bush being anyone else. Julian was my other suspect, but him being Gary Numan confirmed it otherwise (And reading that more than one other person was after her, I wouldn't be surprised if you had gone with her as well as a first choice?)

Absolutely no hard feelings from me though as you did a fantastic job with her, I'm really glad you got to showcase all her hits and they were smartly timed to get to the live shows and some great lesser known moments as well like Army Dreamers and Experiment IV as well and I'm particularly pleased we got something from the Ninth Wave given I thought that chance had gone when the album track round didn't feature it! I think King of the Mountain is the only song I'd have liked to see (or maybe something from her Snow album if you wanted to be really risk taking), but it's not a super essential one. Edit: Thank you for those recommendations and I'll definitely check those out!

Well played from Jack as well, a shame we didn't get Latch and Dancing With a Stranger as my big favourites, but it did remind me they can be an interesting artist outside of the ballads.

Depeche Mode the sole alt factor representatives left then, only option next round is to reach out and touch faith!

15 minutes ago, Jade said:

So yeah, here's one I prepared earlier...

Firstly, Bré's suspicions of me sending Gary Numan / a man was solid logic after I'd previously competed with a female act in series 1 and a group last time. In fact, I was planning to complete the set this time, but plans were altered after Calum announced a changing of the parameters for series 3. The man I had in mind wasn't European so I panicked! My heart was set on a certain person, so I mulled it over and decided to push back 'completing the set' to a future edition.

I thought it'd probably be now or never for Kate as I suspected some others might want her in a European-only field. A few people linked me and the Bush early on amongst the sea of Fontaines guesses (which were understandable, considering how much I love them, like a lot of people pinning me down as ROSALÍA last time!) - Dandy and Scene on the forum, plus Chez off-site on SyncTube (either at a BJSC or '80s listening session, where the topic of Pop Factor came up) - the latter was quite mysterious about his suspicions. I soon thought... hang on... Chez mentioned he was beaten to his first choice and I publicly announced that I had got my first choice, while swept up in the excitement of it all. Had I beaten him to Kate? I probably would've represented a male artist on this occasion if Chez hadn't already sent Bowie to the last edition... so maybe this time I had snatched a potential artist off his list in return thinking especially as our music taste is so similar. Apologies if this was the case! If not then I'm intrigued about your early suspicions.

I had a lot of fun in the previous two editions as the mentor for Addison Rae and Blondie, but it was frustrating to miss out on the live shows on both occasions, 'Diet Pepsi' just 1 point away from advancing and 'Call Me' 3 points away in a year where the '1 act per category rule' had not yet come to fruition. So I was delighted that it was indeed third time lucky for me with Kate Bush! I learnt so much from my previous two experiences that I could apply this time. So, let's dive into strategy...

Round 1: 'Hounds of Love' (free choice)

I could immediately apply a lesson learnt from playing Addison here! I sent 'Aquamarine' for her in round 1 and thought I'd be safe as houses with that banger, but she actually struggled more than anticipated. So I remembered this time that the female category can be seriously competitive and people might want to arrive on a strong note. Indeed this category was once again a bloodbath - who would've predicted Tove Lo out first?! I thought I'd arrive with a fairly strong Kate pick, so not top tier like 'Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)' or 'Wuthering Heights' yet, but also not something too risky. I felt the well regarded 'Hounds of Love' was a happy medium and sonically it is very urgent sounding, so tied in well as an arrival song. This pick did the business for her so I was happy with my round 1 performance!

Round 2: 'The Man With the Child In His Eyes' (free choice)

One element to my strategy that people may, or may not, have noticed was that I wanted to challenge myself by never repeating the same era twice in a row! So I moved from the Hounds of Love album over to Kate's debut, The Kick Inside, this time. I'd survived a strong first round and thought I had a bit more breathing room this time. I selected the lovely 'The Man with the Child In His Eyes' this time, quickly showing off Kate's sonic diversity with a slower pick, plus it was a top 10 hit - so not exactly super risky to me on paper. However, this did struggle a bit more than expected, as I think it was bottom 3! So that was food for thought. But, at the end of the day, I wasn't last - so this had still done enough and I could move forward. It was nice to see some appreciation for this song all the same! One comment that stuck with me was Rollo pointing out that Kate wrote this song when she was just 13 years old, a fact that has always stayed with me too. Very impressive!

