Jump to content

Featured Replies

1 hour ago, AllStarBySmashMouth said:

I figured such craziness would happen after revealing the points of the 20th placer in semi 2. 🫣

I am taking some responsibility for that painful miss for Cor Lupus, similarly for Aeroche last contest.

THIS VERY MUCH SO!

  • Replies 449
  • Views 11.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • THE LIFE OF A DNQ

  • The mundane images being used for the DNQ’s are sending me west. What do you mean Brer & Silas are a silver handle and a piece of toast?!

  • To those of you who stayed with me for this long: thank you! I apologize for the late night show. I can only hope that you enjoyed it, regardless of your result. And I promise I'll try to be even

Posted Images

I think there’s definitely weight to both arguments - I wasn’t there when the rule was put into place but I’m kinda of the opinion that because there’s no particular right way, that there’s no particular need to change it either.

I guess the logic is just that having a final with the songs people are most passionate about makes for a better experience but both sides of the coin have merit.

1 hour ago, pavi said:

I guess the logic is just that having a final with the songs people are most passionate about makes for a better experience but both sides of the coin have merit.

I'm leaning towards this now but it stings if you're getting 7s and 8s and not 1s and 2s.

What about some kind of "flash poll" to save one song from each semi from the DNQ's from disaster and redeem it to the final. This would be before the total points and scores are revealed of course to remove the need to rank rejected songs, but then it gives everyone (potentially from both semis to be fairer) the chance to save one song only which they feel is deserving to be in the final with the rest. I know people would argue it would take longer but what's a 24 hour poll if it means getting the right outcome at the end, and it adds to the suspense and intrigue of the semi final results.

1 minute ago, awardinary said:

What about some kind of "flash poll" to save one song from each semi from the DNQ's from disaster and redeem it to the final. This would be before the total points and scores are revealed of course to remove the need to rank rejected songs, but then it gives everyone (potentially from both semis to be fairer) the chance to save one song only which they feel is deserving to be in the final with the rest. I know people would argue it would take longer but what's a 24 hour poll if it means getting the right outcome at the end, and it adds to the suspense and intrigue of the semi final results.

What is the “right outcome” though, because I doubt you’d get every single participant to vote and hosting is challenging enough without introducing another added factor to consider.

I love hearing people’s ideas though so if I don’t necessarily agree, please don’t take that as me just rejecting your right to offer alternatives routes. I just recognise that BJSC works best in its simplicity and the route we have currently (confirmations -> two semis -> one final) allows hosting to be as simple and easy to understand as it possibly can be without having too many variables to throw into the mix.

7 minutes ago, awardinary said:

What about some kind of "flash poll" to save one song from each semi from the DNQ's from disaster and redeem it to the final. This would be before the total points and scores are revealed of course to remove the need to rank rejected songs, but then it gives everyone (potentially from both semis to be fairer) the chance to save one song only which they feel is deserving to be in the final with the rest. I know people would argue it would take longer but what's a 24 hour poll if it means getting the right outcome at the end, and it adds to the suspense and intrigue of the semi final results.


I think the most important thing is keeping it as simple as possible for hosts, with as little variables as possible. It's already a huge commitment and something like this sounds cool in theory but is just another headache for the person organising it

13 minutes ago, blacksquare said:


I think the most important thing is keeping it as simple as possible for hosts, with as little variables as possible. It's already a huge commitment and something like this sounds cool in theory but is just another headache for the person organising it

Yes all valid points too.

14 minutes ago, blacksquare said:


I think the most important thing is keeping it as simple as possible for hosts, with as little variables as possible. It's already a huge commitment and something like this sounds cool in theory but is just another headache for the person organising it

i-restored-in-hd-4k-the-original-spider-

I call upon @Calum to invent us the official BJSC Adjudicator as the digital bot who takes away the responsibility from the host and collates the votes (using a Google form or something similar) and after 24 hours the results are revealed and the host doesn't have to do anything but watch the drama unfold! Once the result of the 24 poll are revealed then the finals go up as normal.

It's all hear'say anyway, I'm not seriously expecting this to happen, just putting the idea out there.

I’d agree we don’t want to over complicate things. The results of the semi voting should be the ‘correct’ result.

I don’t particularly mind which way the ties are broken in all honesty! The likelihood is that you will benefit from it in one contest as well as fall victim to losing a tie in another contest so it all balances out.

