Wednesday at 23:141 day Congratulations @Jack & @Jade on making it this far. You both made the top 10 and reached a personal best!! Well done!!@Jack Sam Smith was such a great choice and you did a fantastic job with them. I'm Not The Only One and Like I Can are my two favourite songs from Sam so I was so happy that both of them got there moment in this competition. I kind of went off Sam after their first album but it was really nice to discover some new songs and be remined of some that I do like.@Jade You played Kate Bush fantastically. I'll admit I didn't think I knew anything outside of Wuthering Heights or Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God), but I was pleasantly surprised when I recognised Babooshka. That along with Army Dreamers were my favourite discoveries from Kate Bush.
Wednesday at 23:501 day Well done to the two eliminated on getting this far! I had forgotten how many Sam Smith songs I like, and those 3 you would have played next @Jack are great choices. Glad to have had what I consider the two highlights from the debut played - I do also like Sam's solo version of 'Lay Me Down' (but not the John Legend version), and 'To Die For', but can see they would have been risky choices as ballads.@Jade I remember in the last rate of Buzzjack's favourite female artist that we shared the same top 2 of Lana 1st and Kate 2nd (as well as Amy in 5th!) However in my case, I'd have to say that I wasn't too familiar with her discography outside of the singles, so I'd probably rated her so highly more from a pioneering point of view. Therefore it's been great to hear a few lesser known songs from her canon, and you've showcased her hits really well too with so many of her albums represented. (I did think maybe you were a little hard done by in that no one was eliminated after the round where you played 'Wuthering Heights', as following Robyn's withdrawal the remaining 4 women could maybe have been given a bye in the next round in which Kate was eliminated, rather than reintroduce Zara straight away.) I'm delighted Kate came straight back in the Gamu round though, and it was heartwarming to see big support for 'Running Up That Hill (A Deal With God)', even if it meant you couldn't save it for later - it would have been a shame not to have it played at all!
Wednesday at 23:581 day These were my votes for the round just gone:1 Darin - En säng av rosor2 Adele - Turning Tables3 Sam Fender - Little Bit Closer4 MARINA - I'm a Ruin5 Kate Bush - Hello Earth6 Depeche Mode - Policy of Truth7 Bananarama - Move in My Direction8 Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Today the Sun's on Us9 Sam Smith - NirvanaThe Darin song was so unexpected it floored me a little. Adele sounds marvellous on every track on 21, 'Little Bit Closer' hadn't really clicked with me before, but outside the context of the album it sounded great here, likewise 'I'm A Ruin' which I now realise MARINA means "I will ruin (you)" rather than being one herself which is a clever turn of phrase. It was really tough to rank the Kate and DM songs against these newer songs, although I like both, in fact all 9 songs were decent and didn't deserve to be the end for anyone.
23 hours ago23 hr 01. A great song that I find a bit underrated for this artist tbh! MARINA02. Gorgeous song. One of my favourites by this artist. Adele03. Think I've heard this maybe once before but I should listen more! Sophie Ellis-Bextor04. A beautiful song. Nice change of pace for this artist. Darin05. I really don't get on very well with their vocals, but I did like this. Sam Smith06. Not a favourite of mine by this artist, but it really is nice! Sam Fender07. Bop tbh. Bananarama08. Didn't hate this as much as people would probably expect me to! Kate Bush09. Yawn. More of the same imo. This artist is unfortunately just not doing anything for me. It's a taste thing ofc! Please don't take this comment to heart! Depeche ModeJack and Jade you both did incredibly well with your artists. Sam Smith is an artist who is hit & miss for me but thankfully more of the hits were played! So great job on that. I KNEW 'Dancing With A Stranger' was coming up and I'm so annoyed now </3 Depeche Mode just don't do it for me, personally. Sorry Jade ☹️ But incredibly well played by yourself.
22 hours ago22 hr 1 Adele - Turning Tables2 Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Today the Sun's on Us3 MARINA - I'm a Ruin4 Sam Fender - Little Bit Closer5 Depeche Mode - Policy of Truth6 Kate Bush - Hello Earth7 Darin - En säng av rosor8 Sam Smith - Nirvana9 Bananarama - Move in My Direction
17 hours ago17 hr 01 loved it on first listen and it's never got old for me despite the heavy overplay (from me) since its release! So pleased their mentor played this. I'll be speechless if this doesn't get the act through to the semi. MARINA02 incredible song. A standout from its album and a faultless choice at this stage imo. ADELE03 another great song from this act - they're so consistently on-point I can't help but stan. DARIN04 another act I find to be consistently strong albeit this song didn't hit quite as hard as their previous choices. SAM FENDER05 one of my absolute fave picks from this act to date! (which may or may not say much ) I thought they may struggle with this theme but actually brought a hit! BANANARAMA06 this was a really good discovery - sixth seems a bit cruel. DEPECHE MODE07 oops this doesn't deserve to be so low but there's just a bit more oomph to the ones above imo. SOPHIE ELLIS-BEXTOR08 can't deny the nailing of the theme but I just wouldn't listen to this again by choice. KATE BUSH09 this act has been very hit-and-miss for me in this contest and sadly it's more miss this time. SAM SMITH
16 hours ago16 hr Well done Jack - you guided Sam really well. I thought you might be Marina gah, but still think that’s your first top 10 result in this.And Jade - you played Kate so beautifully. Of course I did consider her but I was very keen to not seem greedy post ABBA this series and I’d have struggled to play her as well. Poor “Mrs Bartolozzi” not being among your favourites though and generally being shunned in Bop Idol: I find the imagery on that absolutely stunning. ❤️ I knew it would mean a lot to you to get to the lives for the first time so I’m thrilled that you did it and went quite a lot further. x
16 hours ago16 hr Fairly sure at this point that it’s:Marina - ElgornioSophie Ellis Bextor - JosephBananarama - SpiceboySam Fender - MangoAdele - PaddingtonDepeche Mode - DanGDarin - LeeJBig congrats to Jack and Jade for getting this far. Definitely would never have guessed Jack was behind Sam Smith until the live shows and I definitely suspect it wasn’t his first choice but smart smart choices the whole way through, didn’t really put a foot wrong. And well done Jade, who I also was sure was Fontaines D.C and then probably New Order, so I didn’t settle on Kate Bush until the last two rounds or so. The quality of the females meant she was way lower than she should’ve been in a lot of my rankings but by and large, I’ve enjoyed her.
16 hours ago16 hr 11 minutes ago, RobBot said:Fairly sure at this point that it’s:Marina - ElgornioSophie Ellis Bextor - JosephBananarama - SpiceboySam Fender - MangoAdele - PaddingtonDepeche Mode - DanGDarin - LeeJNot these libellous accusations.Me mentoring a male vocal? Could never be me x
Create an account or sign in to comment