Round 3: 'Reaching Out' (should've been a single)

Now I thought I'd test out another Kate era, The Sensual World, a personal favourite for both me and Robert Smith. I remember Chez commenting that he would've liked something from The Ninth Wave section of Hounds of Love for this round, but I was 100% planning to send something from that later on in the contest. Perhaps that would've been a safer move at this point but I was hoping 'Reaching Out' would be enough for round 3 nevertheless. I think Kate sounds incredible on this song and the chorus really stuck with me after I first explored her albums years ago, so thought it would be a viable single, in an alternate universe. However, this is one of those occasions when my personal taste wasn't quite in line with the forum and I came close to leaving, bottom 2 drama I noticed quite a lot of comments about how Kate sounded amazing but that the song itself didn't do much for them. On a positive note, Dandy's comment stuck with me, that after repeated listens he could see how this would've made sense as a single choice. So yeah... I was playing dangerously here in the end but once again had avoided coming last, which was all that mattered at the end of the day. I quickly realised just how competitive this category was and needed to switch things up a bit now!

Round 4: 'Cloudbusting' (free choice)

Kate was losing momentum after a couple of low finishes and people were beginning to write her off. So now felt like time to go bigger again! I thought I'd mine from the classic Hounds of Love singles run once more, like in round 1. 'Cloudbusting' is one of my favourite songs of hers, well regarded and known despite only peaking at #20 and has an extra layer of familiarity thanks to the 'Something Good' dance reworkings by Utah Saints (something that would become relevant later on in the contest...), but wasn't a top tier trump card I'd need later on, so felt like the right level to send at this point. I felt validated when Rich commented that 'Cloudbusting' was the exact song he expected Kate's mentor to send to this round! It worked and Kate felt like a bit more of a contender again; I was happy with this performance. I didn't know at the time that this would make 'Something Good' ineligible for the remix round but at the end of the day, it would've been criminal to not send the original 'Cloudbusting' at any point!

Round 5: 'This Woman's Work' (Six Chair Challenge)

Now I wanted to continue with a strong choice while sticking to my rule of not repeating the same era twice in a row. So it was back to The Sensual World for a much loved Kate song and another personal favourite, what a stunner. I think a few people had recently mentioned how much they liked this song too so it was also on my mind for that reason. It was a shame this didn't get full public attention, due to the powers falling into the hands of our judges this time, but never mind! So yeah, Six Chair Challenge, utter chaos! lol I consider Iz to have quite similar taste to me, but the judge I hoped for most was actually Jaz, just because I noticed him putting Kate top / near the top of his votes quite consistently so far, whereas MARINA appeared to be the act Iz had most loyalty towards. So Jaz seemed like the one who would most likely be in Kate's corner. But Iz was still a great, forensic judge to have and his alt leanings could still work in her favour. I also felt 'This Woman's Work' would probably stand out in a crowd, when trying to assess this logically. I was delighted that Iz saw the magic in this song and it sent Kate through! Although it was of course sad to lose the two women who did end up departing.

Round 6: 'Wuthering Heights' (top 10 most streamed)

My lessons learnt from Blondie were now kicking in at this point. This was: don't be afraid to go BIG when the moment calls for it, as I really kicked myself for not using 'Heart of Glass' at the opportune moment. It wasn't quite time for Gamu yet, like in that situation, so Kate's biggest trump card felt a bit premature. Instead, I wasn't going to be afraid to send her second most loved song and my own personal favourite, as this category was just ridiculously competitive. I thought I just need to get past the females and will have a bit more room to breathe if she makes it to the lives later on. So 'Wuthering Heights' it was. Maybe I could've got away with 'Babooshka' but who knows, I wasn't taking any chances... seems like other mentors had similar ideas as 'Murder On The Dancefloor' and 'With Every Heartbeat' showed up !!! So this wasn't even Kate's chance to win a round, settling for 3rd behind those two juggernauts, but they seemed to be quite a clear cut top 3 with the public. I was a tiny bit worried that Kate's striking vocal performance would be a bit much for some (indeed a couple commented on it) but overall, the strength of this classic came through. The Bush was still fighting.