Only thing I’d suggest is applying the same rule to the semis and the final regarding tiebreaks so it is easier for us all to remember and doesn’t result in the host accidentally getting it wrong and putting another country through. But either way I’m not too bothered about which way the tiebreaks are decided as there’s not one obvious right way to do it.

A flash poll would probably always result in an alt fave going through because the alt crowd and listenthrough attendees (I know some are pop) are, on the whole, more likely to participate in 'extra curricular' stuff, which is why the old The Best Of/TBO at the end of the year always skewed more alt than pop.

Based on recent discussion I will happily graciously accept a retrospective Q for all of my six semifinal 21st place (and one 20th place cause smaller contest) entries that didn't quite make it; I fully expect those finals to be re-run by the original hosts of course. x

😮

(20) (1) - BJSC 121 // "Blueless Bird" - Joni

(21) (6) - BJSC 86 // "Above The Clouds Of Pompeii" - Bear's Den | BJSC 99 // "Slow Days" - Sœur | BJSC 113 // "Savages" - Savoir Adore | BJSC 143 // "Pins" - Fever Fever | BJSC 147 // "Shadowplay" - GOOSE | BJSC 166 // "Life In Vain" - Daniel Johnston

All the same, everyone has the opportunity to cast their vote in a flash poll and if they don't or if they miss it then they know the consequences that would mean the higher chance of something making it that they may not have been a fan of.

It might make no difference at all and the intent is not to complicate things as people keep suggesting. If every new idea was described as a complicated one we would never embrace any changes at all. Times do change and so do voting habits as evidenced by the sheer disappointments of missing out because of 'wrong semi syndrome' etc. Having a bot do the legwork of calculating scores takes that extra work away from a host so not making it harder to do.

Wrong semi syndrome will always have happened though, that’s not a change of the time. People will have fallen victim to it since it was introduced in like 2009.

I’m also kinda not a fan of anything that gives away how any country has done in the semis - there’d be one entry in the final that we knew hadn’t qualified initially but got a strong enough support to be voted through as a wildcard, competing against 41/42 songs that could’ve finished anywhere between 1st and 20th in the final, which also creates an imbalance.

Omg too much to read again (after the results have already concluded). I was hoping to just read my book today... Oh well, this is what I signed up for and I ain't a skipper of posts in these threads so I'll read a bit later xo

3 minutes ago, awardinary said:

All the same, everyone has the opportunity to cast their vote in a flash poll and if they don't or if they miss it then they know the consequences that would mean the higher chance of something making it that they may not have been a fan of.

It might make no difference at all and the intent is not to complicate things as people keep suggesting. If every new idea was described as a complicated one we would never embrace any changes at all. Times do change and so do voting habits as evidenced by the sheer disappointments of missing out because of 'wrong semi syndrome' etc. Having a bot do the legwork of calculating scores takes that extra work away from a host so not making it harder to do.


I think every change or idea should be judged on what it fixes against what it costs, and to me a poll looks like a big change for a small effect.

I just wonder what it adds. The songs that miss the line often miss by only a point or two, so the poll would mostly pick between near-ties, and with one vote each a handful of the more engaged BJSC dwellers (alt bloc) could decide it. Also, not everyone will have listened to both semis. You're also highlighting a song in a final that didn't Q, so it's a strange imbalance potentially

25 minutes ago, Klumzee said:

The likelihood is that you will benefit from it in one contest as well as fall victim to losing a tie in another contest so it all balances out.

I think Klumzee said it best, and annoying as a tiebreak is, it's something we're all likely to deal with at some point

3 minutes ago, matto said:

Omg too much to read again (after the results have already concluded). I was hoping to just read my book today... Oh well, this is what I signed up for and I ain't a skipper of posts in these threads so I'll read a bit later xo

You are not compelled to read every single post! D

6 minutes ago, RobBot said:

Wrong semi syndrome will always have happened though, that’s not a change of the time. People will have fallen victim to it since it was introduced in like 2009.

I’m also kinda not a fan of anything that gives away how any country has done in the semis - there’d be one entry in the final that we knew hadn’t qualified initially but got a strong enough support to be voted through as a wildcard, competing against 41/42 songs that could’ve finished anywhere between 1st and 20th in the final, which also creates an imbalance.


4 minutes ago, blacksquare said:

You're also highlighting a song in a final that didn't Q, so it's a strange imbalance potentially


I should just wait and see what you post before I reply in future

bratcheeseblock

Just now, matto said:

Yes I am

Ok. We'll all try to post less.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 1