With the success of the ultimate album track game in other artist forums and the green light to do the same, I’m bringing the game into the Taylor forum!

Each round, vote your favourite and least favourite track from each album starting with the first, and then the second, and so on to determine the best and worst picks from each album on average of the votes the tracks receive.

12 albums into her career, the variety is very strong, which will make for a big but fun challenge!

I’ll keep each thread open for 4 days, so the first round I’ll keep up until Sunday. Have fun!

Edited October 4Oct 4 by Doug

That was a toughy all are strong choice except 2

Went with my gut

Favourite - the fate of ophelia

Worst - state of grace

Favorite - ...ready for it

Least favorite - State of Grace

Best: Ready For It (very special mentions to State Of Grace, Welcome To New York, Willow and The Fate Of Ophelia though! This really has started off strong!)

Worst: Tim McGraw

Best: Ready For It

(Special Mention: Mine)

Worst: Fortnight

1 Lavender Haze 10/10

2 Mine 10/10

3 Ready For It 9.5/10

4 Fearless 9/10

5 Welcome To New York 8.5/10

6 I Forgot That You Existed 8/10

7 Willow 7.5/10

8 State Of Grace 4/10

9 The 1 3.5/10

10 The Fate of Ophelia 2.5/10

11 Tim Mcgraw 2/10

12 Fortnight 1/10

The top 2 were tough to choose between.

Favourite: Fortnight

Least Favourite: I Forgot That You Existed

The State of Grace votes in Least Fave is absurd!!!! Omg!

Have some shame!!!! 😭

Ooh this is going to be fun!

Favourite: I initially picked Ready For It but switched to Willow. Both are amazing though so I wish I could've voted for both :')

Least: Tim McGraw

glad I'm not quite the only one who adores State Of Grace here 😭 - putting it as the worst is shameful!! Mine cuts it fine tho and both Welcome To New York and Lavender Haze are great too!

I Forgot That You Existed should be running away with the worst track here though

Edited October 1Oct 1 by maggotsforbrains

Favourite: the stunning 'willow'

Least favourite: the grating 'I Forgot That You Existed', my least favourite on Lover

I've never actually listened to her debut album before. I was waiting for the 'Taylor's Version' but it looks like we may never get that so this will be a good excuse to give it a spin.

I've heard of all her other albums but I'm a lot less familiar with her pre-1989 albums so I'd expect a lot of my least favourites are going to come from those first 4 albums. And unfortunately that's the case this time where Tim McGraw is my least favourite.

My favourite is the 1. I'm not as huge on folklore as most but it's opener has always been my favourite from the record.

This will be so fun! Definitely going to be tough! I went with:

Favorite: The 1 with shoutouts to Ready for it.. and willow

Least Favorite: Welcome to New York as it never really did anything for me

Very close between faves as I thought it would be! There’s a tie between Ready For It and The 1 that needs breaking - if it’s not broken by tomorrow I’ll set up a separate tiebreak poll.