Round 7: 'Experiment IV' (bottom 10 streamed)

I panicked a bit when I saw this round theme and thought oh gosh, am I going to have to send birdsong, or the one where her and Stephen Fry list different types of snow (even if that is genuinely my favourite from its parent album haha)?! But then, I looked at her list and thought I'd lucked out, when I remembered her Best Of The Other Sides compilation was only uploaded to streaming last year. 'Experiment IV' is genuinely a favourite for me so I was delighted when I realised it was her 9th least streamed, due to how recently it had been uploaded. A single and everything. I remember dropping pretence a tiny bit here to serve #facts when people accused Kate of cheating, which was understandable as she had so much junk on her Kworb list below 'Experiment IV' at a quick glance, but it was mostly just a bunch of remastered duplicates and live versions that needed to be removed. Once that was applied, this indeed qualified for the round. However... this is one of those instances when my own taste does not match up to the general Pop Factor audience; this got some harsh comments even during a private voting round lol this experiment sadly did not work out, a distant last even below a demo (no shade to Zara - just funny that a single wasn't enough to beat a demo!!) - was gutted to have been tripped up on a 'dregs' round, even if with a song I really like. Flashbacks to Ariana being lumbered with 'Beauty and the Beast' in an AF Idol 'flops' round x Still, Kate had her trump card, so I wasn't going to give up on her yet... This round was also a bit of a blessing in disguise (unless Kate had not come back in the end, then boo hiss x) as I probably would've sent 'Experiment IV' to one of the live shows, due to it being a personal favourite. Maybe that wouldn't have been as much of a disaster outside of the competitive female category, but yeah, I didn't have to find out now.

Round 8: 'Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)' (Gamu)

Now it was 100% time for Kate's golden ticket! Upon submission, I was confident this would see her through, as it's so beloved and with a unique level of generational crossover - with those who remember it from the '80s, the 2012 Olympics, plus from Stranger Things. However, I must say I was a little concerned for Kate's chances when an Agnes campaign seemed to be forming in the thread. I wasn't going to play dirty though and submitted honestly as ever, ranking 'Release Me' as high as 3rd (what a banger!) behind my own Kate classic and 'Stan', as I decided not to penalise Dido and just go on song quality. Turns out I didn't need to be worried as Kate was just about the most comfortable winner of the three categories, despite being a person down (Robyn/Dandy much missed </3) in a victorious outcome for retro acts! I felt so bad for Agnes' mentor as they'd had rotten luck with their trajectory so far. But as for Kate, I was so happy she managed to win a round and FINALLY got me a route to the live shows after missing out with both of my previous acts, yay!!

Round 9: 'Babooshka' (Live show 1, free choice)

I wondered if people would go big and use this round as the opportunity for a reset. Many factors were making 'Babooshka', Kate's last big hitter, the one for me. I really didn't want to make it to the live shows for the first time only to go out in round one. I also thought it'd be pretty neat timing for the witchy 'Babooshka' as the round coincided with Halloween. In addition to this, I realised I hadn't sent anything from Never for Ever yet, so would be good to showcase another Kate era, especially as I continued to ban myself from sending something from the same album twice in a row. Finally, I quite liked the idea of a freeing, experimental run once this big hitter was played. So I just thought... let's see how far she can go and I'll continue to send choices I love. 'Babooshka' it was and Kate's live show experience began on a high, including some notable love from members who weren't always her biggest fan. Rob ranking this 2nd comes to mind! Oh and Rob... I always think of that holistic vocal coach woman from X Factor when I hear this song too lol this did the business for Kate and saw her through comfortably. Now it was going to get seriously interesting for my game plan!

Round 10: 'The Big Sky (Meteorological Mix)' (Live show 2, club bangers/remixes)

Kate was the butt of the joke when this round was announced as least likely to have a club banger in her repertoire. However, I actually thought I'd hit the jackpot as I assumed I could send 'Something Good' by Utah Saints (albeit a very cheeky move as a repackaged 'Cloudbusting'), but then the rules of no song repeats were laid out, so it was looking a bit more shaky for Kate! The Meteorological Mix of 'The Big Sky' was by far my favourite other option available for her, but I was concerned it would be too long and left-field (didgeridoo in the club anyone?) to make it through. I think M83's initial exit with a long, unconventional pick was in the back of my mind. But still, I really loved this mix, so thought I'd go with my heart and hope it'd find its fans. It'd certainly stand out anyway! The first rank it received in the thread was a last place, so I quickly began to prepare myself for Kate leaving now. However, her fortunes turned around as some of you really seemed to love this! It was particularly amazing to see Rich ranking Kate 1st for the first time <3 I actually did hope he would be a fan, as someone who often comments on percussion, as the drumming on this song is pretty impactful. This choice was a bit too eccentric to properly dominate or anything but it kept Kate safe for another round, which was all that mattered. What a pleasant surprise!

