Jump to content

Featured Replies

3 minutes ago, Colm said:

Ok. We'll all try to post less.

You do what you want bro, and I'll do what I want which is read every post 😁 (after putting it off for some time ofc)

  • Replies 449
  • Views 11.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • THE LIFE OF A DNQ

  • The mundane images being used for the DNQ’s are sending me west. What do you mean Brer & Silas are a silver handle and a piece of toast?!

  • To those of you who stayed with me for this long: thank you! I apologize for the late night show. I can only hope that you enjoyed it, regardless of your result. And I promise I'll try to be even

Posted Images

As the one who started this impromptu discussion on the rationale for the tiebreak situation, I feel I have a responsibility to say the contest does not need any drastic changes. So thank you Wardy for your suggestion, but I don't see it as a solution to a problem raised here. All I'm suggesting is one small change to how tiebreaks are decided.

I agree with Patrick that consistency between the semis and the final would reduce the potential confusion for hosts. Also (and I'm aware that this may be of little interest to those who only participate in BJSC), consistency with other song contests on Buzzjack, which use the same 10-vote, 12 to 1 system as the BJSC semis, but where all tiebreaks are settled by most votes first before 12s and 10s come into consideration. It's an ongoing source of frustration for hosts to present a "final scoreboard" in these contests that they later need to amend to resolve and reverse ties, usually higher up the scoreboard than 20th/21st (and I say this as someone who has lost a tiebreak for 1st/2nd in one such contest where I had received more 12s), when they had expected all contests to use the same system as BJSC.

The rules can't be changed once the contest starts, so unfortunately Cor Lupus have to be eliminated in 21st in this occasion. Ironically, Cody benefitted from the opposite tiebreak situation in the final of BJSC 171 with ALT BLK ERA winning against Skall's Blanck Mass in a tiebreak due to having more votes, so it is very much swings and roundabouts in the bigger scheme of things. It's just food for thought for future contests, whether for BJSC 191 or perhaps BJSC 201 onwards.

Anyhow I've almost certainly said enough on this for now. Thank you Freeze and mods in the running of the current contest.

Just on the wrong semi syndrome, any views on keeping semi voting compulsory for the semi you’re in, but also making it optional for the opposite semi?

(I’m aware it’s swings and roundabouts again as we possibly suffered from wrong semi syndrome this time but had the perfect semi for our 189 entry. Just thinking this might even out the bumps in fortune if you’re from a country who tends to send relatively niche stuff.)

1 hour ago, blacksquare said:

I think Klumzee said it best, and annoying as a tiebreak is, it's something we're all likely to deal with at some point

Unless you are Botanikka x

57 minutes ago, matto said:

You do what you want bro

My new favourite matto quote.

i participated some editions in another contest where they do wildcards for picking a song out of the two that finished 1 position below the last qualifier and ended coming top 6 in the grand final kink so the information being given away that the song almost qualified kinda created a boost which i think might be unfair 👀 but then i also see somewhere else doing wildcards as well and the results don't impact as much though they never come last so i'm not sure how they are revealed or if they are just announced qualifier just like the rest 🤷

My rankings of the SF2 DNQ's btw:

+12 | QUALIFIED
+10 | QUALIFIED
+08 | QUALIFIED
+07 | QUALIFIED
+06 | QUALIFIED
+05 |
Kylienips | Anais Vacariu - Eat My Heart Out
+04 |
Lentyll | Au/Ra - CRACK!
+03 | QUALIFIED
+02 |
Dalisska | Hallan - Solomon
+01 | QUALIFIED

_14 |
Cor Lupus | Maisi and the Disco - Madonna
_20 |
Vaskla | Matilda Mann - The Fig Tree
_22 |
FARC | Mckayla Twiggs - What A Girl Wants
_23 |
Thelonia | Monic - Why Did You Leave
_24 |
Wholune | Pauline Murray and The Invisible Girls - Dream Sequence 1
_28 |
New Helvetica | Gaelynn Lea - Someday We’ll Linger in the Sun
_30 |
Republic of Adonia | B0YG1RL - MOND LAN FINI
_31 |
Scotland 2 | Lily Chou-Chou - Arabesque
_32 |
Beaverdonia | TR3N TEN - Bomboclat Wallahi

So I really wouldn't have been much help either way too any of these!

35 minutes ago, Addy! said:

What did I do?

You never flop [/compliment]

52 minutes ago, pavi said:

You never flop [/compliment]

Thank you, but it’s worth mentioning that I have my share of flops and DNQs!

Especially during BJSC 40-100 era lol.

I have 45 DNQ’s under my belt!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 1