Round 11: 'Army Dreamers' (Live show 3, free choices)

Pete wondered if the rationale behind sending this was because the round fell at the time of Remembrance Day. The answer to that is... not solely, but it was a contributing factor. I once again wanted to avoid repeating an album and 'The Big Sky' is originally from Hounds of Love, so thought I'd wait a little bit longer to unleash some of my favourite album tracks from that record. I looked to Kate's most streamed for some inspiration from another album and was reminded that 'Army Dreamers' is her 2nd most streamed on Spotify (!!! yes, even above 'Wuthering Heights'), so BuzzJack not quite as fond of it as the TikTok youth tongue in all seriousness, I was surprised by this too, but apparently it had a moment on there a few years ago. I slotted this in as an option. I already thought this song was great but properly fell in love with it upon revisiting it for this contest. The lyrics are indeed hard-hitting, as pointed out by some, plus sonically I thought it would continue to show off Kate's versatility, with its waltz-like execution. On top of this, I love a connecting factor, so the timing of Remembrance Day felt like another sign. I assumed it might struggle, despite the streaming numbers, but hoped it could perhaps scrape through. I was fully expecting to walk into a round of 'Venus', 'Blue Monday', 'Personal Jesus' etc., so had a tiny bit more hope for Kate before any votes came in, as the field was more unpredictable than assumed. When it was time for the results, I was now expecting to be straight out, as Bananarama suddenly got a massive surge on the last day and Fontaines seemed to be hanging in there, so I was shocked when New Order were straight out, as they flew under the radar compared to those three who had attracted the danger zone talk in the thread. I hated being up against Fontaines, as they were my favourite in that round, but did hope I could cling on one more time after finding out what the next round was - SO up artsy Kate's street. Thank you judges for saving her even if it was brutal to lose Fontaines D.C. in the same breath! I'm glad we at least received the exact same amount of points though so I wasn't robbing another act who had genuinely been more popular in the voting.

Round 12: 'Hello Earth' (Live show 4, suave, sophisticated, artistic)

I actually assumed this would be a 'slow dance' type round, as Rich suggested, as a companion piece to club bangers. I had already pencilled in 'Hello Earth' for such a round as this haunting song is my favourite Kate album track. However, instead it was this 'suave, sophisticated, artistic' round, which couldn't suit this musical genius more. I thought I would stick with the 'Hello Earth' pick, as it's from the much acclaimed, highly sophisticated art-rock Ninth Wave part of Hounds of Love, so still felt on theme. Something from Aerial or especially The Dreaming would've been a good fit too, as the latter is such an uncompromising body of work, but by this point I was gagging to send 'Hello Earth', after coming so close to not getting to unleash it at all. I suppose an album track was a bit risky but it was such a striking one to me, so I'm pleased Kate got to leave on a high. I particularly loved to find out just now that it was one of Rob's favourite choices for her!

These were my future choices:

Round 13: 'The Sensual World' - one I felt was a good combination of personal favourite and with appeal for Pop Factor from the options left; I also thought the folky instruments would stand out

Round 14: 'Jig Of Life' - some more folk instruments if that last choice went down well, another really striking album track from Hounds of Love and has a bit of familiarity for BJSC participants who were in the 100th edition

Round 15: 'Suspended in Gaffa' - the in demand 'December Will Be Magic Again' probably would've been a better competitive choice than some of these, but wanted to stay true to myself and unleash my absolute favourites even if I do enjoy that too. The Dreaming is generally Pop Factor poison, but I still wanted to use something from that era and this is my favourite song from the album <3 would it win against 'Someone Like You'? no, but what a tune x

...and I wouldn't have even got into several other Kate albums I also enjoy yet, like Lionheart or Aerial! I did especially consider 'Nocturn' from the latter album as a huge swerve that could've been a good discovery for some. What a discography, I am honoured to have represented Queen Bush, one of my absolute favourite artists. She's of course a marvel and paved the way for many who came after her. Kate's never been afraid to take some pretty wild risks in her time but could also create something with as much universal appeal as 'Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)'. I greatly admire her!

For those who want to do a bit of further listening (or may be curious because who doesn't love lists on BuzzJack x) - these are my top 3 songs from every Kate album:

The Kick Inside: Wuthering Heights, The Man with the Child in His Eyes, Oh to Be in Love

Lionheart: Hammer Horror, Coffee Homeground, In Search of Peter Pan

Never for Ever: Babooshka, Blow Away, Army Dreamers

The Dreaming: Suspended in Gaffa, Sat In Your Lap, Leave It Open

Hounds Of Love: Hello Earth, Cloudbusting, Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)

The Sensual World: This Woman's Work, The Sensual World, The Fog

The Red Shoes: Top Of The City, Lily, Moments Of Pleasure

Aerial: Nocturn, King Of The Mountain, Aerial

50 Words For Snow: 50 Words For Snow, Misty, Lake Tahoe

(I know Director's Cut counts as a studio album too but I view that in a separate way, since it's reworkings)

Here is also a playlist of all my highlights from her (there are a LOT of them lol), in order of preference (minus a couple of backing vocal highlights/Utah Saints remixes that I stuck at the end), that are available on streaming if anyone is interested in some more expansive inspiration. I was fully behind every song I sent, but there's of course a lot more weird and wonderful stuff I love tucked away here too, that didn't necessarily feel suitable for a Pop Factor audience.

Thank you so much Calum for doing a stellar job with this as ever and being a supportive presence in the background. The contest isn't without its moments of drama, which can be a bit much for me at times, but all of the music and passion, in addition to the hard work from our host keep me coming back for more.

Best of luck to all of those still remaining! I can relax now lol x

Amazing write up, I throughly enjoy reading people’s thinking and planning it’s fascinating! ❤️

Well done, you did go up and down in my ratings, I have to be honest, I am a big Kate fan but I also cannot stand some of her stuff too 🤣. Was hoping for hammer horror I love that one and in search of Peter Pan, I must listen to Lionheart again actually!!

 

17 minutes ago, ElectroBoy said:

So who is left in?

Dan, Spiceboy, Lee, Mango....???

Joseph - aka Marina! 😎

Just now, Spiceboy said:

Joseph - aka Marina! 😎

I had Joseph down as SEB

But idk anymore 🤣

Unless Paddington is SEB and Joseph is Marina

Edited by ElectroBoy

3 minutes ago, ElectroBoy said:

I had Joseph down as SEB

But idk anymore 🤣

Unless Paddington is SEB and Joseph is Marina

I keep flipping between him as those two, but he is too quiet, slipping under the radar with the assassin I think! 🤔

Amazing write up Jade, I love hearing what goes on behind the scenes, and glad I could put Kate top once, that such a great find! You played it so well throughout.

Jack I figured only recently was Sam, but what amazing play. Showing us that outside their dreary ballads (none of which were played, only the good ones), is a fantastic artist who I ranked in my top three way more times than I’d have ever expected to. Sad we didn’t get Latch but completely get holding on to it in case you made it to the end. Well done Jack!

Dan - Depeche Mode

Paddington - Sophie

Lee - Darin

Mango - Bananarama

Spiceboy - Adele

Joseph - Marina

Still not worked out who has Sam Fender, Elgornio? Or they could have Marina but I doubt Joseph has Sam.

Edited by gooddelta

2 minutes ago, Spiceboy said:

I keep flipping between him as those two, but he is too quiet, slipping under the radar with the assassin I think! 🤔

Executive Producer Joseph slipping under the radar to his 3rd final 🤣

2 minutes ago, gooddelta said:

Dan - Depeche Mode

Paddington - Sophie

Lee - Darin

Mango - Bananarama

Spiceboy - Adele

Joseph - Marina

Still not worked out who has Sam Fender, Elgornio? Or they could have Marina but I doubt Joseph has Sam.

That’s a good shout. starts Adele campaign 🤭 DON’T YOU REMEMBEEEEER!

5 minutes ago, Spiceboy said:

That’s a good shout. starts Adele campaign 🤭 DON’T YOU REMEMBEEEEER!

If you are not her then don’t rein me in because I have NOTHING for Mr F.

1 minute ago, gooddelta said:

If you are not her then don’t rein me in because I have NOTHING for Mr F.

👀

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.